Ship finance and asset valuation
The ship as a capital asset: how earnings capitalize into hull value, the SALEFORM deposit, newbuilding instalments, mortgage LTV covenants and LDT scrap value.
Contents17 sections
Ship asset valuation is the estimation of what a vessel would fetch in a sale today, and the market convention is that it is quoted charter-free: a willing buyer and a willing seller, prompt delivery, no employment attached. That basis is not a technicality. It is what a loan agreement means when it refers to market value, because a lender enforcing its security takes the hull and cannot rely on a charter that may not survive the enforcement.
Ship finance is the machinery built on top of that number. A mortgage advances a fraction of it, a covenant tests it through the life of the loan, an accounting standard depreciates a different number beside it, and a recycling market sets a floor under it. Those four numbers behave differently and are computed under different rules, and most of the expensive mistakes in shipping come from confusing them.
This article covers the ship as a capital asset: what sets its value, how it is bought and sold, how it is financed and secured, how it is carried on the books, and how it ends as steel. The contract mechanics of the transfer are worked through in detail in ship sale and purchase; the freight earnings that feed the valuation are in time charter equivalent and the Baltic Dry Index and freight indices.
What a ship is worth, and who says so
A ship’s market value is an opinion, produced by a named house on a named hull, and the identity of the producer is part of the number. There is no exchange on which ships trade, so no price is observable in the way a bond price is. Values come from shipbrokers who see the enquiries and the fixtures, and from model providers who infer them from transaction histories.
The shipbroker is the traditional source. A broker valuation is a signed opinion, addressed to a client, stating the basis, the assumptions and the date, and it is what loan documentation normally requires. Model-driven valuations sit alongside it: VesselsValue, founded in 2011 and acquired by Veson Nautical in a transaction announced on 11 April 2023, produces daily vessel-specific values across eight value categories from a base of more than 100,000 historical transactions, together with ownership, fleet and AIS-derived movement data.
The Baltic Exchange publishes the benchmark layer. Its sale and purchase assessments and its demolition assessment were introduced in 2004 and are published weekly.
Charter-free, the basis behind every quoted value
Charter-free means the ship is valued on her own merits, with no fixture attached. It is the default basis for the sale and purchase market and for the covenant testing in a loan agreement, and it is written into the Baltic’s assessment specifications alongside the other assumptions that make one week comparable to the next.
Those specifications are unusually explicit, which is what makes them useful. The Baltic assesses five-year-old vessels at fixed nominal sizes: VLCC 305,000 dwt, Aframax 105,000 dwt, MR 45,000 dwt, Capesize 172,000 dwt, Panamax 74,000 dwt and Supramax 52,000 dwt, with Handysize added from 3 April 2020 at 38,200 dwt on the Japanese-built Imabari 38 design. The Handysize specification states the full set: special survey passed, prompt delivery of two to three months, charter free, 2% total commission.
A charter-attached valuation is a different number. It prices the hull together with an existing fixture, and it moves in either direction: a long charter fixed above the current market adds roughly the present value of the excess, and one fixed below it subtracts the same. The two bases can differ by millions on the same steel, which is why a valuation that does not state its basis is not a valuation.
Desktop and inspected valuations, and the lender’s panel
A desktop valuation is produced from records, comparables and market knowledge with no attendance on board. An inspected valuation involves a physical visit. Loan documentation routinely accepts desktop valuations from an approved panel for periodic covenant testing and reserves inspection for enforcement, a disputed number, or a distressed situation where condition is the live question.
The panel mechanism matters more than the label. A minimum value clause names the acceptable valuers, requires two certified valuations, requires the two to fall within a stated spread of each other, and calls a further valuation if they do not. The borrower instructs the valuers and pays for them, which sounds like a conflict and is managed by the panel being the lender’s list rather than the borrower’s.
How Baltic assessments are actually produced
Each Baltic assessment, other than the forward curves, is the simple arithmetic average of submissions from vetted independent shipbrokers. That is the whole method, and it is stated rather than modelled.
Panellists are competitive shipbrokers who do not invest in the markets they report, and no part of their remuneration is linked to benchmark performance. Because the sale and purchase market is thin, panellists weight what transactional evidence exists against tonnage availability, order lists, sentiment and news flow, and apply expert judgement of the wider market where a route-specific transaction does not exist. The Baltic Exchange states adherence to the IOSCO Principles for Financial Benchmarks and compliance with Regulation (EU) 2016/1011 on benchmarks, with an oversight function and an administrator, BEISL, separate from the Exchange itself.
The four prices that bracket a ship’s life
Every ship lives between four prices: the newbuilding price at the yard, the secondhand price for delivered trading tonnage, the earnings expressed as time charter equivalent in USD per day, and the demolition price per light displacement ton. The first three move with the freight market. The fourth is a scrap-steel price that sets a rough floor under the others.
The spreads between them are supply signals, and they are read that way by owners deciding what to do with capital. When the secondhand price for a five-year-old ship rises above the newbuilding price for the same type, the market is paying a premium for immediate delivery over a two to three year wait, and ordering follows. When the secondhand price converges on the demolition value, the residual is doing all the work and the ship is worth little more than her steel.
Neither spread produces its effect quickly. Ship recycling in 2024 ran at 6.3 million gross tons, matching 2023 and equal to 0.25% of the global fleet, on UNCTAD’s Review of Maritime Transport 2025 published on 24 September 2025. A narrow secondhand-to-scrap spread does not by itself empty the fleet.
How earnings capitalize into hull value
A ship’s value is the present value of the net cash she is expected to generate over her remaining life, plus her residual scrap value, discounted at a rate reflecting the cost of capital and the risk of those cash flows. That is the mechanism behind every comparable sale, even where nobody computes it explicitly.
$$V_0 = \sum_{t=1}^{n} \frac{TCE_t - OPEX_t}{(1+r)^t} + \frac{LDT \cdot P_{scrap}}{(1+r)^n}$$The relation between earnings and value is supportable empirically, but as a long-run relation rather than as close tracking. Work by Hale and Vanags in 1992, by Kavussanos and Alizadeh in 2002 and by Alizadeh and Nomikos in 2007 finds that secondhand prices and timecharter earnings are cointegrated, which is what the present-value model predicts. Short-run deviations from that long-run relation are what an investor is actually trading, and they are usually expressed as a sale and purchase price-to-earnings ratio: the price of a benchmark ship divided by her one-year timecharter earnings.
