Corrosion Margins and Renewal Thickness
Corrosion margins and renewal thickness: CSR corrosion addition, net scantlings, substantial corrosion, renewal criteria and thickness gauging of hull steel.
Contents17 sections
A corrosion margin is the thickness added to a hull member’s net scantling to allow for wastage in service. The renewal thickness is the point at which that margin is used up. The IACS Common Structural Rules call the margin the corrosion addition tc. CSR Pt 1 Ch 13 Sec 2 [2.1.1] sets the renewal thickness at tren = tas-built − tc − tvol_add.
The CSR adds tc to the net scantling at design and checks the gauged thickness against tren in service. Between tren + 0.5 mm and tren, UR Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5 call the condition substantial corrosion. Ships outside the CSR follow the renewal criteria of their classification society. The hull thickness measurement article covers the survey that finds the gauged value.
The corrosion addition
The CSR corrosion addition is the sum of the one-side values for the two spaces at a member, rounded up, plus 0.5 mm. CSR Pt 1 Ch 3 Sec 3 [1.2.1] sets the formula. “Roundup0.5 (t) means that t is rounded to the upper half millimetre.”
Corrosion addition
where
| \(t_{c}\) | corrosion addition, not less than 2 mm (1.5 mm for stiffener webs and face plates and dry-space internals) | mm |
| \(t_{c1}, t_{c2}\) | one-side values for the spaces on each side of the member, Table 1 | mm |
| \(t_{res}\) | reserve thickness, 0.5 mm | mm |
An internal member inside one compartment takes tc = Roundup0.5(2 tc1) + tres. Stainless steel or aluminum takes tc = tres = 0.5 mm. For stainless clad steel, tc1 follows Table 1 on the carbon steel side and tc2 is zero.
Minimum values and the strake rule
CSR [1.2.2] sets a minimum total tc of 2 mm. The minimum is 1.5 mm for the web and face plate of stiffeners and for the internals of dry spaces. The minima are not applied to stainless steel, clad steel or aluminum.
Under [1.2.3], a stiffener takes its tc by the location of its connection to the attached plate. Under [1.2.4], the most onerous value applies to the entire strake. Oil tankers have an exception for vertical corrugations at the 3 m line.
Figure 1 shows how the rounding and the reserve build up tc for an internal member.
Worked example: three corrosion additions
The examples below use the CSR Table 1 values. The arithmetic is Shipping-Wiki.com’s.
- An internal member of a ballast tank, other members, elsewhere. The sum is 1.2 + 1.2 = 2.4 mm, rounded up to 2.5 mm. tc is 3.0 mm.
- The inner bottom of a BC-A hold (LLL ≥ 150 m) over a ballast double bottom. The sum is 3.7 + 1.2 = 4.9 mm, rounded up to 5.0 mm. tc is 5.5 mm.
- The weather deck over a ballast tank, within 3 m of its top. The sum is 1.7 + 1.7 = 3.4 mm, rounded up to 3.5 mm. tc is 4.0 mm.
The inner bottom of the BC-A hold takes the largest addition of the three. The hold-side value of 3.7 mm is more than three times the 1.2 mm on the ballast side of the same plate.
Two rounding rules
The CSR rounds two different quantities in two different ways. The corrosion addition is rounded up, to the upper half millimetre, under Ch 3 Sec 3 [1.2.1]. The required net thickness is rounded to the nearest half millimetre, under Ch 3 Sec 2 [1.3.1].
A sum of one-side values of 2.6 mm therefore becomes 3.0 mm before tres is added. A required net thickness of 10.6 mm becomes 10.5 mm.
The one-side values of CSR Table 1
CSR Pt 1 Ch 3 Sec 3 Table 1 gives the one-side value for each type of space and member. It has separate columns for oil tankers and two classes of bulk carrier. The bulk carrier columns are “BC-A or BC-B ships with LLL ≥ 150 m” and “Other BC ships”. A single value across the columns applies to every ship type.
| Space and member | One-side value (mm) |
|---|---|
| Ballast water tank, primary supporting member face plate | 2.0 within 3 m below the tank top, 1.5 elsewhere |
| Ballast water tank, other members | 1.7 within 3 m below the tank top, 1.2 elsewhere |
| Cargo oil or slop tank, primary supporting member face plate | 1.7 within 3 m, 1.4 elsewhere |
| Cargo oil or slop tank, inner bottom | 2.1 |
| Cargo oil or slop tank, other members | 1.7 within 3 m, 1.0 elsewhere |
| Dry bulk hold, lower stool sloping, vertical and top plate | 5.2 (BC-A, BC-B ≥ 150 m), 2.6 (other BC) |
| Dry bulk hold, transverse bulkhead, other parts | 3.0 (BC-A, BC-B ≥ 150 m), 1.5 (other BC) |
| Dry bulk hold, hopper sloped plating and inner bottom | 3.7 (BC-A, BC-B ≥ 150 m), 2.4 (other BC) |
| Dry bulk hold, transverse bulkhead upper part | 2.4 (BC-A, BC-B ≥ 150 m), 1.0 (other BC) |
| Dry bulk hold, other members, upper part and upper end brackets of single side frames | 1.8 (BC-A, BC-B ≥ 150 m), 1.0 (other BC) |
| Dry bulk hold, other members, lower bracket webs and flanges | 2.2 (BC-A, BC-B ≥ 150 m), 1.2 (other BC) |
| Dry bulk hold, other members, other parts | 2.0 (BC-A, BC-B ≥ 150 m), 1.2 (other BC) |
| Weather deck plating | 1.7 |
| Other members exposed to the atmosphere | 1.0 |
| Shell between the minimum ballast and scantling draught waterlines | 1.5 |
| Shell elsewhere | 1.0 |
| Fuel oil, lubricating oil and fresh water tanks, void spaces | 0.7 |
| Dry spaces | 0.5 |
The table groups the rows of Table 1 by space. The dry bulk hold rows do not apply to oil tankers. The value for the shell depends on the waterline band. A side shell strake takes 1.5 mm on its sea side between the ballast and scantling draughts, and 1.0 mm elsewhere.
