Damage Stability: Rules and Criteria by Ship Type
Damage stability is a ship's ability to survive flooding after collision or grounding. SOLAS, MARPOL, IBC, IGC and Load Line regimes compared by ship type.
Contents12 sections
Damage stability is the ability of a ship to remain afloat, upright and within prescribed heel and righting-lever limits after one or more watertight compartments are flooded by collision, grounding or structural failure. It is proved by calculation at design approval, not by test, and the governing standard depends on the ship type: SOLAS Chapter II-1 for passenger ships and dry cargo ships of 80 m and upwards, MARPOL Annex I Regulation 28 for oil tankers, the IBC Code and IGC Code for chemical and gas carriers, and Regulation 27 of the Load Line Convention for Type A and reduced-freeboard Type B ships.
Two methods run side by side. The deterministic method assumes a fixed damage and requires survival in every case. The probabilistic method of SOLAS, harmonized for passenger and cargo ships by MSC.216(82) from 1 January 2009 and revised by MSC.421(98) from 1 January 2020, sums the likelihood of survival over all damages into an attained index that must reach a required one. The detail of that index is in probabilistic damage stability; this article sets out which regime governs which ship, what each assumes and requires, how compliance reaches the bridge, and which casualties changed the rules.
| Ship type | Governing rule | Method | Damage assumed | Pass condition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Passenger ship, any length | SOLAS II-1 Parts B-1 to B-4 (MSC.421(98) for ships contracted from 1 January 2020, keel laid from 1 July 2020 or delivered from 1 January 2024) | Probabilistic | Side damage distribution of Reg 7-1, bottom damage Reg 9 | A at least R; As, Ap, Al at least 0.9R |
| Dry cargo ship, 80 m and upwards | SOLAS II-1 Parts B-1 to B-4 | Probabilistic | As above | A at least R; partial indices at least 0.5R |
| Bulk carrier, 150 m and upwards | SOLAS XII Reg 4 and 5 (MSC.170(79)), on top of Part B-1 | Deterministic overlay | Any one cargo hold flooded | Equilibrium per A.320(IX) as amended by A.514(13), plus hull strength |
| Oil tanker, 150 GT and above, delivered after 31 December 1979 | MARPOL Annex I Reg 28 (MEPC.117(52)) | Deterministic | Side or bottom, B/5 or 11.5 m | Heel 25 deg (30 deg); range 20 deg; GZ 0.1 m; area 0.0175 m-rad |
| Chemical tanker | IBC Code chapter 2 (MSC.176(79)) | Deterministic | Location set by ship type 1, 2 or 3 | Same criteria as Reg 28 |
| Gas carrier | IGC Code chapter 2 (MSC.370(93)) | Deterministic | Location set by type 1G, 2G, 2PG or 3G | Reg 28 criteria; 20 deg range may start anywhere up to 25 deg (30 deg) |
| Type A or B-60/B-100 freeboard | Load Line Reg 27 (MSC.143(77)) | Deterministic | One compartment, or two for B-100 | Heel 15 deg (17 deg); GM positive |
| Polar category A or B, built from 2017 | Polar Code I-A 4.3.2 (MSC.385(94)) | Deterministic overlay | Ice damage, 760 mm penetration | s = 1 in every loading condition |
| High-speed craft | 2000 HSC Code chapter 2 (MSC.97(73)) | Deterministic | Extents scaled on displacement volume | Code residual stability criteria |
The table is a Shipping-Wiki.com summary drawn from the instruments named in each row. A ship’s own approved stability documentation, not this table, states which text applies to it by its construction date.
What damage stability measures
Damage stability measures what is left of a ship’s buoyancy and righting ability once the sea is inside the hull. A breach floods one or more spaces, and the ship sinks bodily and takes on trim and list; and the flooded water’s free surface reduces the metacentric height. The question every regime asks is whether the resulting GZ curve still carries enough range, lever and area for the ship to resist wind and waves while it is evacuated or brought to port.
Two calculation conventions exist for the flooded ship. The lost-buoyancy method treats the damaged compartment as no longer part of the hull, keeps displacement constant, and recomputes the waterplane. The added-weight method treats floodwater as cargo of the ship. Both give the same equilibrium position and the same righting moment, but because they work from different displacements they report different values of both GM and GZ, so a damage calculation states which method it used.
Damage stability and intact stability
Intact stability judges the undamaged ship, chiefly against the 2008 IS Code minimum GZ areas and the severe wind and rolling criterion. Damage stability starts where those calculations stop, with the hull opened. The two are approved separately and combined only at the end, when Regulation 5-1 of SOLAS II-1 turns the minimum GM values assumed at the three damage calculation drafts into a limiting GM or KG curve, which the stability booklet and loading computer checks for every departure condition.
The governing curve is the more onerous of the intact and damage limits at each draft, so a loading condition can pass every intact criterion and still breach the damage limit.
Subdivision, watertight boundaries and progressive flooding
Subdivision is the arrangement of watertight bulkheads and decks that limits how much of the hull one breach can flood; damage stability is the test of whether that arrangement is good enough. The design rules for bulkhead spacing, the classic floodable-length curves and their history are in subdivision and floodable length.
A watertight boundary holds the full head of water that flooding applies to it. A weathertight one only keeps out sea and spray in normal service. The distinction decides whether an opening is a flooding path: an air pipe head, a ventilator or a weathertight door that lies below the damaged waterline, or that goes under during the heel, admits water to spaces the damage did not reach. That is progressive flooding, and every regime controls it, from MARPOL Regulation 28.3.1, which requires the final waterline to stay below any opening through which progressive flooding may take place, to the SOLAS rule that sets the survival factor to zero when such openings immerse.
Watertight doors and closures are where design and operation meet: their position in the subdivision, their remote closing and their status at sea are all inputs to the calculation, and the collision bulkhead forward is a fixed boundary that no regime lets the designer omit.
Permeability
Permeability is the fraction of a space’s moulded volume that floodwater can occupy, and it sets both how much water enters and how large the free-surface moment becomes. SOLAS II-1 Regulation 7-3 fixes the values used in the index:
| Space | Permeability (SOLAS II-1 Reg 7-3) |
|---|---|
| Accommodation, voids | 0.95 |
| Machinery | 0.85 |
| Stores | 0.60 |
| Dry cargo and container spaces | 0.70 at ds, 0.80 at dp, 0.95 at dl |
| Ro-ro spaces | 0.90, 0.90, 0.95 |
Regulation 7-3.3 allows other values only where calculations substantiate them. The deterministic regimes use 0.95 for most spaces and 0.85 for machinery (Load Line Regulation 27(3), IBC 2.7.2), and SOLAS XII Regulation 4.4 uses 0.9 for a loaded bulk carrier hold and 0.95 for an empty one.
