Buckling of Ship Plating and Stiffeners
Buckling of ship plate panels and stiffeners under hull girder compression and shear: the modes, the UR S11.5 checks, tripping, CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 and UR S35.
Contents16 sections
Buckling is the loss of stability of a plate panel or a stiffener under compressive or shear stress, often at a stress below yield. In a ship’s hull it limits the deck when the hull girder sags and the bottom when it hogs. IACS UR S11 Rev.10 (December 2020), S11.5, gives the buckling check for panels and longitudinals under hull girder stress. It covers ships of 90 m and over outside the CSR and UR S11A.
The hull girder carries its bending moment as stress in the deck and the bottom. The section modulus gives that stress, and buckling decides whether the compressed members can carry it. This article covers the buckling modes, the UR S11.5 formulas and the CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 method. It also covers UR S35 for hatch covers and the fabrication tolerances.
Buckling in a ship’s hull
A compressed plate or stiffener buckles when it deflects out of its plane and stops carrying its share of the load. A thin panel can buckle elastically at a fraction of the yield stress. A thick one yields first.
Where the hull is compressed
The hull girder puts the deck in compression when the ship sags and the bottom in compression when it hogs. UR S11.5.4.1 states the rule for the check: the sagging moment for members above the neutral axis, the hogging moment for those below it. The side shell and the longitudinal bulkheads carry the vertical shear force, so shear buckling is checked there. Hatch covers, girders and corrugated bulkheads buckle under their own local loads.
UR S11.5.1 states that its requirements “apply to plate panels and longitudinals subject to hull girder bending and shear stresses”. UR S11.3.2 adds that buckling strength is checked “in particular in regions where changes in the framing system or significant changes in the hull cross-section occur”.
The modes
A plate panel between stiffeners buckles in a pattern set by its load. Figure 1 shows the two basic plate cases.
The plate cases and the stiffener cases are:
| Member | Mode | UR S11 clause |
|---|---|---|
| Plate panel | Compression in the direction of the longitudinals | S11.5.2.1.1 |
| Plate panel | Compression across transverse stiffening | S11.5.2.1.1 |
| Plate panel | Shear | S11.5.2.1.2 |
| Longitudinal | Column buckling without rotation of the section | S11.5.2.2.1 |
| Longitudinal | Torsional buckling (tripping) | S11.5.2.2.2 |
| Longitudinal | Web and flange buckling | S11.5.2.2.3 |
Plate buckling under IACS UR S11.5
IACS UR S11.5.2.1.1 gives the elastic buckling stress of a plate panel as σE = 0.9 m E (tb/(1000 s))². The stress rises with the square of the thickness and falls with the square of the stiffener spacing.
Elastic buckling stress of plating
where
| \(\sigma_{E}\) | elastic buckling stress of the plate panel | N/mm² |
| \(m\) | buckling factor; a transversely stiffened panel uses m = c [1 + (s/ℓ)²]² × 2.1/(ψ + 1.1) | |
| \(t_{b}\) | net plate thickness, after the standard deduction | mm |
| \(s\) | shorter side of the panel, the stiffener spacing | m |
| \(E\) | modulus of elasticity, 2.06 × 10⁵ | N/mm² |
| \(\psi\) | ratio of the smallest to the largest compressive stress across the panel |
The factor m
For plating with longitudinal stiffeners, parallel to the stress, m = 8.4/(ψ + 1.1). The stress ratio ψ is the ratio of the smallest to the largest compressive stress across the panel, from 0 to 1. Uniform compression gives m = 4.0. A stress that falls to zero at one edge gives m = 7.6.
For plating with transverse stiffeners, perpendicular to the stress, UR S11.5.2.1.1 sets m = c [1 + (s/ℓ)²]² × 2.1/(ψ + 1.1). The factor c depends on the stiffener at the panel edge:
| Edge stiffening | c |
|---|---|
| Floors or deep girders | 1.30 |
| Angles or T-sections | 1.21 |
| Bulb flats | 1.10 |
| Flat bars | 1.05 |
Take a transversely stiffened panel with angle stiffeners and s/ℓ of 0.2. In uniform compression its m is about 1.31, against 4.0 for longitudinal framing.
Worked example: transverse stiffening
Take a 12 mm net plate at 0.8 m spacing in mild steel, with transverse angle stiffeners and a panel 4.0 m long. The factor is m = 1.21 × (1 + 0.2²)² × 2.1/2.1 = 1.309. The elastic buckling stress is 0.9 × 1.309 × 206,000 × (12/800)² = 54.6 N/mm².
The value 54.6 N/mm² is below σF/2, so the critical stress is also 54.6 N/mm². The same plate with longitudinal stiffening, in the worked example below, has a critical stress of 152.3 N/mm², nearly three times as much.
Net thickness and the standard deductions
UR S11.5.2 uses the net thickness tb, the as-built thickness less a standard deduction. The deduction depends on the exposure of the plate:
| Exposure, UR S11.5.2 | Deduction | Limits |
|---|---|---|
| Dry bulk compartments; one side exposed to ballast or liquid, vertical or sloped more than 25° | 0.05 t | 0.5 to 1 mm |
| One side exposed, horizontal or sloped under 25°; two sides exposed, vertical | 0.10 t | 2 to 3 mm |
| Two sides exposed, horizontal or sloped under 25° | 0.15 t | 2 to 4 mm |
The deduction matters because σE varies with tb². A plate that has lost 10% of its thickness has lost about 19% of its elastic buckling stress. The thickness measurement of an ageing ship therefore feeds directly into its buckling margin.