Note 6 of Table 1 defines the upper part of a hold. It is the part above the connection of the topside tank to the inner hull or side shell. Otherwise it is the upper one third of the hold height. Note 7 sets the lower stool extent where no stool is fitted. The extent runs up to the level of the opposing stool. Otherwise it runs from the inner bottom to the hopper top, not over 3 m.
Reading Table 1 for a bulk carrier
A BC-A ship of 150 m or more carries the highest values in the hold. The lower stool of that ship takes 5.2 mm a side and the inner bottom 3.7 mm. The same members of a ship in the “Other BC ships” column, such as a BC-C ship, take 2.6 mm and 2.4 mm.
The bulk carrier article covers the BC-A, BC-B and BC-C notations. The alternate hold loading article covers the empty-hold conditions that go with BC-A.
The notes to Table 1
The notes add values for particular cases:
- 1.0 mm more within 3 m above the bottom of a chain locker
- 0.5 mm more on the ballast side of a boundary with a heated cargo or slop tank, with 0.3 mm on each stiffener surface
- 0.7 mm more on the ballast side of a boundary with a heated fuel or lubricating oil tank
- the 3 m rule applies only to tanks with the weather deck as the tank top
- a pipe tunnel is treated as a ballast tank for the outer shell
The cargo tank heating of a tanker raises the corrosion addition of the adjacent ballast tank structure.
Steel grade does not change the values
CSR [1.1.1] applies the corrosion additions to carbon-manganese steels without a distinction by strength. A plate of AH36 steel takes the same tc as a mild steel plate in the same space. The higher tensile steel article covers what that means for thinner higher tensile plating.
The net scantling approach
The CSR checks each member on a net thickness, the gross offered thickness less all or half of the corrosion addition, depending on the check. CSR Pt 1 Ch 3 Sec 2 [1.1.1] describes the approach as one that “clearly separates the net thickness from the thickness added to address the corrosion that is likely to occur during the ship-in-operation phase”.
Gross and net offered thickness
where
| \(t_{gr\_off}\) | gross offered thickness | mm |
| \(t_{vol\_add}\) | thickness voluntarily added as owner's or builder's extra margin | mm |
| \(t_{off}\) | net offered thickness | mm |
| \(t_{as\_built}\) | actual thickness provided at the newbuilding stage | mm |
The required gross thickness is tgr_req = treq + tc. The required net thickness treq is rounded to the nearest half millimetre: 10.75 ≤ t < 11.25 gives 11.0 mm (CSR [1.3.1]). The design production margin tdm “is not to be considered as an additional corrosion margin”. Owner or builder additions are not counted for compliance (CSR [1.3.2]).
Full tc or half tc
CSR Pt 1 Ch 3 Sec 2 Table 1 sets which deduction each check uses. Figure 2 shows the split.
- Full tc: minimum thickness; local strength, including buckling; primary supporting member stiffness, proportions and buckling; finite element buckling; hull girder buckling.
- 0.5 tc: primary supporting member section properties; finite element strength analysis at all mesh levels; hull girder section properties; ultimate and residual strength; fatigue.
For profiles, the 0.5 tc is “deducted from the surface of the profile cross-section”. The hull girder section modulus and the hull girder ultimate strength therefore use half the addition. The buckling of ship plating and stiffeners uses the full addition.
Local and global corrosion
CSR [1.1.2] defines the two scales of wastage: “Local corrosion is defined as uniform corrosion of local structural elements, such as a single plate or stiffener. Global corrosion is defined as the average corrosion of larger areas, such as primary supporting members and the hull girder.”
CSR [1.3.2] states how the half deduction is made: “Half of the applied corrosion addition specified in Table 1 is to be deducted from both sides of the structural members being considered.” The net properties of primary supporting members and the hull girder are “based on the gross offered scantling with a reduction of the applicable corrosion addition, as specified in Table 1”.
Worked example: one plate, two net thicknesses
Take the example plate again: tas-built 16.0 mm, tvol_add 0.5 mm and tc 3.0 mm. These are example values.