Deterministic and probabilistic methods
A deterministic rule fixes the damage and demands survival from every case; the probabilistic rule weights every plausible damage by its likelihood and demands a minimum overall chance of survival. Neither is more accurate by nature. The deterministic method is transparent and easy to audit, and it still governs every tanker. The probabilistic method rewards the arrangement that a fixed damage rule cannot see, such as a wing bulkhead that stops most collisions short of a cargo hold.
The deterministic method
A deterministic regime has three parts: a damage extent (length, penetration and height), a set of locations where that damage must be assumed, and survival criteria for the flooded equilibrium and its intermediate stages. MARPOL Regulation 28 is the template. Its side damage runs \( \tfrac{1}{3}L^{2/3} \) or 14.5 m along the ship, whichever is less, and B/5 or 11.5 m inboard, whichever is less, at the level of the summer-load-line, from the moulded bottom line upward without limit. The same extents appear in MARPOL Annex I Regulation 24 for outflow assumptions, IBC Code 2.5.1, IGC Code 2.3.1 and Load Line Regulation 27(12).
The older passenger-ship form of the deterministic method worked on floodable length: the length of compartment that could flood without submerging the margin line, a line below the upper surface of the bulkhead-deck at the side, at least 76 mm (3 in) below it in the US form of 46 CFR 171.015. The permissible compartment length was the floodable length multiplied by a factor of subdivision that fell as length and passenger numbers rose. US rules keep the margin line in 46 CFR 171.015 for US passenger vessels under Subchapter S. For SOLAS passenger ships, the floodable-length method ended for ships built from 1 January 2009.
The probabilistic method
The SOLAS probabilistic method computes an attained subdivision index A as the sum, over every damage case, of the probability that the damage occurs and the probability that the ship survives it. It is evaluated at three drafts, the deepest subdivision draft ds, the partial subdivision draft dp = dl + 0.6(ds - dl), and the light service draft dl, and combined as A = 0.4As + 0.4Ap + 0.2Al. A must be at least the required index R, and each partial index at least 0.9R on a passenger ship or 0.5R on a cargo ship (SOLAS II-1 Regulation 6.1).
Three factors build each case. The factor p, from Regulation 7-1, is the probability that a side collision opens a given zone or group of adjacent zones, with transverse penetration carried by an r-factor in which the distance b to a longitudinal bulkhead is taken no greater than B/2. The factor v, from Regulation 7-2.6, is the probability that the damage does not extend above a given horizontal boundary; it rises from zero to 1 between the draft and 12.5 m above it. The factor s, from Regulation 7-2, is the probability of survival once the case floods:
s_final (Reg 7-2.3)
where
| \(GZ_{max}\) | Maximum positive righting lever within the range, not taken above TGZ_{max} | m |
| \(TGZ_{max}\) | Target GZ: 0.12 m, or 0.20 m for ro-ro passenger ship damage cases involving a ro-ro space | m |
| \(Range\) | Range of positive righting levers from the equilibrium angle, not taken above TRange | deg |
| \(TRange\) | Target range: 16 deg, or 20 deg for ro-ro passenger ship damage cases involving a ro-ro space | deg |
| \(K\) | Heel factor: 1 if theta_e is at or below theta_min, 0 if at or above theta_max | dimensionless |
| \(\theta_e\) | Equilibrium heel angle in the final flooding stage | deg |
| \(\theta_{min}, \theta_{max}\) | 7 and 15 deg for passenger ships, 25 and 30 deg for cargo ships | deg |
Source: SOLAS II-1 Reg 7-2.3 (MSC.216(82), as amended by MSC.421(98))
The targets in that formula are 0.12 m of GZ and 16 degrees of range, or 0.20 m and 20 degrees for a ro-ro passenger ship damage case involving a ro-ro space (Regulation 7-2.3, 2020 text). The heel factor K tapers s to zero between 25 and 30 degrees on a cargo ship and between 7 and 15 degrees on a passenger ship. Passenger ships must also hold a GZ of at least 0.05 m over at least 7 degrees through each intermediate stage of flooding.
R depends on ship type. For a cargo ship over 100 m in subdivision length Ls, R = 1 - 128/(Ls + 152), giving 0.636 at 200 m; a separate formula in Regulation 6.2.2 covers 80 m to 100 m and gives 0.394 at 80 m. For a passenger ship under the MSC.421(98) text R depends only on the number of persons on board: 0.722 below 400, about 0.801 at 1,000, about 0.876 at 3,000 and about 0.901 at 6,000 (Regulation 6.2.3). The full derivation of each factor, with the constants of Regulation 7-1, is in the probabilistic damage stability article and the explanatory notes.
Bottom damage is not in A. SOLAS II-1 Regulation 9 handles it through a double bottom requirement, with an assumed bottom damage check where the double bottom is omitted or reduced.
How the two methods developed
SOLAS was first adopted in 1914, in response to the loss of the Titanic, and was followed by new conventions in 1929, 1948 and 1960 and the present SOLAS Convention, adopted 1 November 1974 and in force 25 May 1980.
The probabilistic route opened in 1973. Assembly resolution A.265(VIII), adopted 20 November 1973, set regulations on the subdivision and stability of passenger ships as an equivalent to Part B of Chapter II of SOLAS 1960, with a required index that rose with ship length and persons carried. It was optional: an Administration could accept it in place of the deterministic Part B.
| Instrument | Adopted | In force | What it did |
|---|---|---|---|
| A.265(VIII) | 20 November 1973 | Equivalent, not mandatory | Probabilistic passenger-ship subdivision as an alternative to SOLAS 1960 Part B |
| MSC.12(56), SOLAS 90 | 28 October 1988 | 29 April 1990 | Deterministic passenger-ship residual stability: range 15 deg, area 0.015 m-rad |
| MSC.19(58) | 25 May 1990 | 1 February 1992 | Probabilistic Part B-1 for dry cargo ships over 100 m |
| MSC.47(66) | 4 June 1996 | 1 July 1998 | Part B-1 extended to cargo ships of 80 m to 100 m |
| MSC.216(82) | 8 December 2006 | 1 January 2009 | Harmonized probabilistic Parts B to B-4 for passenger and cargo ships |
| MSC.421(98) | 15 June 2017 | 1 January 2020 | New passenger R by persons; revised s-factor; ships contracted from 1 January 2020 |
| MSC.474(102) | 11 November 2020 | 1 January 2024 | Watertight integrity; s = 0 where an unprotected opening immerses at an intermediate stage |
The SOLAS 90 standard applied to passenger ships only. Cargo ships went probabilistic first, in 1992, 17 years before passenger ships did under MSC.216(82). The MSC.421(98) text applies to ships with a building contract on or after 1 January 2020, or keel laid on or after 1 July 2020 where there is no contract, or delivered on or after 1 January 2024 (Regulation 1.1.1). A ship built between 2009 and that window stays on the MSC.216(82) text as amended by MSC.269(85) and MSC.325(90).