The critical buckling stress
IACS UR S11.5.3.1 uses the elastic buckling stress as the critical stress only up to half the yield stress, and corrects it above that. The correction keeps the critical stress below yield.
Critical buckling stress
where
| \(\sigma_{c}\) | critical buckling stress | N/mm² |
| \(\sigma_{E}\) | elastic buckling stress | N/mm² |
| \(\sigma_{F}\) | minimum upper yield stress; 235 for mild steel | N/mm² |
UR S11 states that “σF may be taken as 235 N/mm2 for mild steel”. For higher tensile steel, σF is the specified minimum yield stress of the grade. Figure 2 draws both stresses against the net thickness for an example plate.
Worked example: a plate between longitudinals
The example plate is longitudinally stiffened at a spacing of 0.8 m, in uniform compression, and made of mild steel. The steps follow UR S11.5.2.1.1 and S11.5.3.1.
- Find m. Uniform compression gives ψ = 1, so m = 8.4/2.1 = 4.0.
- Find σE at 12 mm net. 0.9 × 4.0 × 206,000 × (12/800)² = 166.9 N/mm².
- Compare with σF/2. Half of 235 is 117.5 N/mm², and 166.9 is above it.
- Correct. σc = 235 × (1 − 235/(4 × 166.9)) = 152.3 N/mm².
- Check the margin. Plating needs σc ≥ 1.0 σa, so the working stress can be up to 152.3 N/mm².
At 10 mm the elastic stress is 115.9 N/mm², below σF/2, so the critical stress is the same 115.9 N/mm². The change from elastic to corrected behavior is at 10.07 mm. At 20 mm the critical stress is 205.2 N/mm².
Higher tensile steel and slender plates
The elastic buckling stress does not depend on the steel grade, because E is the same for mild and higher tensile steel. Only the correction above σF/2 uses the yield stress. The 12 mm example plate in AH36 steel, σF 355 N/mm², has σE 166.9 N/mm², below half of 355. The critical stress of the AH36 plate is therefore the elastic 166.9 N/mm², against 152.3 N/mm² in mild steel.
On this plate, a 51% higher yield stress gives a 9.6% higher critical buckling stress. The UR S11 required section modulus is multiplied by k, 0.72 for AH36 under UR S4, but the buckling capacity does not rise in proportion.
Slender and stocky plates under the same load
A slender plate deflects out of its plane far below the yield stress, while a stocky plate stays nearly flat up to its critical stress. Figure 3 shows the example plate of Figure 2 at 10 mm and at 20 mm net thickness, under the same rising compression.
Both plates start with an initial unfairness w0 of 4 mm, the IACS Rec 47 Table 6.10 Standard for shell plating in the parallel part. In small-deflection plate theory, an initial deflection in the buckled shape grows as w = w0/(1 − σ/σE). The deflection therefore depends on how close the applied stress is to σE, not to the yield stress.
The 10 mm plate has σE 115.9 N/mm², below σF/2, so UR S11.5.3.1 takes its critical stress as σE. At 104.3 N/mm², 0.9 σE, the deflection of the 10 mm plate is 40 mm. A 40 mm deflection is ten times w0 and four times the plate thickness.
The 20 mm plate has σE 463.5 N/mm², so its critical stress is corrected to 205.2 N/mm². At that stress its deflection is only 7.2 mm, 1.8 times w0. Yield, not elastic buckling, sets its limit.
The small-deflection relation has no limit at σE, and a real slender plate does not collapse there. The CSR method uses the elastic post-buckling strength of plates, as the CSR section below explains. The large deflection of the slender plate remains, and a deck or bottom plate in that state carries less in-plane stiffness.
Shear buckling of plating and webs
IACS UR S11.5.2.1.2 gives the elastic shear buckling stress as τE = 0.9 kt E (tb/(1000 s))², with kt = 5.34 + 4 (s/ℓ)². The side shell and the longitudinal bulkheads carry the hull girder shear force, so this check, with UR S11.4 at 110/k, sets their thickness. The shear flow section of the section modulus article sets out how the force is shared.
Shear buckling of plating
where
| \(\tau_{E}\) | elastic shear buckling stress | N/mm² |
| \(k_{t}\) | shear buckling factor | |
| \(\tau_{F}\) | shear yield stress | N/mm² |
| \(\tau_{c}\) | critical shear buckling stress | N/mm² |
| \(s, \ell\) | shorter and longer sides of the panel | m |
The factor kt is 9.34 for a square panel and falls toward 5.34 as the panel gets longer. A long, narrow panel is therefore weaker in shear than a square one of the same thickness. Figure 4, in the next section, shows the effect on a web plate.
UR S11.5.3.2 applies the same correction as for compression, with the shear yield stress τF = σF/√3. For mild steel τF is 135.7 N/mm². Take a 15 mm plate 0.8 m by 4.0 m. The factor kt is 5.50 and τE is 358.5 N/mm². τc is then 135.7 × (1 − 135.7/(4 × 358.5)) = 122.8 N/mm².
Stiffener buckling and tripping
A longitudinal stiffener can buckle as a column, twist about its connection to the plate, or buckle locally in its web or flange. UR S11.5.2.2 gives a check for each mode, and Figure 4 shows them.