Why asset prices swing further than the earnings under them
Both halves of the discounting move at once, and usually in the same direction. A change in the expected long-run earning level moves a present value by a multiple of the annual change, because the change is applied across every remaining year rather than one.
The discount rate compounds it. Cheap and available ship finance lifts asset prices by lowering the rate applied to the same cash, and a credit squeeze does the reverse, so a lending cycle and a freight cycle that peak together produce an asset price that overshoots both. That double sensitivity is why a shipowner’s balance sheet is more volatile than the trade the ship performs, and it is the engine of the asset play.
Comparable sales against discounted cash flow
Brokers value by comparable sales; analysts value by discounted cash flow; and the two answer different questions rather than competing.
| Comparable sales | Discounted cash flow | |
|---|---|---|
| Input | Recent transactions in similar tonnage | Projected TCE, opex, remaining life, residual, discount rate |
| Strength | Reflects what buyers are actually paying now | Prices the ship against her own earning capacity |
| Weakness | Thin markets give few comparables, and none identical | Every input is an estimate the market disagrees on |
| Used for | Loan covenant testing, S&P negotiation, insured value | Investment appraisal, impairment testing, bid ceilings |
| Adjustments | Age, yard, specification, survey position, class notation | Sensitivity on rate and residual assumptions |
The honest position is that the comparables are themselves anchored by the earnings logic, so the two methods are not independent. A buyer paying the last-done price is paying what the previous buyer thought the cash stream was worth. Where they diverge sharply, the divergence is the information: a comparable price well above a defensible discounted cash flow is the market pricing an expectation the cash flows do not yet contain.
Neither method survives a bad survey position. A ship a year from her special survey and drydocking with heavy expected steel renewal is not comparable to a sister with the survey freshly passed, and a valuer who does not adjust for it is quoting the wrong ship.
The asset play, and how it fails
The asset play is buying a secondhand ship near the bottom of the price cycle to sell her near the top, capturing the capital gain on the hull rather than the operating margin from trading her. It is a separate return stream from the freight market, and in a strong upswing it can exceed several years of trading profit.
It works because ship values are cyclical and mean-reverting rather than trending, and the cycle has a mechanical driver: shipping market cycles turn on the lag between an ordering decision and the delivery of the hull it produces. High rates make ordering look rational to every owner at once, the orderbook delivers into a market that has already softened, and the correction runs through scrapping rather than price alone.
Three things end it. Timing, because a trough can be longer than the owner’s patience. Leverage, because a further fall in values breaches the minimum value clause and can force a sale at exactly the wrong point. And carrying cost, because a hull held through a trough consumes crew, insurance, class and survey money every day it waits.
The sale and purchase process
A secondhand sale runs on a standard form amended by rider clauses, negotiated between brokers, and closed against documents on a fixed day. The discipline of that sequence is what protects a buyer who has inspected a multi-million-dollar asset for a day.
The dominant form is the Norwegian Saleform. SALEFORM 2025 is the current edition, announced by BIMCO in a Documentary Committee update published on 26 February 2026, with copyright held by the Norwegian Shipbrokers’ Association rather than by BIMCO. It replaces SALEFORM 2012, which will nonetheless appear on live transactions for years, because deals in progress do not migrate.
Alternatives exist and are used regionally. BIMCO’s own SHIPSALE 22, published in 2022, is built around electronic signature and e-document workflows. NIPPONSALE 1999 is the current Japan Shipping Exchange form, issued in 1965 and last amended on 2 November 1999, with arbitration at TOMAC. The Singapore Ship Sale Form 2011, launched in January 2011 by the Singapore Maritime Foundation with the Singapore Shipping Association and the Asian Shipowners’ Forum, takes Singapore as the default arbitral seat with a choice of Singapore or English governing law.
The memorandum of agreement and what the deposit secures
The Memorandum of Agreement is the sale contract, and signing it triggers the deposit. The deposit is the buyer’s earnest money and the seller’s compensation for taking the ship off the market: forfeited on buyer default, refunded with accrued interest if the seller fails to deliver.
One point is routinely misstated, including in commentary that ought to know better. SALEFORM 2012 clause 2 does not fix the deposit at 10%. It reads as a blank for the parties to complete, with 10% supplied only as a fallback where the box is left empty, and the pre-printed lodgement period is three Banking Days after the Agreement date and confirmation that the account is open. Interest accrues to the buyers unless amended. Deals are done at other percentages, and treating 10% as a contractual default rather than a market custom misreads the form.
The balance is paid on delivery against the closing documents, which is where a mortgage lender’s funds arrive. The choreography of deposit, finance and balance is why closing is a tightly timed event, with funds, documents and physical delivery coordinated to the same hour.
When the deposit becomes a debt
A seller’s claim to the deposit accrues as a debt only once the deposit holder confirms that the account is open, and not before. That was settled for English law in King Crude Carriers SA and others v Ridgebury November LLC and others [2025] UKSC 39, judgment of 12 November 2025 on appeal from [2024] EWCA Civ 719.
Three memoranda of agreement on SALEFORM 2012 as amended, concluded between 28 and 30 April 2020, each provided for a 10% deposit. The buyers failed to supply the documentation needed to open the deposit accounts, so the accounts were never opened. The sellers argued that the buyers’ own breach should be treated as fulfilling the condition, on the principle associated with Mackay v Dick.
The Supreme Court held unanimously for the buyers. There is no deemed fulfilment principle in English law; the steps around the deposit accounts are conditions precedent to the debt accruing, not mere payment machinery, following and approving The Blankenstein [1985] 1 WLR 435. The sellers were confined to damages, and on the assumed facts the market had risen above the contract price by termination, so the damages measure produced no loss. The commercial consequence is stark: a buyer facing a rising market was better off breaching before lodging the deposit than after. That is the gap the SALEFORM 2025 escrow and know-your-customer redraft is written to close.