Damage stability by ship type
The ship type decides the regime before any calculation starts. SOLAS II-1 Regulation 4.2.1.2 allows the Administration to exclude from Regulations 6 to 7-3 a cargo ship shown to comply with the subdivision and damage stability rules of another IMO instrument: MARPOL Annex I, the IBC Code, the IGC Code, or Load Line Regulation 27. The exclusion does not cover combination carriers with Type B freeboards, or Load Line Regulation 27 ships intended to carry deck cargo, which must meet SOLAS as well.
Passenger ships
Every passenger ship under SOLAS, whatever its length, is assessed by the probabilistic index, and its R is set by persons on board rather than length under the 2020 text. The 0.9R partial-index floor means a cruise ship can offset a weaker draft with surplus at another only as far as each partial index stays at or above 0.9R. Survival also depends on keeping essential systems running: SOLAS II-1 Regulation 8-1.2 requires passenger ships constructed on or after 1 July 2010 of 120 m or more, or with three or more main vertical zones, to keep the systems listed in SOLAS II-2/21.4 operational after flooding of any single watertight compartment, which ties damage stability to safe return to port.
Lightship weight changes with every refit, and the damage calculation is only as good as the KG it started from. SOLAS II-1 Regulation 5.5 requires a lightweight survey at intervals not exceeding five years, with a fresh inclining where lightship displacement has changed by more than 2 percent or the longitudinal center of gravity by more than 1 percent of L; the procedure is covered in inclining experiment and lightweight survey.
Ro-ro passenger ships and water on deck
A ro-ro vessel carrying passengers has a long, open vehicle deck close to the waterline, and water spread across it carries a free-surface moment large enough to capsize the ship before any space below has flooded, which is what happened to the Herald of Free Enterprise in 1987. SOLAS answers through the higher s-factor targets for damage cases involving a ro-ro space. It does not model water on deck.
That calculation is regional. The Stockholm Agreement, concluded in February 1996 under SOLAS 95 Conference Resolution 14 and in force from 1 April 1997 for eight north-west European states, adds a layer of water on the vehicle deck after damage: 0.5 m where residual freeboard is 0.3 m or less, none where it is 2.0 m or more, interpolated between, and scaled to the significant wave height of the route between 1.5 m and 4.0 m. Directive 2003/25/EC of 14 April 2003 made that standard EU law for ro-ro passenger ships on regular international services to or from EU ports. Directive (EU) 2023/946 of 10 May 2023 revised it for ships with keel laid on or after 5 December 2024: above 1,350 persons they follow SOLAS 2020, and at 1,350 or fewer they choose between water on deck and an EU required index. The EU overlay and its amendments are in Directive 2003/25/EC.
Domestic passenger ships in the EU follow Directive 2009/45/EC: Class A ships meet SOLAS, and Classes B, C and D meet the deterministic Regulation 8 requirements set in the original text of that Directive.
Dry cargo ships and container ships
Dry cargo ships of 80 m in length and upwards, including the container ship, the general cargo ship and the car carrier, are assessed by the probabilistic index with the cargo R. Below 80 m SOLAS sets no Part B-1 calculation, and any standard comes from the flag state, the class society or another instrument.
The 0.5R partial-index floor is far lower than the passenger 0.9R. For a container ship the inputs that move A most are the length and number of holds, the width of the double side, and the permeability of the container holds, 0.70 at the deep draft. A deck stow also raises KG, so the same subdivision can pass at one stack weight distribution and fail at another, through the limiting GM curve.
Bulk carriers under SOLAS XII
A bulk carrier of 80 m and upwards meets the cargo index like any dry cargo ship, and SOLAS Chapter XII adds a deterministic one-hold test on top. Under Regulation 4, in the text of MSC.170(79) adopted 9 December 2004 and in force 1 July 2006, bulk carriers of 150 m and upwards designed for cargo of 1,000 kg/m3 and above must survive flooding of any one cargo hold in all loading conditions where they are:
- single-side skin ships constructed on or after 1 July 1999 (Regulation 4.1), or
- double-side skin ships constructed on or after 1 July 2006 in which any part of a longitudinal bulkhead lies within B/5 or 11.5 m of the side (Regulation 4.2).
Single-side skin ships built before 1 July 1999 and carrying cargo of 1,780 kg/m3 and above need only survive flooding of the foremost hold (Regulation 4.3). The hold floods to the outside water level, at a permeability of 0.9 loaded and 0.95 empty, and the equilibrium must meet A.320(IX) as amended by A.514(13) (Regulation 4.4).
Regulation 5 adds the structural half: the same ships must have hull strength to withstand flooding of any one hold in all loading and ballast conditions, including the dynamic effect of water in the hold. For bulk carriers outside the IACS Common Structural Rules, the hull girder check is IACS UR S17, longitudinal strength of the hull girder in the flooded condition. UR S17 is a strength rule, not a damage stability rule.
Oil tankers under MARPOL Annex I Regulation 28
Every oil tanker of 150 GT and above delivered after 31 December 1979 meets the deterministic standard of MARPOL Annex I Regulation 28, in the revised Annex adopted by MEPC.117(52) on 15 October 2004 and in force 1 January 2007. The ship must survive the side damage set out above, and a bottom damage, in every loading condition. After flooding:
- heel must not exceed 25 degrees, or 30 degrees if no deck edge immerses;
- the residual GZ curve must have a range of at least 20 degrees beyond equilibrium;
- the maximum residual GZ within that range must be at least 0.1 m; and
- the area under the curve within the range must be at least 0.0175 m-rad.
Regulation 28.3.5 gives no credit for equalization arrangements that need valves or cross-levelling pipes, and the final waterline must stay below any opening through which progressive flooding may take place (28.3.1). Regulation 28 is a survival standard only. How much oil escapes is a separate question for the double hull of Regulation 19 and the accidental oil outflow index of Regulation 23. The full regulation, its bottom damage table and its intermediate-stage provisions are in the Regulation 28 article.
Chemical tankers under the IBC Code
A chemical tanker meets chapter 2 of the IBC Code, whose 2.5.1 extents and 2.9 survival criteria match MARPOL Regulation 28. What differs is where damage must be assumed, which IBC Code 2.8.1 sets by ship type and length:
| IBC ship type | Length | Damage assumed (IBC 2.8.1) |
|---|---|---|
| Type 1 | Any | Anywhere in the length |
| Type 2 | Over 150 m | Anywhere |
| Type 2 | 150 m or less | Anywhere except either bulkhead bounding an aft machinery space |
| Type 3 | Over 225 m | Anywhere |
| Type 3 | 125 m to 225 m | Anywhere except either bulkhead bounding an aft machinery space |
| Type 3 | Below 125 m | Anywhere except damage to an aft machinery space |
Tank location is the second line of defense. IBC 2.6.1 places type 1 cargo tanks inboard of the B/5 or 11.5 m side extent and above the bottom damage depth of B/15 or 6 m, and never closer than 760 mm to the shell; type 2 tanks keep the bottom clearance and the 760 mm; type 3 tanks carry no location rule. The ship type itself is assigned per product in IBC chapter 17, so the damage standard follows the most hazardous cargo the ship is certified to carry.