Column buckling
UR S11.5.2.2.1 gives the column buckling stress “without rotation of the cross section” as 0.001 E Ia/(A ℓ²). Ia is the moment of inertia of the longitudinal in cm⁴, A its area in cm² and ℓ its span in m. The clause states that “a plate flange equal to the frame spacing may be included” in Ia and A.
Column and local buckling of stiffeners
where
| \(\sigma_{E}\) | column buckling stress, without rotation of the cross section | N/mm² |
| \(I_{a}\) | moment of inertia of the longitudinal with a plate flange up to the frame spacing | cm⁴ |
| \(A\) | cross-sectional area of the longitudinal with its plate flange | cm² |
| \(\ell\) | span of the longitudinal | m |
| \(\sigma_{E,web}\) | elastic buckling stress of the web | N/mm² |
| \(t_{w}, h_{w}\) | web thickness and web height | mm |
| \(b_{f}, t_{f}\) | flange width (half the width for a T-section) and as-built flange thickness | mm |
Worked example: a longitudinal as a column
The example longitudinal is a T-bar with a 300 × 11 mm web and a 100 × 16 mm flange. It sits on 14 mm net plating at 0.8 m spacing and spans 3.2 m between web frames. The steps follow UR S11.5.2.2.1.
- Find A with the plate flange. 112.0 + 33.0 + 16.0 = 161.0 cm².
- Find the neutral axis of the combined section: 7.05 cm above the bottom of the plate.
- Find Ia about that axis: 20,018 cm⁴.
- Find σE. 0.001 × 206,000 × 20,018/(161.0 × 3.2²) = 2,501 N/mm².
- Correct for AH36 steel, σF 355 N/mm². σc = 355 × (1 − 355/(4 × 2,501)) = 342.4 N/mm².
- Apply β = 1.1. The working stress can be up to 342.4/1.1 = 311.3 N/mm².
A stocky longitudinal like this one is limited by yield, not by column buckling. The web buckling stress, 3.8 × 206,000 × (11/300)², is 1,052 N/mm², and the flange ratio bf/tf is 50/16 = 3.1, well inside 15. For such a member, the plate between the longitudinals and tripping are the modes left to check.
Torsional buckling: tripping
UR S11.5.2.2.2 gives the torsional buckling stress from the warping constant Iw, the polar moment Ip and the St Venant constant It of the profile. The elastic stress is π² E Iw/(10⁴ Ip ℓ²) (m² + K/m²) + 0.385 E It/Ip. Here m is the number of half-waves and K the spring parameter of the plate. UR S11 gives It, Ip and Iw formulas for flat bars, flanged profiles, Tee sections, angles and bulbs.
The plate resists the twist through a spring stiffness C. C falls as the plate itself approaches buckling, through the factor kp = 1 − σa/σEp, which is not less than zero. “For flanged profiles, kp need not be taken less than 0.1.” A slender plate therefore weakens the stiffener’s resistance to tripping. In the CSR, the torsional span ℓtor is the spacing of primary supporting members or of tripping brackets (Ch 8 Sec 5 [2.3.4]).
The torsional constants
UR S11.5.2.2.2 gives the constants in cm⁴ and cm⁶, with the profile dimensions in mm:
| Constant | Flat bar | Flanged profile |
|---|---|---|
| St Venant, It | hw tw³/3 × 10⁻⁴ | (1/3)[hw tw³ + bf tf³ (1 − 0.63 tf/bf)] × 10⁻⁴ |
| Polar, Ip | hw³ tw/3 × 10⁻⁴ | (hw³ tw/3 + hw² bf tf) × 10⁻⁴ |
| Warping, Iw | hw³ tw³/36 × 10⁻⁶ | tf bf³ hw²/12 × 10⁻⁶ for a Tee |
The warping constant of a flat bar is small. A flat bar therefore trips at a lower stress than a flanged profile of the same area. The number of half-waves m comes from K. The number m is 1 for K up to 4, 2 for K from 4 to 36, and 3 for K from 36 to 144. For bulb profiles, UR S11 accepts the mean thickness of the bulb.
Web and flange buckling
UR S11.5.2.2.3 gives the web buckling stress as 3.8 E (tw/hw)². It limits the flange outstand to bf/tf ≤ 15, with bf the flange width for an angle and half the flange width for a T-section. The flange thickness tf is the as-built value.
The required margin
UR S11.5.5.1 requires the critical stress to meet the working stress with a factor β.
Required buckling margin
where
| \(\sigma_{c}\) | critical buckling stress | N/mm² |
| \(\beta\) | 1.0 for plating and for the web plating of stiffeners; 1.1 for stiffeners | |
| \(\sigma_{a}\) | working compressive stress from the hull girder moment, not less than 30/k | N/mm² |
| \(\tau_{c}, \tau_{a}\) | critical and working shear stresses | N/mm² |
β is 1.0 for plating and for the web plating of stiffeners, and 1.1 for stiffeners. The working stress comes from UR S11.5.4.1, as (Ms + Mw)/In × y × 10⁵, and is not less than 30/k N/mm². UR S11.5.4.1 adds: “Where the ship is always in hogging condition in still water, the sagging bending moment (Ms + Mw) is to be specially considered.”
Shear in a web plate
Figure 5 shows how the panel length changes the shear buckling of a 7 mm example web plate 0.8 m deep.