Inspection, class records and condition on delivery
The buyer’s protection against condition risk is the inspection regime, and the more valuable half of it is documentary rather than physical. The classification society holds the ship’s survey record, and it documents every survey, every condition of class and every outstanding recommendation, which is a noted defect the society requires rectified within a set period.
A ship can pass a walkthrough and still carry a stack of recommendations that will cost her new owner heavily at the next drydock. A buyer’s superintendent reads the records for exactly that. Under SALEFORM 2012 the inspection provisions sit at clause 4, with underwater examination and drydocking at clause 6, and clause 6 is the most heavily negotiated provision after the deposit because it allocates the cost if divers find class-affecting damage.
SALEFORM 2025 adds an option that reflects how the market already behaved during periods when attendance was impractical: inspection may be waived in favour of the class records alone. That shifts more weight onto the documentary review and onto the seaworthiness and due diligence position at delivery.
Delivery, the bill of sale, and encumbrance-free title
Delivery transfers the ship, and it is the bill of sale that conveys title, executed and normally notarized and legalized or apostilled so it can be registered in the buyer’s chosen flag. Alongside it come the protocol of delivery and acceptance recording the exact time and place, the class and statutory certificates, and the deletion certificate from the outgoing registry or a power of attorney to procure it.
The financial protection that matters most is the warranty that the ship is delivered free of encumbrances, at clause 9 of SALEFORM 2012. A maritime lien attaches to the hull by operation of law and survives a private sale, so an unpaid crew wage, a salvage claim or a damage claim from the previous owner can be enforced against the new owner by arrest. The seller’s warranty and indemnity, backed by the outgoing registry’s deletion of the old mortgage, is what lets a buyer pay and a lender register a fresh first-priority mortgage without inheriting the seller’s debts.
There is a hard limit on what a private sale can achieve, and it is the single most important thing a financier should understand about title. No private sale extinguishes a maritime lien. Only a judicial sale does. Where a ship is registered in a state party to the International Convention on Maritime Liens and Mortgages, 1993, Article 3(2) additionally prevents her registration in another state party without a certificate of deregistration, or a certificate that deregistration takes effect immediately on the new registration, which is why the deletion certificate is a closing-day item rather than an afterthought.
Ordering a newbuilding
Building a ship is a different transaction from buying one. The buyer is commissioning an asset rather than acquiring one, paying a yard in stages across a two to three year construction period, against a contract that allocates the risks of delay, defect and yard insolvency.
Several contract families are in use, and the choice shapes how much risk sits with the buyer. The Shipbuilders’ Association of Japan form, published in January 1974, is long established across Asian yards and is generally builder-leaning. The AWES form, introduced in 1972 and revised and reissued in May 1999, is the European equivalent. The Norwegian SHIP 2000 is an agreed document between owner and builder bodies and dominates Norwegian building. The CMAC Standard Newbuilding Contract, the Shanghai Form, was published in March 2011 by the China Maritime Arbitration Commission and differs from the SAJ form in requiring written notice of default to the buyer where SAJ default is automatic. The MARAD form is used for United States newbuildings financed under Title XI of the Merchant Marine Act 1936.
NEWBUILDCON, issued by BIMCO in 2007 and still the only edition, is the international standard form drafted for any jurisdiction and any ship type, and written to sit more evenly between the parties than the older yard forms.
The instalment schedule sits in Box 11, not in the form
A newbuilding is paid in instalments tied to construction milestones, and the familiar structure spreads the price across payments on signing, at steel cutting, at keel laying, at launching, and a final and often largest instalment on delivery.
That structure is market practice, not a contractual term. NEWBUILDCON clause 15 provides that instalments fall due in accordance with Box 11, which the parties complete, and the form prescribes no split. What the form does fix is the characterization: pre-delivery instalments are advances, not deposits, which shapes what a buyer can recover if the yard fails.
The exposure this creates is the central financial fact of a newbuilding. Every instalment paid before delivery is money handed to a shipyard against a ship that does not yet exist, cannot be arrested and cannot be sold.
The refund guarantee and the bank behind it
The refund guarantee is what stands between the buyer and that exposure: a bank guarantee issued by the yard’s bank in the buyer’s favour, repaying paid instalments with interest if the yard defaults, becomes insolvent or fails to deliver. BIMCO calls it the financial cornerstone of a shipbuilding project.
Under NEWBUILDCON it sits at clause 16, with the specimen at Annex A(iii) and the guaranteeing bank named in Box 32, provided with each pre-delivery instalment invoice for that instalment plus interest. Failure to provide it lets the buyer terminate under clause 39(a)(ix). The Annex A(iii) wording creates a primary, on-demand obligation, with payment capable of deferral where the builder disputes the repayment claim within 28 days of demand until the dispute is resolved.
Clause 16 runs both ways, which is less well known. The Instalment Guarantee is the buyer’s security to the builder, form at Annex A(ii), bank named in Box 31, due within five Banking Days of the contract’s effective date under clause 44, and its absence lets the builder terminate under clause 39(b)(iv).
BIMCO adopted a standalone Refund Guarantee for Shipbuilding Contracts in 2021, drafted for use alongside bespoke contracts and the Asian yard forms, under which the guarantor’s liability increases automatically as instalments are received up to a stated maximum, avoiding a separate guarantee for each instalment.
Export credit under the OECD Sector Understanding
Where an export credit agency finances a newbuilding, the terms are capped by the OECD Sector Understanding on Export Credits for Ships, Annex I to the Arrangement on Officially Supported Export Credits. It applies to any new sea-going vessel of 100 gt and above, plus conversions and hovercraft.
The three numbers a shipowner needs are fixed. Official support may cover a maximum of 80% of the contract price, with a minimum cash payment of 20% by delivery, and the maximum repayment term is 12 years after delivery, irrespective of country classification. Principal is repaid in equal instalments normally every six months and at most every 12; interest is paid at least every six months, with the first payment no later than six months after the starting point of credit, and post-starting-point interest may not be capitalized.