Gas carriers under the IGC Code
Gas carriers built on or after 1 July 2016 meet the 2016 IGC Code adopted by MSC.370(93) on 22 May 2014. Its chapter 2 uses the IBC side extents but a shallower bottom damage, B/15 or 2 m vertically. The gas carrier types map to damage standards in IGC 2.6.1, and the type is assigned per product in IGC chapter 19, so an LNG carrier certified for methane is a type 2G ship:
- Type 1G: damage anywhere in the length.
- Type 2G over 150 m: anywhere; 150 m or less, anywhere except the bulkheads bounding an aft machinery space.
- Type 2PG: 150 m or less, independent type C tanks with MARVS of at least 0.7 MPa gauge and design temperature of minus 55 degrees C or above; anywhere except transverse bulkheads spaced further apart than the longitudinal damage extent.
- Type 3G of 80 m or more: as 2PG; under 80 m, the same plus no damage to an aft machinery space.
The survival criteria match MARPOL Regulation 28, with one relaxation: the 20 degree range may begin anywhere between the equilibrium position and 25 degrees, or 30 degrees where no deck immerses. IGC 2.2.6 requires every gas carrier to carry an approved stability instrument covering intact and damage stability, with ships built before 1 July 2016 fitted by the first scheduled renewal survey after that date and not later than 1 July 2021.
Load Line Type A, B-60 and B-100 ships
A ship with less freeboard has less reserve buoyancy above the damaged waterline, so the Load Line Convention grants a reduced freeboard only against a damage survival test. Regulation 27 of the 1988 Load Lines Protocol, in the revised Annex B adopted by MSC.143(77) on 5 June 2003 and applying to ships with keel laid on or after 1 January 2005, sets four cases:
- A Type A ship over 150 m, a ship designed to carry only liquid cargo in bulk, must withstand flooding of any compartment at a permeability of 0.95, or 0.85 for the machinery space (Regulation 27(3)).
- A Type B ship over 100 m may receive a reduced freeboard if it meets the same flooding test and the crew protection, freeing port and hatch cover provisions (Regulation 27(8)).
- A B-60 ship may reduce its tabular Type B freeboard by not more than 60 percent of the difference between the Type B and Type A tables (Regulation 27(9)).
- A B-100 ship may reduce it by up to the whole difference, provided it meets Type A closure standards under Regulation 26 and survives flooding of two adjacent fore-and-aft compartments, excepting the machinery space boundary bulkheads (Regulation 27(10)).
The damage is from the base line upward without limit and B/5 or 11.5 m inboard (27(12)). After flooding, heel must not exceed 15 degrees, or 17 degrees where no part of the deck immerses; GM must stay positive; and where the deck immerses or the margin is doubtful, the range must be 20 degrees with GZ 0.1 m and area 0.0175 m-rad (27(13)). The heel limit is ten degrees tighter than MARPOL’s 25 degrees, so a tanker’s Load Line and MARPOL checks are separate calculations. Ships built before 1 January 2005 stay on the 1966 Convention text as modified by the 1988 Protocol. Freeboard assignment itself is covered in freeboard and reserve buoyancy.
Polar Code ice damage
The Polar Code, made mandatory under SOLAS by SOLAS Chapter XIV and taking effect 1 January 2017, adds an ice damage case in Part I-A paragraph 4.3.2. It applies to category A and B ships constructed on or after 1 January 2017, and treats both categories alike. The ship must survive ice penetration with a survival factor s equal to 1 for every loading condition used in the attained index; a cargo ship that meets another instrument instead of the SOLAS index meets that instrument’s residual criteria.
The ice damage is long and shallow. Its longitudinal extent is 4.5 percent of the upper ice waterline length where the damage is centered forward of the maximum breadth on that waterline, or 1.5 percent elsewhere. It penetrates 760 mm normal to the shell, far less than the B/2 limit of the SOLAS collision distribution, and its vertical extent is 20 percent of the upper ice waterline draft or the longitudinal extent, whichever is less, at any position from the keel to 120 percent of that draft. Category C ships and ships built before 2017 carry no ice damage case. The hull’s own ice strengthening is a separate class matter, covered in ice class notations.
High-speed craft
The 2000 HSC Code, adopted by MSC.97(73) on 5 December 2000 and applied through SOLAS Chapter X, scales damage on the craft’s displacement volume V at the design waterline rather than on its length. Under paragraph 2.6.7, side damage runs longitudinally for the least of 0.75V^(1/3), 3 m plus 0.225V^(1/3), or 11 m, and penetrates 0.2V^(1/3) transversely over the full vertical extent; on craft with inflated skirts or non-buoyant side structures, the penetration is at least 0.12V^(1/3) into the main buoyancy hull or tank structure. The HSC Code sets its own residual stability criteria for the flooded craft.
Special purpose ships, offshore supply vessels and drilling units
The Special Purpose Ships Code (MSC.266(84), adopted 13 May 2008) applies the SOLAS index to research, training and similar ships with an R tied to persons on board: the full passenger R for 240 or more, and 0.8R for 60 or fewer; the special purpose ships code article covers the interpolation between. An offshore supply vessel under US rules meets SOLAS Part B-1 with R multiplied by F = (N + 720)/960 below 240 persons (46 CFR 127.610). A mobile offshore drilling unit is certified under IMO’s MODU Code, which sets damage criteria for column-stabilized, self-elevating and surface units on their own terms, outside SOLAS II-1.
Damage assumptions and survival criteria compared
The deterministic regimes share one damage geometry and differ on where it is applied and how much heel they accept. The table sets the main figures side by side.
| Item | MARPOL I Reg 28 | IBC Code | IGC Code | Load Line Reg 27 | SOLAS XII Reg 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Side damage, length | (1/3)L^(2/3) or 14.5 m | Same | Same | Bulkheads effective if spaced at least this | One hold |
| Side damage, penetration | B/5 or 11.5 m | Same | Same | Same | Hold floods to outside level |
| Bottom damage, depth | Reg 28 table | B/15 or 6 m | B/15 or 2 m | Not assumed | Not assumed |
| Maximum heel | 25 deg (30 deg) | 25 deg (30 deg) | 25 deg (30 deg) | 15 deg (17 deg) | Per A.320(IX) |
| Residual range | 20 deg | 20 deg | 20 deg, may start up to 25 deg | 20 deg where deck immerses | Per A.320(IX) |
| GZ max within range | 0.1 m | 0.1 m | 0.1 m | 0.1 m | Per A.320(IX) |
| Area within range | 0.0175 m-rad | 0.0175 m-rad | 0.0175 m-rad | 0.0175 m-rad | Per A.320(IX) |
The bracketed heel applies where no deck edge immerses. Against those figures, the SOLAS index does not set a single limit at all: s falls to zero at 30 degrees of equilibrium heel on a cargo ship and 15 degrees on a passenger ship, and the targets of 0.12 m and 16 degrees are where s reaches 1, not where it starts.