A square panel has kt 9.34 and a critical shear stress of 101.0 N/mm². A panel 4.0 m long has kt 5.50 and 76.7 N/mm². Web stiffeners that shorten the panel raise its shear capacity.
The CSR buckling method
CSR BC&OT (1 July 2025) Pt 1 Ch 8 checks buckling as a buckling capacity against an allowable utilization factor. The capacity is a lower bound estimate of the ultimate capacity. It applies to bulk carriers and double hull oil tankers built to the IACS Common Structural Rules.
Structure of Ch 8
Ch 8 has five sections and an appendix:
- Sec 1 General: application, net thickness and the utilization factor
- Sec 2 Slenderness requirements for plates, stiffeners and primary members
- Sec 3 Prescriptive buckling requirements, for the hull girder and local members
- Sec 4 Buckling requirements for direct strength analysis
- Sec 5 Buckling capacity: plates, stiffeners and other elements
- App 1 Stress based reference stresses
Sec 1 [1.1.3] takes the net scantling “obtained by removing tc from the gross offered thickness”. That is a larger deduction than the 0.5 tc the CSR uses for the hull girder section properties.
Buckling capacity and post-buckling strength
Sec 1 [3.1.2] states that the buckling capacity “gives a lower bound estimate of ultimate capacity” and that it “utilises the positive elastic post-buckling effect for plates”. A slender plate can carry more than its elastic buckling stress, through load redistribution between the plating and the stiffeners.
The same paragraph warns that “accepting elastic buckling of structural components in slender stiffened panels implies that large elastic deflections and reduced in-plane stiffness will occur at higher buckling utilization levels”. Sec 1 [3.1.3] defines two methods. Method A applies where the panel edges are forced to remain straight, and Method B where they are not.
The plate reduction factor
Sec 5 [2.2.3] gives the plate capacity as σ’cx = Cx ReH for compression along the panel. Table 3, case 1, sets Cx from the slenderness λ.
CSR plate reduction factor
where
| \(C_{x}\) | reduction factor on the yield stress for compression along the panel | |
| \(\lambda\) | reference slenderness, the square root of ReH/(K σE) | |
| \(c\) | factor depending on the stress ratio ψ | |
| \(\psi\) | edge stress ratio, 1 ≥ ψ ≥ 0 for this case |
For uniform compression, c is 1.13 and λc about 0.83. Figure 6 compares the CSR factor with the UR S11 curve for the same slenderness.
The CSR curve reaches 1.0 below λc 0.83, where UR S11 gives 0.83, and falls more slowly above it. That is the post-buckling strength the CSR accepts. The two curves are not directly interchangeable. The CSR takes the applied hull girder stress from properties at 0.5 tc. It takes the capacity at the full tc (Ch 3 Sec 2, Table 1), with its own load combinations.
Slenderness requirements
Sec 2 sets minimum proportions before any load is applied. The plate card gives the plate rule.
Minimum plate thickness for slenderness
where
| \(t_{p}\) | net plate thickness | mm |
| \(C\) | 100 for the hull envelope and cargo and tank boundaries; 125 for other structures | |
| \(R_{eH}\) | specified minimum yield stress of the plate | N/mm² |
| \(b\) | breadth of the plate panel, the stiffener spacing | mm |
For stiffeners, Sec 2 [3.1.1] requires tw ≥ (hw/Cw) √(ReH/235) and a flange thickness from Cf. Cw is 75 for angles and T-bars, 45 for bulb profiles and 22 for flat bars, and Cf is 12 for angles and T-bars. Sec 2 [3.1.2] requires a flange breadth of at least 0.2 hw. Sec 2 [3.1.3] sets a minimum moment of inertia for the stiffener with its plating.
Plate capacity in detail
CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 Sec 5 [2.2.1] checks a plate against an interaction formula for combined σx, σy and τ. The formula has an exponent e0 and a coefficient B, both from Table 1. Where both stresses are compressive, B = 0.7 − 0.3 βp/α² and e0 = 2/βp^0.25.
βp is the plate slenderness parameter (b/tp) √(ReH/E). The reference slenderness is λ = √(ReH/(K σE)), with σE = π² E/(12(1 − ν²)) (tp/b)² from [2.2.2]. K is the buckling factor of Table 3 for the stress ratio ψ.
For compression along the panel, Table 3 gives K for three ranges of ψ:
- 1 ≥ ψ ≥ 0: Kx = Flong × 8.4/(ψ + 1.1)
- 0 > ψ > −1: Kx = Flong × [7.63 − ψ (6.26 − 10 ψ)]
- ψ ≤ −1: Kx = Flong × 5.975 (1 − ψ)²
Flong is a correction for the type of stiffener at the long edge. For compression across the panel, the factor Cy uses c1 = 1 − 1/α, not less than zero, for SP-A and UP-A panels. It uses c1 = 1 for SP-B and UP-B panels.
Elementary plate panels
The CSR and UR S35 check an elementary plate panel, the smallest panel between stiffeners and primary members. UR S35 2.3.1 takes its length a as the longest edge and its breadth b as the shortest. A stiffened panel, SP, is part of a stiffened structure. An unstiffened panel, UP, stands alone. The suffix A or B gives the method: A where the edges are forced to remain straight, and B where they are not.