- Find the gross offered thickness. 16.0 − 0.5 = 15.5 mm.
- Find the net thickness for local strength and buckling. 15.5 − 3.0 = 12.5 mm.
- Find the net thickness for hull girder section properties. 15.5 − 1.5 = 14.0 mm.
- Find the net thickness for fatigue and ultimate strength. 14.0 mm, the same 0.5 tc basis.
The same plate is therefore 12.5 mm thick in the buckling check and 14.0 mm thick in the section modulus. A buckling check run on the section modulus thickness would overstate the plate capacity.
Where the gross scantling is used
CSR [1.1.3] lists exceptions to the net approach. Superstructures and deckhouses, under Ch 11 Sec 1, are assessed on gross scantlings. Steel forgings and castings are also gross. No corrosion addition is deducted for those items.
UR S11A uses the same principle
UR S11A for container ships uses net scantlings with its own α factors: 0.5 for section properties and stresses, 1.0 for buckling capacity. The one-side values of UR S11A Table 2 differ from the CSR. The UR S11A article covers them.
Corrosion additions in other IACS rules
The CSR is one of several IACS texts that set a corrosion addition, and each one sets its own values and deductions. The table compares four of them.
| Instrument | Ships | Corrosion addition | Deduction by check |
|---|---|---|---|
| CSR BC&OT Pt 1 Ch 3 Sec 3 | CSR bulk carriers and oil tankers | Roundup0.5(tc1 + tc2) + 0.5 mm, one-side values 0.5 to 5.2 mm | Full tc or 0.5 tc (Ch 3 Sec 2 Table 1) |
| UR S11A | Container ships | One-side values 0.0, 0.5 or 1.0 mm (Table 2), plus tres 0.5 mm | α of 0.5 or 1.0 (Table 1) |
| UR S18 Rev.10 | Non-CSR bulk carriers, corrugated bulkheads | 3.5 mm | Net thickness tnet for the flooding check |
| UR S31 Rev.4 | Non-CSR single side skin bulk carriers, side frames | tC of 2.0 to 4.0 mm by length and hold (Table 1) | Part of the renewal thickness tREN |
The values are not interchangeable. A deck plate between the atmosphere and a container hold takes 2.5 mm under UR S11A. A weather deck plate over a ballast tank on a CSR ship takes 4.0 mm, as the worked example shows. The IACS Common Structural Rules article covers the scope of the CSR.
The renewal thickness
The renewal thickness is the gauged thickness below which a member is renewed: the as-built thickness less the corrosion addition and any owner’s extra. CSR Pt 1 Ch 13 applies “only to ships in operation that are classed in accordance with these Rules” (Sec 1 [1.1.2]). Under Sec 1 [1.2.2], the ship is not reassessed against the newbuilding requirements while the measured thickness stays above the renewal thickness.
Renewal thickness
where
| \(t_{ren}\) | renewal thickness; renewal is required below it | mm |
| \(t_{c}\) | corrosion addition of the member | mm |
| \(t_{repair}\) | thickness of a renewed insert, of the same or greater grade and yield stress | mm |
The renewal thickness equals the net offered thickness toff of Ch 3 Sec 2. That equality is arithmetic from the two formulas. The member is renewed when its gauged thickness falls below the net thickness that the design took credit for.
Figure 3 shows the thicknesses of an example plate and the zones a gauged value can fall in.
Repair inserts
CSR Ch 13 Sec 2 [2.1.2] requires a renewed insert of the “same or greater grade and yield stress” as the original. Its thickness is at least tas-built − tvol_add. Where tren ≤ tm < tren + tres, CSR [2.1.3] allows alternative solutions in the society rules that incorporate UR Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5.
Under Sec 1 [1.3.1], the plans on board show the as-built thickness, the renewal thickness and any tvol_add. Sec 1 [1.2.3] states: “Steel renewal is required if either the local or global corrosion allowance is exceeded.”
CSR Ch 13 does not hold the survey procedure itself. Sec 1 [1.1.4] and Sec 2 [2.1.1] send the survey requirements to the society rules that incorporate UR Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5. The CSR sets the limit, and the survey URs set how and where the thickness is measured.
Worked example: a plate at survey
Take a CSR plate with an as-built thickness of 16.0 mm, tvol_add of 0.5 mm and tc of 3.0 mm. These are example values.
- Find the gross offered thickness. 16.0 − 0.5 = 15.5 mm.
- Find the renewal thickness. 16.0 − 3.0 − 0.5 = 12.5 mm.
- Find the substantial corrosion band. 12.5 to 13.0 mm.
- Compare a gauged value of 12.8 mm. It lies in the band, so the plate has substantial corrosion.
- Find the insert thickness if renewed. At least 15.5 mm.
The gauged plate has used 2.7 mm of its 3.0 mm addition, or 90%. Under the general 75% definition it would also be substantial corrosion.
Substantial corrosion
Substantial corrosion is wastage close to the renewal limit, which triggers closer examination or gauging at the next surveys. UR Z7 1.2.8, and the matching clauses of UR Z10.1, Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5, define it as “wastage in excess of 75% of allowable margins, but within acceptable limits”.