Cross-flooding arrangements show the regimes at their furthest apart. SOLAS II-1 Regulation 7-2, as amended by MSC.421(98), caps equalization at 10 minutes, and the MSC.429(98) notes treat equalization within 60 seconds, calculated by the method of MSC.362(92) of 14 June 2013, as instantaneous. The deterministic tanker and chemical codes give no credit at all to equalization through valves or cross-levelling pipes. A cross-flooding duct that earns index on a passenger ship earns nothing on a product tanker.
Showing damage stability compliance on board
Damage stability reaches the ship as approved operating limits, plans and, increasingly, software. The master never sees A or R; the master sees a limiting GM or KG curve, a damage control plan and a booklet.
Approval and the stability information
The flag Administration approves the damage stability calculation, almost always through a classification society acting as its recognized organization. Approval yields the limiting curves of SOLAS II-1 Regulation 5-1: minimum operational GM, or maximum KG, and maximum permissible trim against draft, built by linear interpolation of the minimum GM values assumed at ds, dp and dl. The curves sit in the stability booklet with the intact limits, and the stricter of the two governs. Hydrostatic inputs come from the ship’s hydrostatics and Bonjean data and cross curves of stability.
A tanker or gas carrier keeps a further layer. The Administration issues a document of approval for its stability instrument, which port state control officers check under MARPOL Regulation 11 or SOLAS XI-1/4. MSC.1/Circ.1461 of 8 July 2013 sets guidelines for verifying tanker damage stability, Part 1 for tankers constructed on or after 14 June 2013 and Part 2 for the operational checks on all tankers; the topic is covered in tanker damage stability verification.
Damage control plans and booklets
SOLAS II-1 Regulation 19 applies to passenger ships and to all cargo ships, tankers included, since Part B-4 covers every cargo ship (Regulation 4.2.2). It requires plans, permanently exhibited or readily available on the navigation bridge for the guidance of the officer in charge, showing for each deck and hold, the watertight compartment boundaries, the openings in them with their means of closure and the position of the controls, and the arrangements for correcting any list due to flooding. A damage control booklet with the same information goes to the officers. The guidance on content and layout is MSC.1/Circ.1245 of 29 October 2007, and the procedures that use them are in damage control drills and plans.
Passenger ships also drill. SOLAS II-1 Regulation 19-1, added by MSC.421(98) and in force 1 January 2020, requires a damage control drill at least every three months on every passenger ship, whatever its build date, and at least one a year must activate the shore-based support link where the ship has one.
Stability instruments and shore-based support
The trend since 2014 has been to move damage stability from the booklet to an approved computer:
| Ship | Rule | New ships | Existing ships |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oil tanker | MARPOL I Reg 28.6, MEPC.248(66) | From 1 January 2016 | First scheduled renewal survey on or after 1 January 2016, not later than 1 January 2021 |
| Gas carrier | IGC Code 2.2.6, MSC.370(93) | From 1 July 2016 | First scheduled renewal survey after 1 July 2016, not later than 1 July 2021 |
| Chemical tanker | IBC Code 2.2.6, MSC.369(93) | In force 1 January 2016 | Per IBC 2.2.6 |
| Passenger ship, 120 m or 3 or more MVZs | SOLAS II-1 Reg 8-1.3, MSC.325(90) and MSC.436(99) | Built from 1 January 2014 | Not later than the first renewal survey after 1 January 2025 |
A passenger ship may meet Regulation 8-1.3 with either an onboard stability computer or shore-based support that runs the flooded calculation for the master in an emergency. For tankers the instrument requirement is in tanker stability instrument. Regulation 28.6 allows a waiver under Regulation 3.6 where the ship’s loading is fixed, with the alternative means of verification recorded in the IOPP Supplement.
Survey and port state control
Class surveys at renewal confirm that the watertight subdivision, the closing appliances and the lightship remain as approved, and the flag state answers for the outcome under SOLAS Regulation I/6. Port state control under the Paris MoU and the other regional regimes checks the documents and their use: an unapproved loading condition, a missing document of approval for a tanker’s stability instrument, or watertight doors found open at sea are grounds for a deficiency and, where they make the ship unsafe, detention under port state control procedures.
Regional damage stability overlays: EU and US
The IMO instruments set the baseline, and the EU and the United States add their own damage stability rules on top of it. The EU overlay is covered under ro-ro passenger ships above. The US overlay is broader.
US-flag ships follow 46 CFR Subchapter S, Parts 170 to 174, issued by the US Coast Guard:
- Part 170 sets general stability provisions, including free surface in damage calculations (170.290), and requires SOLAS-certificated ships built from 1 January 2009 to carry MSC.216(82) information (170.140).
- Part 171 covers passenger vessels, with Type I and Type II subdivision, damage standards in 171.080 and the margin line in 171.015.
- Part 172 covers bulk cargoes, with hazardous liquids in Subpart F and liquefied gases in Subpart G.
- Part 173 covers specific vessel uses such as school ships and oceanographic vessels.
- Part 174 covers specific vessel types, among them deck cargo barges, MODUs and offshore supply vessels.
The 46 CFR texts are the ones a USCG plan reviewer applies to a US-flag ship; a foreign-flag ship in US waters is held to its SOLAS, MARPOL and Code certificates.
Casualties that shaped damage stability rules
Three of the casualties below, Herald of Free Enterprise, Estonia and El Faro, lost watertight integrity through a door, a visor or an unsecured opening, and Costa Concordia was lost to hull damage beyond its subdivision standard. Each summary states the findings of the official investigation named, and each ship has its own article.
Herald of Free Enterprise, 1987
The ro-ro passenger ferry Herald of Free Enterprise capsized off Zeebrugge in 1987 with the loss of 188 lives, about four minutes after passing the outer mole, with its bow doors open (UK Department of Transport, Report of Court No. 8074). The hull was not damaged. Water entered the vehicle deck through the open doors, and its free surface removed the ship’s stability in minutes. SOLAS 90 for passenger ships followed within two years.