There is a trap in the recent history. The wider OECD Arrangement was modernized with effect from 15 July 2023 and generally allows credit periods of up to 15 years, replacing the earlier 8.5-year and 10-year split. The ships Sector Understanding was not changed to match: 12 years and 20% cash still stand for ships. The Sector Understanding is a Gentlemen’s Agreement rather than an OECD Act under Article 5 of the OECD Convention, and its participants are Australia, the European Union, Japan, Korea, New Zealand and Norway.
Depreciation, carrying value and impairment
On the owner’s balance sheet the ship is a depreciating asset, and the carrying value that results is a different number from the market value with different rules behind it. Confusing the two is the most common error in reading a shipping balance sheet.
What IAS 16 requires, and what shipping companies do
IAS 16 Property, Plant and Equipment does not prescribe a 25-year life or a straight-line method. It requires an entity-specific estimate of useful life and residual value, and paragraph 51 requires both to be reviewed at least at each financial year end, with any change treated as a change in accounting estimate under IAS 8 and applied prospectively. Paragraph 50 sets the depreciable amount as cost less residual value, and paragraph 55 starts depreciation when the asset is available for use.
Straight-line depreciation over a 20 to 25 year life down to an estimated scrap residual is the shipping convention. It is not a requirement, and the distinction is load-bearing whenever a company’s policy is compared against a peer’s.
Residual value is also more tightly defined than practice suggests. Paragraph 6 measures it as the amount currently obtainable on disposal, net of estimated disposal costs, for an asset already of the age and condition expected at the end of its useful life. It is anchored to current prices. Forecasting a future scrap price is not what the standard asks for.
Component depreciation is mandatory rather than optional. Paragraph 43 requires each part of an item with a cost significant in relation to the total to be depreciated separately, and IAS 16 sets no numeric significance threshold, which leaves the identification of components to judgement and makes it a recurring audit question in shipping.
Drydock and survey costs under paragraph 14
The five-yearly survey is capitalized, not expensed, and the mechanism is IAS 16 paragraph 14. The cost of a major inspection is recognized as a replacement when the recognition criteria are met, and the carrying amount of the previous inspection is derecognized at the same time. The capitalized amount is then amortized across the interval to the next drydocking, so the cost lands in profit over the cycle it buys rather than in the month it is paid.
Routine repairs and maintenance are expensed as incurred. The line between the two is where a superintendent’s work order becomes an accounting question, and the special survey and drydocking scope is what decides it. Where a ship is on a continuous survey of hull and machinery cycle, or holds approval for in-water survey in lieu of drydocking, the pattern of the expenditure changes and the componentized amortization follows it.
Impairment under IAS 36
A vessel is property, plant and equipment, so impairment testing is indicator-driven rather than annual. IAS 36 paragraph 12 lists the indicators and the list is expressly not exhaustive. In shipping the usual triggers are falling charter rates, falling secondhand values, laid-up tonnage and a market capitalization below net assets.
Recoverable amount is the higher of fair value less costs of disposal and value in use, and only one needs to be computed where it already exceeds the carrying amount. Broker valuations of comparable tonnage usually make fair value less costs of disposal the practical starting point. Paragraph 33 requires value in use to be built from the latest budgets or forecasts approved by management, with financing cash flows and interest-bearing debt excluded from both the cash flows and the carrying amount of the unit, because financing is reflected in the discount rate instead.
The decisive judgement is the level of aggregation. A cash-generating unit under paragraph 6 is the smallest identifiable group of assets generating largely independent cash inflows. A vessel on time charter is typically her own unit; vessels trading in a pool or on interdependent liner networks may have to be grouped, and grouping can conceal an impairment that a ship-by-ship test would expose. Unlike goodwill, an impairment of vessel carrying value is reversible if the indicators cease to exist.
Book value against market value
Book value is depreciated historical cost on a fixed schedule, indifferent to the freight market. Market value is what the ship would fetch in a sale today. They answer different questions and they diverge for reasons that have nothing to do with the ship.
The divergence has consequences in both directions. A market value below book value can force an impairment that reduces reported equity and, where the loan carries a net-worth or gearing covenant, puts the borrower in breach without any change in the ship, the loan balance or the cash she earns. A market value above book value is an unrealized gain, invisible on the balance sheet until the ship is sold, and it is the gain the asset play exists to capture.
Banks lend against market value, not book value. That is why a loan-to-value covenant is tested against a current broker valuation, and why falling values can breach a covenant while the accounts show nothing wrong.
The ship mortgage and where it ranks
The ship mortgage is the dominant security in ship finance: a charge over the vessel recorded in her flag registry, enforceable against the hull itself. Its strength is that it travels with the ship and is discoverable by anyone dealing with her. Its limit is that it does not sit at the top of the priority order.
Recordation creates priority
Recordation, not execution, is what fixes a mortgage’s rank. Under Liberian Maritime Law, Title 21 of the Liberian Code of Laws of 1956, section 101(1), a valid mortgage covering the whole of a vessel takes preferred status as of the date of its recordation, provided it is recorded as required and the mortgagee has not waived that status. Section 101(2) preserves the status even where no advance has yet been made, which is what allows a facility to be secured before it is drawn.
Section 101(3) solves the change-of-flag problem: a mortgage granted in continuation of a prior recorded mortgage, including one recorded under another jurisdiction’s law while the vessel was documented there, takes preferred status as of the date of the earlier recordation.
The Marshall Islands regime is built on the same architecture and is unusually explicit about scope. A preferred mortgage there may secure contingent obligations, charter hire, future advances and future debts, an agreed maximum with no present commitment to lend, revolving facilities, multi-currency amounts and currency-fluctuation losses, and rights under construction, purchase, sale or charter contracts. Section 113 of the Maritime Act provides that Marshall Islands mortgage instruments may be interpreted in accordance with the decisions of the admiralty courts of the United States, which is why practice there tracks United States preferred-ship-mortgage doctrine.