UR Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5 add a definition for CSR ships: “For vessels built under the IACS Common Structural Rules, substantial corrosion is an extent of corrosion such that the assessment of the corrosion pattern indicates a measured thickness between tren + 0.5mm and tren.” Z10.2 1.2.10 defines the renewal thickness as “the minimum allowable thickness, in mm, below which renewal of structural members is to be carried out.”
The two definitions compared
For the example plate of Figure 3, the general definition gives substantial corrosion below 15.5 − 0.75 × 3.0 = 13.25 mm. The CSR definition gives it below 13.0 mm. The two bands overlap but differ in width, and the CSR band is a fixed 0.5 mm whatever the size of tc.
IACS Rec 96 Rev.2 2.1.5 uses the same two forms for double hull tankers: “a wastage between 75 % and 100 % of the allowable diminution”, and for CSR ships “between tnet + 0.5mm and tnet”.
What follows from substantial corrosion
For CSR bulk carriers, UR Z10.2 2.4.2 and UR Z10.5 allow two options for each substantial corrosion area:
a) protected by coating applied in accordance with the coating manufacturer’s requirements and examined at annual intervals to confirm the coating in way is still in good condition, or alternatively b) required to be measured at annual intervals.
For CSR double hull tankers, UR Z10.4 requires the areas “to be examined and additional thickness measurements are to be carried out”. A suspect area is defined in all five URs as one “showing Substantial Corrosion and/or are considered by the Surveyor to be prone to rapid wastage”.
“Excessive corrosion” is not a defined term in UR Z7, Z10.1, Z10.2, Z10.4 or Z10.5. Below the renewal thickness the member is renewed.
Pitting, edge and grooving corrosion
Localized corrosion can go below tren on CSR ships, within set limits. UR Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5 clauses 8.2 to 8.4 set the limits.
Pitting and grooving limits
where
| \(t_{m}\) | measured thickness at the pit, for pitting intensity under 20% | mm |
| \(t_{m}\) | measured thickness in the groove, for grooves up to 15% of web height and 30 mm | mm |
| \(6\ \mathrm{mm}\) | absolute minimum in a groove | mm |
The limits are:
- Pitting, with intensity under 20%: at least the lesser of the two pitting values, with a section average not below tren (8.2.1).
- Edge corrosion, under 25% of the flange breadth or web height: the same two criteria. Opening edges can go below tren over at most 20% of the smallest opening dimension, and 100 mm.
- Grooving, up to 15% of the web height and 30 mm: the lesser of the two grooving values, never below 6 mm (8.4.1).
UR Z10.2 8.2.1 adds a rule for the side structures of bulk carriers. Pitting over 15% triggers cleaning over 300 mm and measurement of the five deepest pits. Frame and bracket webs and flanges keep at least 75% of the as-built thickness. The attached plating within 30 mm of the frame keeps at least 70%. The pitting, edge and grooving stub collects these rules.
Worked example: a pitted plate
Take the example plate, with tas-built 16.0, tvol_add 0.5 and tren 12.5 mm, and pitting of 15% intensity. These are example values.
- Find the first value. 0.7 × (16.0 − 0.5) = 10.85 mm.
- Find the second value. 12.5 − 1 = 11.5 mm.
- Take the lesser. 10.85 mm is the limit at a pit.
- Check the average. The average thickness across the section is not to fall below 12.5 mm.
A single pit can therefore go to 10.85 mm while the plate as a whole stays above tren.
The hull girder in service
The CSR checks the longitudinal strength of a ship over 10 years of age against 90% of its gross offered section modulus. CSR Pt 1 Ch 13 Sec 2 [2.2.1] states: “The ship’s longitudinal strength is to be evaluated by using the thickness of structural members measured, renewed and reinforced, as appropriate, during special surveys, for ships over 10 years of age.”
Hull girder in service
where
| \(Z_{current}\) | section modulus at deck and bottom with the measured thicknesses | m³ |
| \(Z_{gr\_off}\) | section modulus with the gross offered thickness, by Ch 5 Sec 1 | m³ |
| \(A_{zone}\) | current sectional area of the deck zone or the bottom zone | m² |
| \(A_{NA}\) | neutral axis zone area, not less than with gross offered thickness less 0.5 tc | m² |
The neutral axis zone area is not to be less than its area with the gross offered thickness less 0.5 tc. The check is not needed where all reductions of gross offered thickness are under 10% in the deck and bottom zones. In the neutral axis zone the limit is 0.5 tc. CSR Pt 1 Ch 13 Sec 2 [1.2] divides the section into three zones, which Figure 4 shows.
The deck zone takes “elements above or crossed by the 0.9 D level line above the baseline”. The bottom zone of a bulk carrier runs up to the upper level of the hopper sloping plating. Inclined members count by their “projected area onto the vertical plane”.