Stiffener checks in the CSR
Sec 5 [2.3.1] checks a stiffener for two failures: “Stiffener induced failure (SI)” and “Associated plate induced failure (PI)”. The check combines the axial stress, a bending stress from the imperfection and the lateral pressure, and, for SI, a torsional stress. The assumed imperfection is w0 = ℓ/1000. Sec 5 [2.3.4] gives the bending moment M0 from that imperfection.
The stiffener interaction formula
CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 Sec 5 [2.3.4] checks the stiffener by (γc σa + σb + σw)/ReH × S = 1. The bending stress σb is the bending stress (M0 + M1 + M2)/(1000 Z). σw is the torsional stress, for stiffener induced failure only. The three moments are:
- M0, from the assumed imperfection w0 = ℓ/1000 and the Euler load FE = (π/ℓ)² E I × 10⁴
- M1, from the lateral pressure: Ci |P| s ℓ²/(24 × 10³) for a continuous stiffener and /(8 × 10³) for a sniped one
- M2, from the eccentricity of a sniped stiffener, with Csnip ±1.2
The reduction factor Csl on M0 is 1 − λG⁴/12 for λG up to 1.56, and 3/λG⁴ above it. For a flat bar, [2.3.2] reduces the effective web thickness with the ratio of web height to spacing. The torsional buckling stress σET uses the torsional span ℓtor and the warping, St Venant and polar constants of the profile.
The utilization factor
The CSR finds the buckling capacity by scaling the applied stress combination until the interaction formula equals 1.0. The utilization factor is the ratio of the applied stress to that capacity.
Buckling utilization factor
where
| \(\eta_{act}\) | actual buckling utilization factor | |
| \(W_{act}, W_{u}\) | applied stress combination and the stress combination at buckling capacity | N/mm² |
| \(\gamma_{c}\) | stress multiplier factor at failure | |
| \(\eta_{all}\) | allowable utilization factor of Ch 8 Sec 1, Table 1 |
CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 Sec 1, Table 1, sets the allowable values:
| Structural member | ηall, static plus dynamic | ηall, static |
|---|---|---|
| Plates, stiffeners and stiffened panels | 1.00 | 0.80 |
| Web plate in way of openings | 1.00 | 0.80 |
| Struts, pillars and cross ties | 0.75 | 0.65 |
| Corrugations with a lower stool, and horizontally corrugated bulkheads | 0.90 | 0.72 |
| Corrugations without a lower stool | 0.81 | 0.65 |
Sec 3 [1.1.2] applies the hull girder buckling requirements “along the full length of the ship”. Sec 3 [2.2.1] combines the stresses in two cases. The first takes the full hull girder stress with 0.7 of the shear. The second takes 0.7 of the hull girder stress with the full shear.
Direct strength analysis
Sec 4 applies the buckling checks to the results of a finite element analysis under Ch 7. Its elements are:
- stiffened, unstiffened and curved panels
- web plates in way of openings
- corrugated bulkheads
- vertically stiffened side shell of single side skin bulk carriers
- struts, pillars and cross ties
Each element has its own ηall from Table 1.
Exemptions from the slenderness rules
Sec 2 [1.1.1] exempts some members from the slenderness requirements. They are the bilge plates within the cylindrical part, the radius gunwale, corrugations, and superstructure and deckhouse members that do not contribute to longitudinal strength.
IACS UR S35 and hatch covers
IACS UR S35, Buckling Strength Assessment of Ship Structural Elements, is the buckling method that UR S21 applies to hatch covers. UR S35 was new in February 2023, and Corr.1 is dated September 2024.
UR S35 clause 1.1.1 states that it “is to be applied in conjunction with UR S21 for hatch cover structures. UR S21 is referred to as Relevant UR-S.”
Note 1 of UR S35 applies it from the application dates, on or after 1 July 2024, of the URs that require it. Its sections cover slenderness, hull girder prescriptive checks, direct strength analysis of hatch covers and buckling capacity. Its capacity formulas use the same Cx form and the same Cw and Cf table as the CSR.
IACS UR S21 Rev.6 (January 2023) is a complete revision. It applies to the cargo hatch covers and coamings on exposed decks of all ships except CSR bulk carriers. It covers Type-1 and Type-2 ships contracted on or after 1 July 2024, and its clause 3.6.1 requires buckling “in compliance with the requirements in UR S35”. UR S21 sets ηall of 0.80 under external pressure. For other loads it is 0.90 static plus dynamic and 0.72 static. The hatch cover article covers the covers themselves.
UR S21 Rev.6 excludes tarpaulin-secured portable covers and pontoon covers under ICLL Regulation 15, and fishing vessels. Its clause 3.6.2 applies the UR S35 slenderness rules, except to the lower boundary of double skin covers unless the hold carries ballast or liquid. It requires the flange breadth of primary supporting members to be at least 40% of their depth. Earlier revisions applied to Type-2 ships only, and Rev.3 applied from 1 January 2004.
UR S35 1.2.3 allows other methods, such as finite element analysis, “as deemed appropriate by the Society” for cases the UR does not cover. Panels stiffened in two directions are one such case.
UR S35 does not replace UR S11.5. UR S11.5 remains the IACS hull girder buckling check for ships of 90 m and over outside the CSR and UR S11A. UR S11.3.2 adds: “The buckling evaluation criteria used for this check is determined by each Classification Society.” The classification society applies both.