Estonia, 1994
The MS Estonia sank in the northern Baltic on 28 September 1994 on passage from Tallinn to Stockholm, and 852 of the 989 people on board died. The Joint Accident Investigation Commission of Estonia, Finland and Sweden, in its final report of December 1997, found that the bow visor separated at about 01:15, the starboard side was submerged by about 01:30, and the ship disappeared from radar at about 01:50. At midnight the wind was south-westerly at 15 to 20 m/s with a significant wave height of 3 to 4 m. The loss led directly to the Stockholm Agreement water-on-deck standard.
Costa Concordia, 2012
The cruise ship Costa Concordia struck rocks off Isola del Giglio on 13 January 2012. The Italian Marine Casualties Investigative Body found a breach 53 m long that immediately flooded five contiguous watertight compartments, 4 to 8, which held the propulsion motors, the main diesel generators and the ballast and bilge pumps. The report described the damage as well beyond the survivability standard applicable to the ship according to its keel laying date. Thirty-two people died or were missing.
El Faro, 2015
The US-flag ro-ro container ship El Faro sank on 1 October 2015 northeast of Acklins and Crooked Island, Bahamas, with all 33 people on board. NTSB report MAR-17/01, adopted 12 December 2017, found flooding in a cargo hold from an undetected open watertight scuttle and damaged seawater piping, loss of propulsion from low lube oil pressure under a sustained list, and downflooding through unsecured ventilation closures to the cargo holds. It also found a lack of an approved damage control plan.
The report sets out the ship’s damage stability history. El Faro met a single-compartment standard as built. When lengthened in 1993 it was held to the SOLAS probabilistic requirements that had come into force in 1992, the first US-flag ship so held. Its damage stability was not reassessed when it was converted to a ro-ro container configuration in 2005 and 2006, a change that deepened its draft by about 0.6 m (2 ft).
Sewol, 2014
The Korean ro-ro passenger ferry Sewol capsized in April 2014. Its initiating cause is disputed between successive Korean inquiries, and it is covered in its own article rather than summarized here.
Investigation practice itself is covered in marine casualty investigation.
Recent damage stability amendments and open items
MSC.474(102), adopted 11 November 2020 and in force 1 January 2024, is the most recent SOLAS II-1 damage stability amendment summarized here. For passenger ships with a building contract on or after 1 January 2024, keel laid on or after 1 July 2024 without a contract, or delivered on or after 1 January 2028, the survival factor is zero for any damage case in which an unprotected opening immerses at an intermediate stage of flooding. The same resolution revised the watertight integrity provisions of Chapter II-1.
Three other items bear on current damage stability work:
- MSC.510(105) of 28 April 2022 is the performance standard for search and rescue radar transponders. It amends nothing in Chapter II-1.
- The second-generation intact stability criteria of MSC.1/Circ.1627, dated 10 December 2020, are interim and non-mandatory, cover five intact failure modes, and change no damage rule; see second-generation intact stability criteria and the parametric rolling vulnerability criteria.
- The 2025 deadline under MSC.436(99) for older passenger ships to fit a stability computer or shore-based support falls at each ship’s first renewal survey after 1 January 2025; passenger ship certificates are renewed annually, so every ship caught by the rule has passed that point by early 2026.
Alternative compliance remains open by design. SOLAS II-1 Regulation 4 (paragraph 4.2 in the MSC.216(82) text, renumbered 4.3 by MSC.421(98)) lets the Administration accept an alternative methodology for a particular ship or group of ships where it is satisfied that at least the same degree of safety is achieved.
Limitations
This article summarizes rules for orientation and is not a substitute for the instrument texts or a ship’s approved stability information. The applicable text depends on the ship’s construction date, measured by contract, keel laying or delivery, and three generations of SOLAS II-1 are live in the fleet at once. Several codes summarized here, among them the HSC Code, the MODU Code and the IBC Code transitional provisions, have later amendments not reproduced. Figures from MARPOL Regulation 28 are given in summary; its bottom damage table and intermediate stage provisions are in the Regulation 28 article. Flag administrations can and do set higher standards, especially for domestic passenger ships, and the regional rules described are the EU and US cases only. Casualty summaries state the official findings named and nothing beyond them.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is damage stability?
Damage stability is a ship’s ability to stay afloat, upright and within set heel and righting-lever limits after one or more watertight compartments flood through collision, grounding or hull failure.
It is shown by calculation at design approval, against the regime that applies to the ship type: SOLAS Chapter II-1 for passenger and dry cargo ships, MARPOL Annex I Regulation 28 for oil tankers, the IBC and IGC Codes for chemical and gas carriers, and Load Line Regulation 27 for reduced-freeboard ships.
How does damage stability differ from intact stability?
Intact stability judges the undamaged ship against criteria on its GZ curve, such as the 2008 IS Code minimum areas and the weather criterion.
Damage stability judges the ship after flooding, when added water, lost buoyancy, heel, trim and free surface in the flooded spaces have changed the curve. A ship that passes intact criteria can still fail damage criteria, so both are approved separately and both feed the limiting GM or KG curve the master works to.
What is the difference between deterministic and probabilistic damage stability?
A deterministic rule fixes a damage size and position and requires the ship to survive every such case, for example the B/5 or 11.5 m side damage of MARPOL Regulation 28.
The probabilistic SOLAS method weights thousands of possible damages by their likelihood and sums the chance of survival into an attained index A, which must be at least a required index R. Tankers, chemical and gas carriers and reduced-freeboard ships stay deterministic; passenger ships and dry cargo ships of 80 m and upwards are probabilistic.
Which ships are excluded from the SOLAS probabilistic damage stability regulations?
SOLAS II-1 Regulation 4.2.1.2 allows the Administration to exclude cargo ships shown to comply with the subdivision and damage stability rules of another IMO instrument: MARPOL Annex I for oil tankers, the IBC Code for chemical tankers, the IGC Code for gas carriers, and Load Line Regulation 27 for Type A and reduced-freeboard Type B ships.
Cargo ships under 80 m in length carry no SOLAS Part B-1 calculation at all. Combination carriers with Type B freeboards, and Load Line Regulation 27 ships intended to carry deck cargo, are not excluded.
Why does an oil tanker follow MARPOL Regulation 28 rather than the SOLAS index?
Because MARPOL Annex I Regulation 28, in the revised Annex adopted by MEPC.117(52), already sets a subdivision and damage stability standard for every oil tanker of 150 GT and above delivered after 31 December 1979, and SOLAS II-1 Regulation 4 excludes ships that comply with another IMO instrument.
The tanker must survive a fixed side or bottom damage with heel not over 25 degrees (30 degrees if no deck edge immersion) and a residual GZ curve of 20 degrees range, 0.1 m maximum and 0.0175 m-rad area.
What damage extent do the deterministic tanker and chemical carrier rules assume?