The trigger age
UR Z10.2 and Z10.5 9.1.1.1 set the longitudinal strength evaluation of CSR bulk carriers at 15 years of age, or Special Survey No.3. CSR Ch 13 sets it for ships over 10 years. The in-service longitudinal strength evaluation article covers the evaluation as a survey task.
For non-CSR oil tankers of 130 m and over, older than 10 years, UR Z10.1 8.1.1.1 and Z10.4 9.1.1.1 apply the Annex III check. The check is triggered where the deck or bottom flange area has diminished by more than 10%. For a tanker built on or after 1 July 2002, the minimum is 90% of the UR S7 or S11 newbuilding requirement, whichever is greater.
UR S7 Rev.4 gives the in-service minimum section modulus coefficient as cs = 0.9 cn, 90% of the newbuilding coefficient. The hull strength hub covers those rules. Z10.4 8.1.1 sends the CSR acceptance criteria to the CSR. UR Z10.4 does not state whether its Annex III also applies to a CSR double hull tanker.
Worked example: the 90% screen
Take a CSR bulk carrier at its fourth special survey. The deck zone of the ship has a gross offered area of 1.20 m², and the bottom zone 1.60 m². These are example values.
- Find the 90% limits. The deck zone limit is 1.08 m², and the bottom zone limit 1.44 m².
- Compare the gauged deck zone area of 1.11 m². The area is 92.5% of gross offered, above the limit.
- Compare the gauged bottom zone area of 1.42 m². The area is 88.8% of gross offered, below the limit.
- Check the section modulus. The zone area criterion is an alternative, so calculate the bottom modulus with the gauged thicknesses.
- If the bottom modulus is also below 90% of the gross offered modulus, the ship fails [2.2.2]. The society rules then set the renewal or reinforcement.
The local criterion still applies to each plate in the zones. A bottom zone that passes the 90% check can still hold a plate below tren, and that plate is renewed under [2.1].
Renewal criteria for non-CSR ships
For ships not built to the CSR, the renewal criteria are the rules of the individual classification society and specific IACS URs. UR Z10.2 8.1.2, Z10.4 8.1.2 and Z10.5 8.1.2 state that the acceptance criteria “are according to the Rules of the individual Classification Society and/or specific IACS URs”. Z10.2 names UR S18, S19, S21 and UR S31.
UR Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5 8.1.2 set no renewal percentage for non-CSR ships; the society rules set it. UR Z7 Annex II, which is “recommendatory”, describes the report form. The report gives gauged minus renewal thickness, coded “R” for renew and “S” for further gauging.
UR S31: side frames of single side skin bulk carriers
UR S31 Rev.4 (April 2007) sets renewal criteria for side frames and brackets of single side skin bulk carriers. UR S31 covers ships not built to UR S12 Rev.1 or later. S31.2.1.2 renews a web where the measured thickness tM is at or below tREN, the greatest of:
- tCOAT − tC, with tCOAT = 0.75 tS12
- 0.75 tAB, three quarters of the as-built thickness
- tREN,d/t, the slenderness criterion of zones A and B
- tREN,S, the strength criterion
The corrosion addition tC of Table 1 runs from 2.0 to 4.0 mm by ship length and hold. A renewed web is at least the greatest of tAB, 1.2 tCOAT and 1.2 tREN. Where tREN < tM ≤ tCOAT, the frame is blasted and coated, and fitted with tripping brackets, and the coating is kept “as-new”. The IACS UR S series article covers UR S12.
UR S18: corrugated bulkheads
UR S18 Rev.10 uses a corrosion addition of 3.5 mm for the corrugated bulkheads of non-CSR bulk carriers. Steel renewal is required below tnet + 0.5 mm. Between tnet + 0.5 and tnet + 1.0 mm, coating or annual gauging “may be adopted as an alternative to steel renewal” (S18.6). The S series article covers the check.
The margins on the plans and in the survey report
The renewal thickness is written on the ship’s plans at delivery, so each gauged value is compared with a stated limit. CSR Pt 1 Ch 13 Sec 1 [1.3.1] requires the plans on board to show each member’s as-built thickness, renewal thickness and tvol_add.
For a non-CSR ship the plans carry the as-built thickness, and the limit comes from the society rules. UR Z7 Annex II, which is recommendatory, gives the reporting convention. The report states the gauged thickness less the renewal thickness for each reading.
- A negative value is coded “R”: the member is renewed.
- A value between zero and the substantial corrosion limit, set “according to the individual classification Society’s Rules”, is coded “S”: the area is gauged further.
Worked example: three readings on one strake
Use the example plate, with tren 12.5 mm and a CSR substantial corrosion band of 12.5 to 13.0 mm. These are example values.
- Read 13.6 mm. The margin over tren is 1.1 mm.
- Read 12.8 mm. The margin over tren is 0.3 mm. The reading is in the band, so code it “S”.
- Read 12.2 mm. The margin over tren is −0.3 mm. Code it “R”.
Under CSR [1.2.4] of Ch 3 Sec 3, the most onerous value of tc applies to the entire strake. The renewal thickness is the same along a strake of one as-built thickness. The hull thickness measurement article covers the reading positions and the report forms.