Public inspection is the international hinge. Article 1 of the International Convention on Maritime Liens and Mortgages, 1993 makes recognition abroad conditional on the mortgage being registered under the law of the state of registration, the register and deposited instruments being open to public inspection with obtainable extracts, and the record specifying the mortgagee, the maximum amount secured where required, and the particulars determining ranking.
Maritime liens outrank the mortgage
Article 5(1) of the 1993 Convention puts maritime liens ahead of registered mortgages, hypothèques and charges, and no other claim ranks above either. The lien list at Article 4(1) is closed and contains five categories: crew wages and related sums including repatriation and social insurance contributions; loss of life or personal injury in direct connection with the operation of the vessel; salvage reward; port, canal, waterway and pilotage dues; and tort claims for physical loss or damage caused by the operation of the vessel, excluding cargo, containers and passengers’ effects. Necessaries are not on that list, and are left to national law.
Liens are also durable and mobile. Article 8 makes them follow the vessel notwithstanding a change of ownership, registration or flag, and Article 9 extinguishes them after one year unless the vessel is arrested or seized within that period and the arrest leads to a forced sale, with no suspension or interruption of the period.
The Convention’s practical reach is narrower than its logic. It entered into force on 5 September 2004 and had 21 parties as at 4 September 2026, and neither England, the United States, Panama, Liberia nor the Marshall Islands is among them. In the principal arrest and registration centres, national law governs, and it reaches similar results by its own route. Liberian Maritime Law section 113 gives the preferred mortgage lien priority over all claims against the vessel except liens arising before the mortgage was recorded, tort liens, liens under section 83 of Chapter 2, crew wages, general average, salvage including contract salvage, and court-allowed expenses, fees and taxed costs.
United States law adds an overlay a mortgagee cannot ignore. Under 46 U.S.C. 31326, a court sale in rem terminates every claim existing at the date of sale and the claims attach to the proceeds in their priorities, with the preferred mortgage lien ranking after court costs and fees and after preferred maritime liens. For a foreign vessel whose mortgage is not guaranteed under chapter 537, the preferred mortgage lien is additionally subordinate to a maritime lien for necessaries provided in the United States. A bunker supplier in a United States port can therefore outrank a first-priority mortgage on a Marshall Islands hull, which is a live consideration in trading patterns as well as in documentation. The wider mechanics are in maritime lien and ship arrest.
Enforcement runs through arrest and judicial sale
A mortgagee’s realistic route is to arrest the ship and ask a court to sell her, because only a judicial sale delivers title free of the liens that outrank the mortgage. Article 12(1) of the 1993 Convention provides that on a forced sale in a state party, all registered mortgages other than those assumed by the purchaser with the holder’s consent, and all liens and other encumbrances of whatsoever nature, cease to attach to the vessel, provided she was within the jurisdiction at the time of sale.
The proceeds become a fund. Article 12(2) pays arrest and sale costs first, including upkeep and crew wages accrued from the time of arrest, and Article 12(5) obliges the registrar, on production of the court’s certificate, to delete the mortgages and either register the purchaser or issue a deregistration certificate.
Cross-border recognition of that clean title was the weak point until recently, and it has changed. The United Nations Convention on the International Effects of Judicial Sales of Ships, adopted on 7 December 2022 by General Assembly resolution 77/100 and opened for signature in Beijing on 5 September 2023, entered into force on 17 February 2026 under Article 21(1), 180 days after the third instrument. It had 34 signatories and 5 parties as at 4 September 2026: Barbados, El Salvador, Spain, Panama and the European Union.
Article 7 requires a registry in another state party, on production of the certificate of judicial sale, to delete pre-sale mortgages and charges and either delete the ship for new registration or register her in the purchaser’s name, and Article 8 requires a court to dismiss an arrest application or release an arrested ship for a claim arising before the sale. Both are subject to a public-policy exception, and the repository for notices and certificates is the Secretary-General of the IMO under Article 11.
Two limits are easy to miss. Article 3 applies the Convention only where the sale is conducted in a state party and the ship was physically within that state’s territory at the time of sale. Article 21(3) applies it only to judicial sales ordered or approved after it entered into force for the state of judicial sale, so it does not reach back over earlier sales. Panama’s accession matters disproportionately: it is the largest registry in the world, and Article 21(2) brings the Convention into force for a later-joining state 180 days after its own deposit.
Loan to value and the covenant that transmits the cycle
The loan-to-value covenant states the loan outstanding as a percentage of the ships’ market value, and it is the provision that turns a freight-market downturn into a balance-sheet event.
$$LTV = \frac{\text{Loan outstanding}}{\text{Aggregate charter-free market value}}$$Nothing about the ship or the loan need change for it to breach. A fall in secondhand values alone lifts the ratio, and the borrower cures by prepaying debt or posting additional security within a stated cure period, commonly 30 days. A recovery in values during that window does not automatically oblige the lender to withdraw a default notice under English law, which is why the covenant is a harder instrument than its arithmetic suggests.
The mortgage never travels alone. The security package normally includes a deed of covenants setting out the owner’s operational, insurance, class and trading obligations, an assignment of earnings and insurances, a pledge of the shares in the owning company, and, where a charterer has taken possession, a quiet enjoyment letter. Insurance sits behind it: hull and machinery insurance protects the asset, and mortgagee interest insurance protects the lender against the failure of that cover.
Leasing and the alternatives to bank debt
Bank debt is the largest channel of ship finance but no longer the only one that matters. Petrofin Research, in its end-2025 survey of portfolios as at 31 December 2025, put top 40 bank lending to shipping at USD 300.6 billion, up 6% on USD 283.6 billion, and total bank lending including local banks at about USD 425 billion, which it assessed as just over 60% of all ship finance. Europe held 50.4% of the top 40 at USD 151 billion, Japanese banks rose from 22% to 26% of the top 40, and Scandinavian banks grew 16.2% to USD 26.2 billion. BNP Paribas continued to head the table and no bank left the sector during the year.
Two cautions attach to those figures. Petrofin restates: its end-2024 edition put the same 2024 year at USD 289.65 billion where the end-2025 edition puts it at USD 283.6 billion, so an edition has to be named and the two must not be mixed in one comparison. And Petrofin is a research house rather than a regulator, so the numbers are attributed rather than authoritative.