Side damage of (1/3)L^(2/3) or 14.5 m longitudinally, whichever is less, and B/5 or 11.5 m transversely, whichever is less, measured inboard from the side at the summer load line, running vertically from the moulded bottom line upward without limit.
The same figures appear in MARPOL Annex I Regulation 28, IBC Code 2.5.1, IGC Code 2.3.1 and Load Line Regulation 27(12). Bottom damage is assumed separately, with a vertical extent of B/15 or 6 m in the IBC Code and B/15 or 2 m in the IGC Code.
Does the SOLAS probabilistic method use the B/5 penetration?
No. B/5 or 11.5 m is a deterministic extent.
SOLAS II-1 Regulation 7-1 treats transverse penetration as a probability through its r-factor, which weights damage that stops at a longitudinal bulkhead at mean distance b from the shell, with b taken no greater than B/2, against damage that passes it.
What are B-60 and B-100 freeboards?
They are reduced freeboards for Type B ships over 100 m under Load Line Regulation 27, as amended by MSC.143(77).
A B-60 ship’s tabular freeboard may be cut by up to 60 percent of the difference between the Type B and Type A tables, and a B-100 ship by up to the whole difference. In return the ship must survive single-compartment flooding (two adjacent fore-and-aft compartments for B-100) at 0.95 permeability, with heel not over 15 degrees, or 17 degrees if no part of the deck is immersed.
How much heel is allowed after damage?
It depends on the regime. MARPOL Regulation 28, IBC 2.9 and IGC 2.7 allow 25 degrees, or 30 degrees where no deck edge is immersed.
Load Line Regulation 27(13) allows 15 degrees, or 17 degrees with no deck immersion. In the SOLAS index the final-stage survival factor falls to zero once equilibrium heel reaches 30 degrees on a cargo ship or 15 degrees on a passenger ship.
What is the margin line and is it still used?
The margin line is a line drawn below the upper surface of the bulkhead deck at the side, at least 76 mm (3 in) below it under US 46 CFR 171.015, which the final damage waterline must not submerge under a deterministic floodable-length rule.
US rules still use it for passenger vessels under Subchapter S. The harmonized SOLAS index of MSC.216(82) dropped it for ships built from 1 January 2009, replacing it with immersion limits on openings and the survival factor.
What is permeability in damage stability?
Permeability is the fraction of a space’s moulded volume that floodwater can occupy.
SOLAS II-1 Regulation 7-3 fixes 0.95 for accommodation and voids, 0.85 for machinery spaces, 0.60 for stores, and 0.70, 0.80 and 0.95 for dry cargo and container spaces at the deepest, partial and light drafts. The deterministic codes use 0.95 for most spaces and 0.85 for machinery, and SOLAS XII uses 0.9 for a loaded bulk carrier hold.
What does a bulk carrier have to survive under SOLAS XII?
SOLAS XII Regulation 4, in the text of MSC.170(79) in force 1 July 2006, requires bulk carriers of 150 m and upwards designed for cargo of 1,000 kg/m3 or more to survive flooding of any one cargo hold in all loading conditions, if single-side skin and built on or after 1 July 1999, or double-side skin with a longitudinal bulkhead within B/5 or 11.5 m of the side and built on or after 1 July 2006.
Regulation 5 adds the matching hull-strength requirement for the flooded hold.
Is IACS UR S17 a damage stability rule?
No. IACS Unified Requirement S17 sets the longitudinal strength of the hull girder in the flooded condition for non-CSR bulk carriers, which is the structural counterpart of the SOLAS XII Regulation 5 requirement.
The survival calculation itself is SOLAS XII Regulation 4.
What do the IBC Code ship types 1, 2 and 3 mean for damage stability?
They set where the damage is assumed.
Under IBC Code 2.8.1, a type 1 ship must survive damage anywhere in its length. A type 2 ship over 150 m must survive damage anywhere, and one of 150 m or less anywhere except at the bulkheads bounding an aft machinery space. A type 3 ship over 225 m must survive damage anywhere; from 125 to 225 m anywhere except those bulkheads; and below 125 m anywhere except in the aft machinery space itself.
What is a 2PG gas carrier?
Under IGC Code 2.1.2, a type 2PG ship is a gas carrier of 150 m or less carrying products in independent type C tanks with a MARVS of at least 0.7 MPa gauge and a containment design temperature of minus 55 degrees C or above.
Under IGC 2.6.1 it must survive damage anywhere in its length except to transverse bulkheads spaced further apart than the assumed longitudinal damage extent. A ship meeting the tank conditions but over 150 m is type 2G.
What ice damage does the Polar Code assume?
Polar Code Part I-A paragraph 4.3.2 requires category A and B ships constructed on or after 1 January 2017 to survive ice damage with a survival factor s of 1 in every loading condition used for the attained index.
The damage is 4.5 percent of the upper ice waterline length if centered forward of maximum breadth (1.5 percent elsewhere), 760 mm of transverse penetration normal to the shell, and a vertical extent of 20 percent of the upper ice waterline draft or the longitudinal extent, whichever is less.
Does the Polar Code ice damage rule apply to category C ships?
No. Paragraph 4.3.2 of the Polar Code covers category A and B ships constructed on or after 1 January 2017 only.
A category C ship, or an older category A or B ship, meets its ordinary SOLAS, MARPOL, IBC or IGC damage standard with no ice damage case added.
Does SOLAS require a water-on-deck calculation for ro-ro passenger ships?
No. SOLAS II-1 handles ro-ro passenger ships through higher survival targets in the index, a GZ of 0.20 m and range of 20 degrees for damage cases involving a ro-ro space.
Water on deck is a regional overlay: the 1996 Stockholm Agreement and EU Directive 2003/25/EC add up to 0.5 m of water on the vehicle deck for ships on regular international services to or from EU ports.
What is a damage control plan and who must carry one?
SOLAS II-1 Regulation 19 requires passenger ships and all cargo ships, tankers included, to have plans, permanently exhibited or readily available on the navigation bridge, showing the watertight boundaries, the openings in them with their means of closure, and the arrangements for correcting any list due to flooding, together with a damage control booklet for the officers.
IMO guidance on their content is MSC.1/Circ.1245 of 29 October 2007. NTSB report MAR-17/01 named the lack of an approved damage control plan on El Faro as a factor in its loss.
Must an oil tanker carry a stability instrument?
Yes. MARPOL Annex I Regulation 28.6, added by MEPC.248(66) of 4 April 2014 and in force 1 January 2016, requires every oil tanker to carry an approved stability instrument able to verify intact and damage stability.
Tankers built before 1 January 2016 had to fit one by the first scheduled renewal survey on or after that date, and not later than 1 January 2021, unless waived under Regulation 3.6 with the alternative recorded in the IOPP Supplement.
