Inherent Vice in Marine Insurance
Inherent vice in marine insurance and carriage: Marine Insurance Act 1906 s.55(2)(c), Institute Cargo Clauses clause 4.4, Soya v White and The Cendor MOPU.
Inherent vice is the risk of deterioration of goods from their own natural behaviour in the ordinary course of the voyage, without any fortuitous external accident or casualty. Loss proximately caused by it is excluded from marine insurance by Marine Insurance Act 1906 s.55(2)(c) and by clause 4.4 of the Institute Cargo Clauses (A), (B) and (C) 1/1/09, and it is a carrier defence under Hague-Visby Rules Art IV r2(m).
The full article will cover the definition Lord Diplock gave in Soya GmbH Mainz KG v White [1983] 1 Lloyd’s Rep 122 and its application in The Cendor MOPU [2011] UKSC 5, the line between inherent vice and perils of the seas, and the commodities where the defence most often arises. See cargo insurance and the Institute Cargo Clauses.