Sale and leaseback and the lessor’s position
In a sale and leaseback, the owner sells the ship to a lessor and charters her straight back on a long bareboat charter or finance lease, often with an option or obligation to buy her back. The owner releases cash and keeps operating the ship; the lessor takes title.
Title is the whole point of the structure. A lessor owns the asset outright, where a mortgagee holds a charge over someone else’s ship and ranks behind court costs and preferred maritime liens on enforcement. That stronger position is why a leaseback can advance a higher proportion of a ship’s value than a conventional mortgage, and why leasing grew as bank lending to shipping tightened. Chinese ship leasing houses are the largest single group of providers, and Japanese operating lease with call option structures serve a different tax-driven investor base, alongside the KG and KS ship funds that raised retail equity for the same purpose.
The accounting follows the control test rather than the label. Under IFRS 16 a lease conveys the right to control the use of an identified asset, requiring both substantially all the economic benefits from use and the right to direct that use. A bareboat charter is a lease. A time charter typically is, because the charterer directs cargo, routing and ports within the period. A voyage charter or a contract of affreightment generally is not, because the use is predetermined and the customer cannot change it during the period of use, does not operate the ship and did not design her. The detail is in IFRS 16 and ship lease accounting.
Tax shapes the choice as much as the covenant package does, and a tonnage tax regime that assesses profit on tonnage rather than on accounting income changes what depreciation is worth to an owner.
Climate alignment inside the financing decision
Emissions performance now enters the financing decision through the lender’s own reporting obligations rather than through the loan covenants alone. The Poseidon Principles are the framework: signatory lenders measure the carbon intensity of their shipping portfolios against a decarbonization trajectory and disclose the result annually.
The Sixth Annual Disclosure Report, published on 15 December 2025, recorded 36 signatories across 14 countries, together covering almost three-quarters of global ship finance on the report’s own attribution to the 2024 Marine Money Shipping Portfolio League Table. Disclosure covered 95% of eligible portfolio activity, up from 93%, with 29 signatories reporting 90% or more and 9 reaching 100%. Misalignment against the minimum trajectory narrowed from just over 19% to just under 12%, and against the striving trajectory from 25% to just over 18%. The framework opened Associate Membership to institutions providing or arranging capital beyond lending, including private equity, hedge funds and capital-markets underwriters, and its methodology has been accepted under the Science Based Targets initiative Financial Institutions Net-Zero Standard.
One comparison needs care. The Fifth report of 12 December 2024 stated coverage as nearly 80% of ship finance and about USD 240 billion, against the Sixth report’s “almost three-quarters”. That is a change of denominator and basis, not a fall in coverage, and signatories rose from 35 to 36 over the same period.
The transmission into value is indirect but real. A ship’s carbon intensity indicator rating and her energy efficiency existing ship index position affect which charterers will take her, which lenders will finance her and on what terms, and therefore what a buyer will pay for the remaining years of her life. That is a residual-value question dressed as a compliance question, and the financing side of it is covered in shipping climate finance and ratings.
Carrying the asset: operating cost, survey cost and lay-up
Owning a ship between purchase and sale consumes money every day, and the carrying cost is what erodes an asset play whose timing is slow. A trading ship accrues crew, stores, lubricants, insurance, maintenance and management costs whether or not she is earning, and the daily running cost is the figure that sets the floor under a break-even freight rate.
On top of the daily figure sit the periodic costs of keeping the ship in class: the special survey and drydocking every five years, the intermediate survey between them, and whatever steel and machinery work the thickness measurements uncover. That periodic cost is what tips an ageing ship toward demolition. When the expected survey bill exceeds the earnings the remaining life would generate, a trading owner is worth less holding the ship than a recycling yard is worth paying for her steel.
Where the market will not cover even the daily cost, the alternative to trading at a loss is lay-up. Hot lay-up keeps machinery operational under a reduced crew and allows a return to service in days; cold lay-up shuts systems down under a preservation regime and takes weeks and a substantial bill to reverse. Neither reduces the cost to zero, and the judgement is entirely about how long the trough will last.
Demolition: light displacement tonnage times the prevailing rate
Demolition value is light displacement tonnage multiplied by the prevailing price per LDT offered in the recycling market, and it is the floor under everything above it. LDT is the weight of the ship in light condition: hull, structure, machinery, equipment and fittings, with no cargo, fuel, water, ballast, stores, passengers or crew aboard. Yards buy recoverable steel, and LDT is the closest available proxy for it, which is why the price is quoted on LDT rather than on deadweight.
The split between the two factors explains the behaviour of scrap values. LDT is fixed for a given hull, so all the volatility sits in the price per LDT, which is a steel-scrap price set by recycling-yard demand and local steel markets and which differs between destinations. The Baltic Exchange publishes ship recycling assessments in USD per LDT for the four principal destinations: Chattogram, Gadani, Alang and AliaÄŸa.
One contractual point costs real money and is regularly left ambiguous. The sale contract must state whether the LDT unit is a long ton or a metric tonne. A long ton of 2,240 lb is about 1.6% heavier than a metric tonne, which on a 20,000 LDT hull is a six-figure difference at any plausible rate. Neither party should assume.
Where the tonnage goes
Recycling is concentrated in a small number of states. On UNCTAD’s Review of Maritime Transport 2025, published on 24 September 2025, ship recycling in 2024 totalled 6.3 million gross tons, the same as 2023 and equal to 0.25% of the global fleet, with bulk carriers the largest share, and Bangladesh, India, Pakistan and Türkiye together accounted for over 91% of it.
The same source puts the world fleet at January 2025 at 112,500 vessels and 2.44 billion dwt, with capacity growth of 3.4% in 2024 against a 2005 to 2024 average of 5.1%, and an average age of 12.6 years weighted by gross tonnage against 22.2 years by vessel count. That age profile is the demolition pipeline, and it is skewed: developing countries hold 21.1% of dwt older than 20 years against 9.3% for developed economies.