Which passenger ships need an onboard stability computer or shore-based support?
SOLAS II-1 Regulation 8-1.3 covers passenger ships of 120 m in length or more, or with three or more main vertical zones.
Ships built on or after 1 January 2014 were caught by MSC.325(90). MSC.436(99) extended the rule to ships built before 1 January 2014, which must comply not later than the first renewal survey after 1 January 2025.
How often must passenger ships hold damage control drills?
At least every three months, under SOLAS II-1 Regulation 19-1 added by MSC.421(98) and in force 1 January 2020.
It applies to every passenger ship whatever its build date, and at least one drill a year must activate the shore-based support link where the ship has one.
Does deck cargo or a change in lightship weight affect damage stability?
Yes, through the ship’s KG. The approved damage calculation produces a minimum GM or maximum KG curve (SOLAS II-1 Regulation 5-1), so any added weight high in the ship, from deck cargo to an unrecorded lightship increase, uses up the margin the subdivision earned.
That is why SOLAS II-1 Regulation 5 requires a lightweight survey on passenger ships at intervals not exceeding five years.
Does cross-flooding count in damage stability?
Only within limits. SOLAS II-1 Regulation 7-2 as amended by MSC.421(98) caps equalization time at 10 minutes, and the MSC.429(98) explanatory notes treat equalization completed within 60 seconds as instantaneous.
The deterministic codes are stricter: MARPOL Regulation 28.3.5 and IBC 2.7.6 give no credit for equalization that needs valves or cross-levelling pipes.
What did El Faro reveal about cargo ship damage stability?
NTSB report MAR-17/01 found El Faro, a US-flag ro-ro container ship lost on 1 October 2015 with all 33 aboard, flooded through an open watertight scuttle and damaged seawater piping, then downflooded through unsecured ventilation closures.
The ship had been held to the 1992 SOLAS probabilistic standard when lengthened in 1993, but damage stability was not reassessed for its 2005 to 2006 conversion, and it lacked an approved damage control plan.
Why did Costa Concordia sink if it met its subdivision standard?
Because the damage exceeded what the standard was built to survive.
The Italian Marine Casualties Investigative Body found a 53 m breach that flooded five contiguous watertight compartments, numbers 4 to 8, holding the propulsion motors, main generators and bilge pumps. It described the damage as well beyond the survivability standard applicable to the ship by its keel laying date. The report lists 32 dead or missing.
What damage does the HSC Code assume?
The 2000 HSC Code (MSC.97(73)) paragraph 2.6.7 sets side damage of the least of 0.75V^(1/3), 3 m plus 0.225V^(1/3), or 11 m longitudinally, and 0.2V^(1/3) transversely, over the full vertical extent, where V is the displacement volume in cubic meters at the design waterline.
Are the second-generation intact stability criteria part of damage stability?
No. MSC.1/Circ.1627 of 10 December 2020 sets interim, non-mandatory guidelines for five intact failure modes, such as parametric rolling and dead ship condition.
They assess the undamaged ship in waves and do not change any damage stability rule.
Did any SOLAS damage stability amendment enter into force on 1 January 2024?
Yes, MSC.474(102), adopted 11 November 2020.
For passenger ships with a building contract on or after 1 January 2024, keel laid on or after 1 July 2024 without a contract, or delivered on or after 1 January 2028, it sets the survival factor to zero for any damage case where an unprotected opening is immersed at an intermediate stage of flooding, and it revises the watertight integrity regulations. MSC.510(105), sometimes cited in this context, is a performance standard for search and rescue radar transponders and has nothing to do with stability.
How does the United States regulate damage stability on US-flag ships?
Through 46 CFR Subchapter S, Parts 170 to 174.
Part 171 sets subdivision and damage standards for passenger vessels, Part 172 covers bulk cargoes including hazardous liquids and liquefied gas, and Part 174 covers specific types such as MODUs and offshore supply vessels. SOLAS-certificated US ships built from 1 January 2009 carry MSC.216(82) information under 46 CFR 170.140.
Do offshore supply vessels and special purpose ships follow SOLAS damage stability?
They follow adapted versions of it.
The Special Purpose Ships Code (MSC.266(84)) applies the passenger-ship required index R at 240 or more persons and 0.8R at 60 or fewer. In the US, 46 CFR 127.610 applies SOLAS Part B-1 to offshore supply vessels with R multiplied by F = (N + 720)/960 below 240 persons.
Can damage stability be checked by hand?
Single deterministic cases can be, from hydrostatic and cross-curve data, and the margin-line and floodable-length checks were done manually for decades.
The SOLAS index needs software, because a typical ship generates thousands of damage cases at three drafts, each with intermediate flooding stages. No ShipCalculators.com tool computes the damage stability index.
No question matches. Try a shorter or different word.
Sources
- IMO MSC.216(82). Amendments to SOLAS 1974, Chapter II-1 Parts A to B-4, harmonized probabilistic subdivision and damage stability (8 December 2006) imo.org
- IMO MSC.421(98). Amendments to SOLAS 1974, Chapter II-1 subdivision and damage stability (15 June 2017) imo.org
- IMO MSC.474(102). Amendments to SOLAS 1974, Chapter II-1 watertight integrity (11 November 2020) imo.org
- IMO MSC.143(77). Amendments to the 1988 Load Lines Protocol, revised Annex B including Regulation 27 (5 June 2003) imo.org
- IMO MSC.170(79). Amendments to SOLAS 1974, revised Chapter XII on bulk carriers (9 December 2004) imo.org
- IMO MSC.176(79). Amendments to the IBC Code, chapter 2 ship survival capability (10 December 2004) imo.org
- IMO MSC.370(93). Amendments to the IGC Code, the 2016 IGC Code (22 May 2014) imo.org
- IMO MSC.385(94). International Code for Ships Operating in Polar Waters, Part I-A chapter 4 (21 November 2014) imo.org
- IMO MSC.97(73). International Code of Safety for High-Speed Craft, 2000 (5 December 2000) imo.org
- IMO MSC.436(99). Amendments to SOLAS 1974, Regulation II-1/8-1 for passenger ships constructed before 1 January 2014 (24 May 2018) imo.org
- IMO MEPC.248(66). Amendments to MARPOL Annex I, Regulation 28.6 stability instrument (4 April 2014) imo.org
- IMCO A.265(VIII). Regulations on subdivision and stability of passenger ships as an equivalent to Part B of Chapter II of SOLAS 1960 (20 November 1973) imo.org
- NTSB/MAR-17/01. Sinking of US Cargo Vessel SS El Faro, Atlantic Ocean, Northeast of Acklins and Crooked Island, Bahamas, 1 October 2015 (adopted 12 December 2017) ntsb.gov
- 46 CFR 171.015. Location of margin line (US Coast Guard) ecfr.gov