Initial imperfections and fabrication tolerances
Real plates and stiffeners are never perfectly flat or straight, and their initial imperfections lower the buckling capacity. The CSR assumes an imperfection in its stiffener check, and IACS Rec 47 sets the tolerances a shipyard works to. The load-end shortening curves of CSR Pt 1 Ch 5 App 2 carry the post-buckling behaviour of each panel into the hull girder capacity.
The assumed imperfection
CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 Sec 5 [2.3.4] uses w0 = ℓ/1000 for the stiffener check. UR S35 states the same value, with ℓ in mm. A stiffener 4,000 mm long therefore carries an assumed initial deflection of 4 mm. The imperfection produces a bending moment that adds to the axial stress.
IACS Rec 47 tolerances
IACS Rec 47, the Shipbuilding and Repair Quality Standard, is at Rev.10 Corr.1 of October 2025. It gives a Standard, the target range, and a Limit, “the maximum allowable deviation”. Its Table 6.10 sets the unfairness of plating between frames:
| Location | Standard | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Shell, parallel part | 4 mm | 8 mm |
| Shell, fore and aft parts | 5 mm | 8 mm |
| Tank top | 4 mm | 8 mm |
| Bulkheads | 6 mm | 8 mm |
| Strength deck, parallel part | 4 mm | 8 mm |
| Strength deck, fore and aft parts | 6 mm | 9 mm |
| Covered deck | 7 mm | 9 mm |
Table 6.11 sets unfairness with frames, as a fraction of the frame span: ±2ℓ/1000 standard and ±3ℓ/1000 limit for the shell parallel part. Table 6.1 sets the straightness of flanged longitudinals at ±10 mm standard and ±25 mm limit per 10 m. Rec 47 is a recommendation, and its applicability to a ship is agreed with the class society.
The welding distortion and fairing stub covers how unfairness arises and how it is corrected.
Buckling in service
Corrosion, damage and local overloads reduce the buckling margin of a ship in service. The UR S11 and CSR checks are made at net thickness for that reason. The CSR deducts the full tc for buckling and 0.5 tc for ultimate strength, as set out in corrosion margins and renewal thickness.
Corrosion and thickness loss
A uniform thickness loss reduces the elastic buckling stress with the square of the remaining thickness. Tank coatings and cathodic protection slow that loss, and cargo oil tank corrosion protection addresses the tanker case. The in-service longitudinal strength evaluation and the close-up survey of the Enhanced Survey Programme measure the remaining thickness. The measurements are taken at the special survey.
The MOL Comfort report
The Japan MLIT Committee on Large Container Ship Safety issued its final report in March 2015. It recorded buckling deformations in the bottom shell plates of sister ships of the MOL Comfort. The deformations were up to 20 mm in height, near the centerline in the midship part. The report reproduced the deformations by simulation, and found that they could occur and grow under repeated loads.
The committee recommended a check of the biaxial stresses from vertical bending and lateral loads. They are to fall within the interaction curve of the buckling collapse strength of stiffened bottom panels. The report states that the fracture originated in the bottom shell amidships. It does not state that buckling collapse caused the fracture. The container ship and UR S11A articles cover the rules that followed.
Buckling by structural region
Each region of the hull buckles under a different stress, so each has its own governing check.
| Region | Governing stress | Check |
|---|---|---|
| Strength deck and deck longitudinals | Compression in sagging | UR S11.5 or CSR Ch 8 Sec 3 |
| Bottom shell and bottom longitudinals | Compression in hogging | UR S11.5 or CSR Ch 8 Sec 3 |
| Side shell and longitudinal bulkheads | Hull girder shear, with bending near deck and bottom | UR S11.5.2.1.2 or CSR Ch 8 |
| Inner bottom and hopper plating | Bending stress at their height, plus lateral pressure | CSR Ch 8 Sec 3 and Sec 5 |
| Hatch covers | Local loads on the cover | UR S21 Rev.6 with UR S35 |
| Corrugated bulkheads | Local and flooding loads | CSR Ch 8, own ηall |
| Pillars and cross ties | Axial compression | CSR Ch 8, ηall 0.75 and 0.65 |
The strength deck and the double bottom carry the largest hull girder stresses, because they are farthest from the neutral axis. In a bulk carrier the topside tank and the hopper plating are also highly stressed. In an oil tanker the longitudinal bulkheads carry a large share of the shear. Stress at any height y follows the beam relation of UR S11.5.4.1, so a member closer to the neutral axis carries less bending stress.
Buckling and the other strength checks
Buckling links the hull girder yielding check to the ultimate strength of the hull. A section that meets its section modulus can still fail if its compressed panels buckle first.
Yielding, buckling and ultimate strength
The section modulus check of UR S11.3.1.1 limits the bending stress to 175/k N/mm². The buckling check of S11.5 then confirms that the compressed members can carry that stress without buckling. The CSR buckling capacity is “a lower bound estimate of ultimate capacity” (Ch 8 Sec 1 [3.1.2]). For CSR ships of 150 m and above, the hull girder ultimate strength check of CSR Pt 1 Ch 5 Sec 2 follows.
Fatigue
Buckling is a check of the extreme load, at the 10⁻⁸ probability level in the CSR. Fatigue is a check of the load history, at 10⁻². A panel can pass one and fail the other.