The Hong Kong Convention regime
The Hong Kong International Convention for the Safe and Environmentally Sound Recycling of Ships, done at Hong Kong on 15 May 2009, entered into force on 26 June 2025 and had 33 contracting states as at 26 August 2026. It covers 90% of the global recycling market on UNCTAD’s assessment.
Entry into force ran on Article 17, not Article 16, and the distinction matters because the article numbers are cited wrongly across the trade press. Article 16 governs signature, ratification, acceptance, approval and accession. Article 17(1) sets the trigger at 24 months after three cumulative conditions are met: not less than 15 states; whose combined merchant fleets are not less than 40% of the gross tonnage of world merchant shipping; and whose combined maximum annual recycling volume over the preceding 10 years is not less than 3% of the combined gross tonnage of those same states. Bangladesh and Liberia both deposited on 26 June 2023, which is what fixed the date. Under Article 17(3) an instrument deposited after entry into force takes effect three months later, so recent accessions bind their states on staggered dates.
The Convention imposes obligations on both sides of a demolition sale. A ship must carry an inventory of hazardous materials under regulation 5, verified by survey under regulation 10 and certified under regulation 11 by an International Certificate on Inventory of Hazardous Materials. Before recycling she needs a ship-specific Ship Recycling Plan under regulation 9, with regulation 9.4 giving the competent authority a 14-day review period, and an International Ready for Recycling Certificate after the final survey. An existing ship’s initial survey must be conducted not later than five years after entry into force, that is by 26 June 2030.
A yard must be authorized by a Party under regulation 16.1, on the basis of a Ship Recycling Facility Plan under regulation 18, evidenced by a Document of Authorization to conduct Ship Recycling in the form of appendix 5 to the annex. Regulation 15.3 obliges each Party to run an inspection, monitoring and enforcement mechanism with powers of entry and sampling.
BIMCO’s RECYCLECON, latest edition 2012, is the standard sale contract for green recycling and voluntarily incorporates the inventory and recycling-plan requirements; the older DEMOLISHCON, latest edition 2001, does not. A RECYCLECON revision to align the form with the Convention was still in progress at BIMCO’s Documentary Committee meeting of 11 December 2025 and has not been adopted.
The European overlay and the European List
The EU Ship Recycling Regulation, Regulation (EU) No 1257/2013 of 20 November 2013, is a stricter overlay on the Convention baseline rather than a parallel regime. EU-flagged ships above 500 gross tons may be recycled only at a facility on the European List, and no facility on that list uses beaching, where the Convention permits it at an authorized facility.
Its reach extends beyond EU-flagged tonnage in one important respect. Article 12(1), applicable since 31 December 2020 under Article 32(2)(b), requires a ship flying the flag of a third country calling at a Member State port or anchorage to carry an inventory of hazardous materials complying with Article 5(2), and port authorities may inspect for it. A non-EU owner trading to Europe is inside part of the regime whether or not the ship will ever be recycled there.
The List was established by Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2016/2323 of 19 December 2016 and is replaced wholesale by each amending decision under Article 16. As replaced by Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2026/448 of 27 February 2026, it carries 41 facilities: 28 in Part A and 13 in Part B. Part A covers facilities in a Member State or the EEA, authorized by national regulators, with 21 in EU Member States and 7 in Norway. Part B covers third-country facilities that apply to the Commission and are inspected by an independent verifier: 10 in Türkiye, 2 in the United Kingdom and 1 in the United States. Listings run five years, and each entry states the recycling method, the maximum ship size and the authorized annual output.
The 2026/448 update is also the clearest available evidence that the inspection regime has teeth. It added the first German yard, at Emden, renewed facilities in Denmark, Estonia, Lithuania, Spain and Türkiye, and removed three: Harland and Wolff (Belfast), where no information on renewal of authorization was received, a Finnish yard whose authorization was not renewed at its own request, and a Turkish facility removed following an Article 15(4) inspection that could not confirm continued compliance with Article 13(1)(g), because it cut the primary hull on the shoreline without an impermeable floor and without a slag collector and did not take sufficient measures to collect and contain waste.
Separately, an end-of-life ship can be a waste for the purposes of the EU waste shipment rules, which implement the Basel Convention regime. The Ban Amendment to that Convention, adopted at Geneva on 22 September 1995 by decision III/1 and in force since 5 December 2019, had 104 parties as at 4 September 2026.
Cash buyers, the last voyage and the exposure it creates
Demolition sales usually run through a cash buyer: an intermediary that buys the ship for its own account and resells her to a yard, sometimes after a change of flag and name. The structure moves the yard relationship, the payment risk and some of the reputational exposure off the owner, and it is the normal commercial route rather than an aberration.
It does not, however, put the seller outside the law. In a judgment of the Rechtbank Rotterdam of 15 March 2018, ECLI:NL:RBROT:2018:2108, a director of a large shipping company was convicted of breaching Regulation (EC) No 1013/2006 on shipments of waste by transferring four ships from the ports of Rotterdam and Hamburg to beaches in India, Bangladesh and Türkiye for demolition. The court held the ships were waste within the meaning of the Waste Framework Directive and saw no reason to give the definition a different content for ships, and imposed a fine of EUR 50,000 and a one-year professional ban.
The exposure of the intermediaries themselves is unsettled in England. In Begum v Maran (UK) Ltd [2021] EWCA Civ 326, judgment of 10 March 2021, the Court of Appeal considered a negligence claim against an English shipbroker arising from a death at the Zuma Enterprise Yard in Chattogram on 30 March 2018. The court refused to strike the claim out, holding the pleaded duty of care was not fanciful on the assumed facts, while allowing the defendant’s appeal on Article 7 of Rome II, so that the Bangladeshi one-year limitation period applied. It did not decide that a duty exists. The judgment also records that the sale was to a cash buyer under a memorandum of agreement dated 24 August 2017 at over USD 16 million, about USD 404 per long ton, and that a clause requiring onward sale to a yard performing demolition in accordance with good health and safety working practices was described by Males LJ as a fig leaf that neither side treated seriously.