UR Z7 1.1.3 refers the ship types covered by UR Z10.1, Z10.2, Z10.3, Z10.4, Z10.5, Z7.1 and Z7.2 to those URs. The UR Z7 and UR Z10.5 stubs collect those texts.
Coatings and the corrosion margin
Coatings protect the corrosion margin, and SOLAS requires them in ballast tanks and in crude oil cargo tanks. SOLAS Chapter II-1 regulation 3-2, added by IMO Resolution MSC.216(82) and in force from 1 July 2008, applies to ships of 500 GT and over. The regulation covers all dedicated seawater ballast tanks, and the double-side skin spaces of bulk carriers of 150 m and over.
The coating follows the Performance Standard for Protective Coatings, MSC.215(82). MSC.215(82) 4.1 sets a target useful coating life of 15 years in “GOOD” condition. The regulation applies by date: a contract from 1 July 2008, a keel laid from 1 January 2009, or delivery from 1 July 2012.
Cargo oil tanks
SOLAS II-1/3-11, added by MSC.291(87) (adopted 21 May 2010, in force 1 January 2012), applies to crude oil tankers of 5,000 dwt and over, contracted on or after 1 January 2013, keel laid on or after 1 July 2013, or delivered on or after 1 January 2016. The cargo oil tank is coated to MSC.288(87), or protected by an alternative means or corrosion resistant steel to MSC.289(87), “to maintain required structural integrity for 25 years”. The regulation does not apply to combination carriers or chemical tankers.
Coating condition at survey
UR Z10.2 1.2.13 defines three coating conditions. GOOD is “only minor spot rusting”. FAIR is “local breakdown at edges of stiffeners and weld connection and/or light rusting over 20% or more of areas under consideration”. POOR is “general breakdown of coating over 20% or more, or hard scale at 10% or more”. The coating condition article covers the survey consequences.
For the repair of coatings in service, IACS Rec 87 Rev.2 (May 2015) gives guidelines for coating maintenance and repairs in ballast tanks and combined cargo and ballast tanks on oil tankers. Rec 87 is guidance on coatings. It does not set a renewal thickness or a strength criterion.
Thickness measurement by age
The extent of thickness measurement at each special survey grows with the age of the ship. UR Z10.2 Table II and UR Z7 Table 1 set the bands:
| Special survey | Age of ship | Extent, UR Z7 |
|---|---|---|
| No.1 | 5 years or less | Suspect areas |
| No.2 | Over 5, up to 10 | One transverse section within 0.5L |
| No.3 | Over 10, up to 15 | Two transverse sections |
| No.4 and later | Over 15 | At least three sections, all keel plates, all wind and water strakes over the full length, all exposed main deck plating |
The table gives the UR Z7 extent for general ships. The Enhanced Survey Programme URs add more for bulk carriers and tankers. The special survey and the continuous survey articles cover the survey cycle. The close-up survey article covers the inspection itself.
Figure 5 shows the example plate of Figure 3 over the life of a ship. In the example, the plate keeps its as-built thickness while the coating holds. After the coating breaks down, the plate uses up its corrosion addition. The extent of gauging grows over the same years.
Common misreadings
Most errors with corrosion margins come from mixing the thicknesses that the CSR keeps apart. Each item below names the misreading and the clause that corrects it.
- The net thickness is the renewal thickness. Only the net offered thickness toff equals tren. The required net thickness treq is smaller wherever the plate was built thicker than the rule required (CSR Ch 3 Sec 2 [1.2]).
- The owner’s extra thickness raises the renewal thickness. It does not. tvol_add is subtracted in tren = tas-built − tc − tvol_add (CSR Ch 13 Sec 2 [2.1.1]). The extra thickness is a margin above the renewal point.
- Substantial corrosion on a CSR ship starts at 75% of tc. For CSR ships, UR Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5 use the band tren + 0.5 mm to tren. The 75% definition is the general one.
- The CSR band reaches tren + 1.0 mm. It runs from tren to tren + 0.5 mm (UR Z10.2 1.2.11). The band from tnet + 0.5 mm to tnet + 1.0 mm is the UR S18 coating option for non-CSR corrugated bulkheads.
- Higher tensile steel takes a smaller corrosion addition. The one-side values of Table 1 do not change with steel strength (CSR Ch 3 Sec 3 [1.1.1]).
- The design production margin counts as corrosion margin. The CSR states that tdm “is not to be considered as an additional corrosion margin”.
- A 0.5 tc basis applies to every check. The 0.5 tc basis applies to global checks such as the hull girder section modulus. Local buckling still deducts full tc (CSR Ch 3 Sec 2 Table 1).
- IACS sets a renewal percentage for all ships. UR Z10.2 8.1.2, Z10.4 8.1.2 and Z10.5 8.1.2 send non-CSR acceptance criteria to the society rules and the specific URs.
- A pit below tren means renewal. Localized pitting, edge and grooving corrosion can go below tren within the limits of UR Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5 clauses 8.2 to 8.4.