What the casualty reports say
The French BEAmer report on the Erika found the deck compressive stresses “relatively small” against the allowable values for buckling. It attributed the loss to the weakness of transverse elements, not to hull girder buckling. The Bahamas Maritime Authority report on the Prestige makes no buckling finding. The MOL Comfort report, above, records buckling deformations in the bottom of sister ships.
Common errors in buckling checks
The errors below mix thicknesses, rule sets and load directions. Each names the clause it breaks.
- Gross thickness used. UR S11.5.2 uses the net thickness after the standard deduction, and the CSR the gross less tc.
- The elastic stress taken as the capacity of a thick plate. UR S11.5.3.1 corrects σE above σF/2.
- One β for all members. UR S11.5.5.1 uses 1.0 for plating and 1.1 for stiffeners.
- ηall 0.80 used for every CSR case. 0.80 is the static value. Static plus dynamic is 1.00 for plates.
- UR S35 applied to a hull girder. UR S35 is applied with UR S21 to hatch covers. For UR S11 ships, UR S11.5 is the hull girder check.
- Only the hogging moment checked on a hogging ship. UR S11.5.4.1 requires special consideration of sagging.
- Tripping ignored on a slender plate. The plate’s spring stiffness falls as the plate approaches buckling (UR S11.5.2.2.2).
Limitations
This article explains how plate and stiffener buckling is checked under the IACS rules. It is not a substitute for the classification society’s rules and calculation for a real ship. The society’s buckling criteria govern. UR S11.3.2 states that the buckling evaluation criteria are determined by each society.
The example plates are illustrations with simple support and uniform stress. Their numbers show the mechanism only. A real panel has its own stress ratio, edge restraint and lateral pressure.
The UR values are from UR S11 Rev.10, UR S35 Corr.1 and UR S21 Rev.6. The CSR values are from the 1 July 2025 consolidated edition. The CSR tables of Flong and the full stiffener interaction formulas are not reproduced here. Hull girder ultimate strength, which follows from the buckling of the deck and bottom panels, has its own article.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Why does the deck buckle in sagging and the bottom in hogging?
Buckling needs compression, and the hull girder puts the deck in compression when it sags and the bottom in compression when it hogs.
The tension side cannot buckle. IACS UR S11.5.4.1 takes the sagging moment for members above the neutral axis and the hogging moment for members below it.
What is the elastic buckling stress of a plate under UR S11?
IACS UR S11.5.2.1.1 gives σE = 0.9 m E (tb/(1000 s))² in N/mm². tb is the net thickness in mm, s the shorter side of the panel in m, and E 2.06 × 10⁵ N/mm².
The factor m depends on the stiffening direction and the stress distribution.
Why is m equal to 4 for a longitudinally stiffened plate in uniform compression?
For a longitudinally stiffened plate, UR S11.5.2.1.1 sets m = 8.4/(ψ + 1.1).
Uniform compression has ψ = 1, so m = 8.4/2.1 = 4.0. A stress that falls to zero across the panel has ψ = 0, and m is then 7.6.
What is the factor c for a transversely stiffened plate?
IACS UR S11.5.2.1.1 sets c by the type of stiffener at the panel edge. c is 1.3 for floors or deep girders and 1.21 for angles or T-sections.
It is 1.10 for bulb flats and 1.05 for flat bars.
What correction applies when the elastic buckling stress is high?
IACS UR S11.5.3.1 uses the elastic buckling stress directly only up to half the yield stress.
Above that, the critical stress is σF (1 − σF/(4 σE)). The correction keeps the critical stress below the yield stress, because a thick plate yields before it buckles elastically.
What shear yield stress does UR S11 use?
IACS UR S11.5.3.2 uses τF = σF/√3.
For mild steel with σF of 235 N/mm², that is 135.7 N/mm². The critical shear stress follows the same correction as compression, applied to the elastic shear buckling stress.
What safety margin does UR S11 require against buckling?
IACS UR S11.5.5.1 requires the critical buckling stress to be at least β times the working stress. β is 1.0 for plating and for the web plating of stiffeners.
It is 1.1 for stiffeners. In shear the critical stress has to be at least the working shear stress.
Which thickness is used in the UR S11 buckling check?
UR S11.5.2 uses the net thickness, the as-built thickness less a standard deduction.
The deduction is 0.05 t for dry bulk compartments and similar surfaces, limited to 0.5 to 1 mm. It rises to 0.10 t (2 to 3 mm) and 0.15 t (2 to 4 mm) for more severe tank exposure.
What is the minimum working stress in the UR S11 buckling check?
IACS UR S11.5.4.1 takes the working compressive stress as (Ms + Mw)/In × y × 10⁵, and not less than 30/k N/mm².
For a ship that is always in hogging in still water, the clause asks for the sagging moment to be specially considered.
What is stiffener tripping?
Tripping is the torsional buckling of a stiffener, in which the profile twists about its connection to the plate.
UR S11.5.2.2.2 gives its elastic buckling stress from the warping, polar and torsional constants of the profile and the stiffness of the plate. The CSR treats it as a stiffener induced failure with a torsional stress.
What flange proportion prevents flange buckling?
IACS UR S11.5.2.2.3 requires the flange outstand ratio bf/tf to be not more than 15. bf is the flange width for an angle and half the flange width for a T-section.
The flange thickness tf is the as-built value.
What web slenderness does the CSR allow for stiffeners?
CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 Sec 2 [3.1.1] requires tw ≥ (hw/Cw) √(ReH/235).
Cw is 75 for angles and T-bars, 45 for bulb profiles and 22 for flat bars. Angles and T-bars also need a flange thickness to the Cf limit of 12.
What is the minimum plate thickness for slenderness in the CSR?
CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 Sec 2 [2.1.1] requires tp ≥ (b/C) √(ReH/235).
C is 100 for the hull envelope and cargo and tank boundaries, and 125 for other structures. b is the panel breadth.
What is the allowable buckling utilization factor in the CSR?
CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 Sec 1, Table 1, sets ηall for plates, stiffeners and stiffened panels.
It is 1.00 for static plus dynamic loads and 0.80 for static loads. Struts, pillars and cross ties have 0.75 and 0.65. Corrugations have their own values.
What do S and S+D mean in the CSR buckling tables?
S is a static design load combination and S+D a static plus dynamic combination.
For plates the CSR factors are 0.80 for S and 1.00 for S+D.
What are Method A and Method B in the CSR?
CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 Sec 1 [3.1.3] defines two methods.
Method A applies where the panel edges are forced to remain straight, and Method B where they are not. The choice changes the buckling capacity formulas.
What is the CSR plate reduction factor Cx?
Cx is the factor on the yield stress that gives the plate buckling capacity in compression.
CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 Sec 5, Table 3, case 1, sets Cx = 1 up to a slenderness λc. Above λc, Cx = c (1/λ − 0.22/λ²), with c = 1.25 − 0.12 ψ.
What initial imperfection does the CSR assume for a stiffener?
CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 Sec 5 [2.3.4] takes an assumed imperfection w0 of ℓ/1000 for the stiffener check.
UR S35 uses the same value and states ℓ in mm. The imperfection sets the bending moment M0 in the stiffener interaction formula.
What is IACS UR S35?
IACS UR S35, Buckling Strength Assessment of Ship Structural Elements, was new in February 2023, with Corr.1 in September 2024.
Its clause 1.1.1 applies it in conjunction with UR S21 for hatch cover structures. UR S21 is its only Relevant UR-S.
Does UR S35 apply to the hull girder of a non-CSR ship?
No. UR S35 has a hull girder section, but its clause 1.1.1 names UR S21 for hatch covers as its only Relevant UR-S.
For ships of 90 m and over outside the CSR and UR S11A, the IACS hull girder buckling check remains UR S11.5.
Which hatch covers need UR S35?
IACS UR S21 Rev.6 applies UR S35 to the hatch covers and coamings on exposed decks of all ships except CSR bulk carriers.
It applies to Type-1 and Type-2 ships contracted on or after 1 July 2024. UR S21 Rev.6 sets ηall of 0.80 under external pressure.
What plate unfairness is allowed at build?
IACS Rec 47 Rev.10 Corr.1 sets the unfairness of shell plating between frames in the parallel part.
The standard is 4 mm and the limit 8 mm. The strength deck parallel part has the same values. The fore and aft parts allow more.
Is IACS Rec 47 mandatory?
No. Rec 47, the Shipbuilding and Repair Quality Standard, is an IACS recommendation.
Its applicability to a ship is agreed with the classification society. Its Standard is the target range and its Limit the maximum allowable deviation.
Where along the ship does the CSR check hull girder buckling?
CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 Sec 3 [1.1.2] states that the hull girder buckling strength requirements apply along the full length of the ship.
UR S11.3.2 also requires buckling checks where the framing system or the hull section changes.
What did the MOL Comfort report find about buckling?
The Japan MLIT committee’s final report of March 2015 recorded buckling deformations of the bottom shell plates in sister ships of the MOL Comfort.
They were up to about 20 mm in height, near the centerline amidships. It recommended checking bottom panels for buckling collapse under biaxial stress.
What is the difference between elastic buckling and buckling capacity?
Elastic buckling is the stress at which a perfect plate first deflects out of plane.
The CSR buckling capacity is a lower bound estimate of the ultimate capacity. It uses the elastic post-buckling strength of plates (CSR Pt 1 Ch 8 Sec 1 [3.1.2]). A slender plate can carry more than its elastic buckling stress.
Does corrosion change the buckling strength?
Yes, strongly. The elastic buckling stress of a plate varies with the square of its thickness, so a 10% loss of thickness cuts it by about 19%.
That is why both UR S11 and the CSR check buckling at net thickness.
No question matches. Try a shorter or different word.
Sources
- IACS UR S11 Rev.10 (Dec 2020). Longitudinal Strength Standard iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IACS CSR BC&OT (1 July 2025). Common Structural Rules for Bulk Carriers and Oil Tankers iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IACS UR S35 Corr.1 (Sep 2024). Buckling Strength Assessment of Ship Structural Elements iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IACS UR S21 Rev.6 (Jan 2023). Evaluation of Scantlings of Hatch Covers and Hatch Coamings and Closing Arrangements of Cargo Holds of Ships iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IACS Recommendation No. 47 Rev.10 Corr.1 (Oct 2025). Shipbuilding and Repair Quality Standard iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- BEAmer. Report of the enquiry into the sinking of the Erika bea-mer.developpement-durable.gouv.fr
- Bahamas Maritime Authority. Report of the investigation into the loss of the Prestige bahamasmaritime.com
- Japan MLIT. Final report of the Committee on Large Container Ship Safety (March 2015) mlit.go.jp