Limitations
This article summarizes the CSR (1 January 2024 with 1 July 2025 Corrigenda), the IACS URs named and the IMO resolutions in the sources. The class rules and the approved plans of a ship decide its margins and its renewal.
- The Table 1 summary leaves out several rows and the ship-type split of some values. CSR Table 1 is the source.
- The worked examples use example values and the site’s arithmetic, not a real ship.
- UR Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5 8.1.2 set no renewal percentage for non-CSR ships; the society rules set it, and they are not summarized here.
- The CSR and UR Z10.2 differ on the trigger age of the in-service hull girder check for bulk carriers, 10 or 15 years.
- UR Z10.4 does not state whether its Annex III check applies to CSR double hull tankers in addition to CSR Ch 13.
- IACS Rec 96 Rev.2 writes the CSR band as tnet + 0.5 mm to tnet and does not define tnet in that clause.
- MSC.288(87) and MSC.289(87) are cited by title only.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is a corrosion addition?
A corrosion addition is the thickness added to the net scantling of a member to allow for wastage in service.
The CSR calculates it as tc = Roundup0.5(tc1 + tc2) + tres (CSR Pt 1 Ch 3 Sec 3 [1.2.1]). The reserve tres is 0.5 mm.
What is the reserve thickness tres?
tres is a reserve of 0.5 mm that the CSR adds to every corrosion addition, after the one-side values are summed and rounded.
How is the CSR corrosion addition rounded?
The sum of the one-side values is rounded up to the upper half millimetre, then tres is added.
CSR Pt 1 Ch 3 Sec 3 states that Roundup0.5(t) means that t is rounded to the upper half millimetre.
What is the minimum corrosion addition?
2 mm, under CSR Pt 1 Ch 3 Sec 3 [1.2.2].
The minimum is 1.5 mm for stiffener webs and face plates and for the internals of dry spaces. The minima do not apply to stainless steel, clad steel or aluminum.
What is the largest one-side value in CSR Table 1?
5.2 mm. The value applies to the sloping, vertical and top plates of the lower stool in a dry bulk hold.
The ship is BC-A or BC-B with a freeboard length of 150 m or more.
Does the corrosion addition depend on steel strength?
No. CSR Pt 1 Ch 3 Sec 3 [1.1.1] applies the values to carbon-manganese steel with no distinction by grade.
Stainless steel and aluminum take tc = tres = 0.5 mm.
What is the 3 m rule in CSR Table 1?
Members within 3 m below the top of a tank take a higher one-side value.
Table 1 note 4 limits the rule to tanks whose top is the weather deck.
What does a heated tank add to the corrosion addition?
0.5 mm on the ballast side of a boundary with a heated cargo or slop tank (CSR Table 1 notes).
The addition is 0.7 mm next to a heated fuel or lubricating oil tank.
What is the gross offered thickness?
The as-built thickness less any thickness voluntarily added by the owner or builder.
CSR Pt 1 Ch 3 Sec 2 [1.2] gives tgr_off = tas_built − tvol_add.
Is the owner's extra thickness credited in the rule checks?
No.
The CSR takes it as tvol_add, which is excluded from compliance with the rules and from the renewal criterion.
Is the design production margin a corrosion margin?
No.
The CSR states that the design production margin tdm is not to be considered as an additional corrosion margin.
Which checks deduct the full corrosion addition?
Minimum thickness, local strength and buckling checks (CSR Pt 1 Ch 3 Sec 2 Table 1).
These include primary supporting member stiffness, proportions and buckling, finite element buckling and hull girder buckling.
Which checks deduct half the corrosion addition?
Checks of global behavior (CSR Pt 1 Ch 3 Sec 2 Table 1).
These are primary supporting member section properties, finite element strength analysis, hull girder section properties, ultimate and residual strength, and fatigue.
What is the difference between local and global corrosion?
CSR Pt 1 Ch 3 Sec 2 [1.1.2] defines local corrosion as uniform corrosion of local structural elements, such as a single plate or stiffener.
Global corrosion is the average corrosion of larger areas, such as primary supporting members and the hull girder.
What is the renewal thickness?
The renewal thickness is the thickness below which a member is renewed.
CSR Pt 1 Ch 13 Sec 2 [2.1.1] gives tren = tas-built − tc − tvol_add.
What thickness must a renewed insert have?
At least tas-built − tvol_add (CSR Pt 1 Ch 13 Sec 2 [2.1.2]).
The steel is of the same or greater grade and yield stress as the original.
What is substantial corrosion?
UR Z7, Z10.1, Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5 define it as wastage in excess of 75% of allowable margins, but within acceptable limits.
For CSR ships, UR Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5 define it as a measured thickness between tren + 0.5 mm and tren.
What happens to a substantial corrosion area on a CSR bulk carrier?
UR Z10.2 2.4.2 allows two options: protect it with coating and examine it at annual intervals, or measure it at annual intervals.
What happens to a substantial corrosion area on a CSR tanker?
UR Z10.4 requires the areas to be examined and additional thickness measurements to be carried out.
What is a suspect area?
A location showing substantial corrosion, or one the surveyor considers prone to rapid wastage (UR Z7, Z10.1, Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5).
What are the pitting limits on a CSR ship?
For pitting intensity under 20%, UR Z10.4 8.2.1 sets a minimum measured thickness.
The minimum is the lesser of 0.7 (tas-built − tvol add) and tren − 1 mm. The average across the section is not to fall below tren.
What are the grooving limits on a CSR ship?
For grooves up to 15% of web height and 30 mm, the lesser of 0.75 (tas-built − tvol add) and tren − 0.5 mm.
The thickness is never less than 6 mm (UR Z10.4 8.4.1).
When is the hull girder strength of a CSR ship checked in service?
CSR Pt 1 Ch 13 Sec 2 [2.2.1] requires the evaluation for ships over 10 years of age, at the special surveys.
UR Z10.2 and Z10.5 9.1.1.1 use 15 years or Special Survey No.3 for CSR bulk carriers.
What is the 90% rule?
The current section modulus at deck and bottom is not to be less than 90% of the gross offered modulus (CSR Pt 1 Ch 13 Sec 2 [2.2.2]).
The current modulus uses the measured thicknesses. Alternatively the deck and bottom zone areas are not to be less than 90%.
What renewal criteria apply to a non-CSR ship?
The rules of the individual classification society and specific IACS URs.
UR Z10.2 8.1.2 names UR S18, S19, S21 and S31 for bulk carriers.
What does UR S31 set for side frames?
UR S31 Rev.4 renews a side frame web where the measured thickness is at or below tREN. tREN is the greatest of tCOAT − tC, 0.75 tAB, a slenderness criterion and a strength criterion, with tCOAT = 0.75 tS12.
Which ballast tanks need protective coating under SOLAS?
SOLAS II-1/3-2, from MSC.216(82), requires coating to MSC.215(82) in all dedicated seawater ballast tanks of ships of 500 GT and over.
The double-side skin spaces of bulk carriers of 150 m and over are also coated. The regulation applies to ships contracted on or after 1 July 2008, keel laid on or after 1 January 2009, or delivered on or after 1 July 2012.
What coating life does the PSPC target?
MSC.215(82) 4.1 sets a target useful coating life of 15 years in GOOD condition.
How are crude oil tanker cargo tanks protected?
SOLAS II-1/3-11, from MSC.291(87), applies to crude oil tankers of 5,000 dwt and over.
The cargo oil tanks are coated to MSC.288(87), or protected by an alternative means or corrosion resistant steel to MSC.289(87). The regulation applies to ships contracted on or after 1 January 2013, keel laid on or after 1 July 2013, or delivered on or after 1 January 2016.
When are thicknesses measured at survey?
At each special survey, to an extent that grows with age.
UR Z7 Table 1 and UR Z10.2 Table II set the age bands. The bands are up to 5 years, 5 to 10, 10 to 15, and over 15 years.
Must the renewal thickness be on board?
Yes.
CSR Pt 1 Ch 13 Sec 1 [1.3.1] requires the plans on board to show the as-built and renewal thicknesses and any tvol_add.
Is excessive corrosion a defined term?
No. UR Z7, Z10.1, Z10.2, Z10.4 and Z10.5 define substantial corrosion, not excessive corrosion.
Below the renewal thickness, the member is renewed.
No question matches. Try a shorter or different word.
Sources
- IACS CSR BC&OT (1 January 2024 with 1 July 2025 Corrigenda). Common Structural Rules for Bulk Carriers and Oil Tankers iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IACS UR Z10.1 Rev.25 (Feb 2023). Hull Surveys of Oil Tankers iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IACS UR Z10.2 Rev.37 (Feb 2023). Hull Surveys of Bulk Carriers iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IACS UR Z10.4 Rev.18 (Feb 2023). Hull Surveys of Double Hull Oil Tankers iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IACS UR S18 Rev.10 (March 2019). Evaluation of Scantlings of Corrugated Transverse Watertight Bulkheads in Non-CSR Bulk Carriers Considering Hold Flooding iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IACS UR S7 Rev.4 (May 2010). Minimum Longitudinal Strength Standards iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IACS UR Z10.5 Rev.20 (February 2023). Hull Surveys of Double Skin Bulk Carriers iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IACS UR Z7 Rev.29 Corr.1 (May 2024). Hull Classification Surveys iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IACS UR S31 Rev.4 (April 2007). Renewal Criteria for Side Shell Frames and Brackets in Single Side Skin Bulk Carriers iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IACS Rec 96 Rev.2 (May 2023). Double Hull Oil Tankers, Guidelines for Surveys, Assessment and Repair of Hull Structures iacs.s3.af-south-1.amazonaws.com
- IMO Resolution MSC.216(82). Amendments to SOLAS, including regulation II-1/3-2 (adopted 8 December 2006) imo.org
- IMO Resolution MSC.215(82). Performance Standard for Protective Coatings (adopted 8 December 2006) imo.org
- IMO Resolution MSC.291(87). SOLAS regulation II-1/3-11, Corrosion Protection of Cargo Oil Tanks (adopted 21 May 2010) imo.org