For the financial reader the point is narrow and practical. The headline price per LDT a yard or cash buyer offers is a gross figure. What reaches the owner depends on the ship’s certification, the buyer’s onward destination, the flag she carries on the last voyage and the regime that applies to it, and those variables are now part of pricing a demolition rather than an afterthought to it.
Limitations
Every market price in this article is dated and attributed, and none of them should be used as a current figure. The Petrofin lending totals are as at 31 December 2025, the Poseidon Principles coverage is from the report of 15 December 2025, and the UNCTAD recycling and fleet figures are from the Review of Maritime Transport 2025 published on 24 September 2025. Petrofin restates prior years between editions, so its figures must be quoted by edition and not compared across them.
This article states no current secondhand price, newbuilding price, price per LDT, mortgage margin or loan-to-value ceiling, and that is a deliberate limit rather than an omission. Those are continuously moving market figures, and none of the sources that publish them with the necessary frequency is a primary regulatory source. The durable statement about demolition value is the basis, LDT multiplied by the prevailing rate, and the durable statement about loan-to-value is the covenant mechanism, not a percentage. Anyone valuing a real ship takes the current numbers from a broker valuation, a recycling-market report and live finance terms.
The contract treatment here is financial rather than legal. SALEFORM 2012, SALEFORM 2025, SHIPSALE 22, NIPPONSALE 1999, the Singapore Ship Sale Form 2011, NEWBUILDCON, the SAJ form, the AWES form, SHIP 2000 and the CMAC Shanghai Form each run to many clauses that are then amended by riders, and what governs a given transaction is what the parties agreed, not what a standard form says. Clause numbers cited here are to the pre-printed forms.
The mortgage and priority discussion is verified against two registries only, Liberia and the Marshall Islands, together with the 1993 Convention and the cited United States provisions. Panama, Singapore, the United Kingdom, Greece and Norway each operate their own registration and priority rules that are not set out here, and no general statement in this article should be applied to a ship on one of those registers without checking the local instrument. Priority contests are decided by the law of the place of enforcement, which may be neither the flag nor the law of the loan.
The accounting sections state what IAS 16, IAS 36 and IFRS 16 require, and separately what shipping companies commonly do. Where the two are described together the distinction is marked, because a common policy is not a standard and an auditor will not accept it as one. Impairment aggregation, component identification and useful-life estimates are judgements that vary between companies applying the same standards correctly.
The case law is stated at the level the judgments decided. Begum v Maran refused a strike-out on assumed facts and did not establish a duty of care; the subsequent procedural history is not covered here. The Rotterdam judgment of 15 March 2018 is cited as a first-instance decision. King Crude Carriers is stated on its holding, and no figure for the deposits in that case is given because published accounts of it differ.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What does charter-free mean in a ship valuation?
Charter-free means the ship is valued on her own merits with no employment attached: a willing buyer, a willing seller and prompt delivery.
It is the default basis for every value quoted in the sale and purchase market and the basis a loan agreement means when it refers to market value, because a lender enforcing its security takes the hull and cannot rely on a charter surviving the enforcement.
How does an attached charter change a ship's value?
A charter-attached valuation prices the hull together with the existing fixture, and it moves in either direction.
A long charter fixed above the current market adds roughly the present value of the excess over the remaining period; one fixed below the market subtracts the same. The two bases can differ by millions on the same steel, which is why a valuation that does not state its basis is not usable.
Is a ship valuation the same thing as a survey?
No. A valuation is an opinion of price, produced by a broker or a model provider, stating a basis and a date.
A survey is a technical examination of condition, whether a class survey, a condition survey or a pre-purchase inspection. A valuer may rely on survey information, but the two answer different questions and are produced by different people for different clients.
What is a desktop valuation, and will a lender accept one?
A desktop valuation is produced from records, comparables and market knowledge with no attendance on board.
Loan documentation routinely accepts desktop valuations from an approved panel for periodic covenant testing, and reserves an inspected valuation for enforcement, a disputed number, or a distressed situation where condition is the live question.
Who decides which valuer a lender will accept?
The loan agreement does, by naming a panel of approved brokers or valuers.
The borrower instructs and pays for the valuations, but the panel is the lender’s list, which is what manages the apparent conflict. A minimum value clause typically requires two certified valuations, requires them to fall within a stated spread of each other, and calls a further valuation if they do not.
What are the four prices that bracket a ship's life?
The newbuilding price at the yard, the secondhand price for delivered trading tonnage, the earnings expressed as time charter equivalent in USD per day, and the demolition price per light displacement ton.
The first three move with the freight market. The fourth is a scrap-steel price that sets a rough floor under the others.
What does it mean when secondhand prices exceed newbuilding prices?
It means the market is paying a premium for immediate delivery over a two to three year wait for a new hull, and ordering usually follows.
The spread between newbuilding and secondhand prices is a supply signal rather than a valuation, and it is read that way by owners deciding where to put capital.
Does a narrow secondhand-to-scrap spread empty the fleet quickly?
No. Ship recycling in 2024 ran at 6.3 million gross tons, matching 2023 and equal to 0.25% of the global fleet, on UNCTAD’s Review of Maritime Transport 2025 published on 24 September 2025.
Scrapping responds to the spread but the response is slow, because the decision also turns on the ship’s survey position and her remaining earning capacity.
How do daily earnings turn into a hull value?
A ship’s value is the present value of the net cash she is expected to generate over her remaining life, plus her residual scrap value, discounted at a rate reflecting the cost of capital and the risk of those cash flows.
Every comparable sale is anchored by that logic even where nobody computes it explicitly, because the previous buyer was paying for the same cash stream.
Do one-year timecharter rates really track secondhand values?
In the long run, yes; in the short run, no.
Work by Hale and Vanags in 1992, by Kavussanos and Alizadeh in 2002 and by Alizadeh and Nomikos in 2007 finds that secondhand prices and timecharter earnings are cointegrated, which is what the present-value model predicts. The short-run deviations from that long-run relation are what an asset investor is actually trading.
What is the sale and purchase price-to-earnings ratio?
The secondhand price of a benchmark ship divided by her one-year timecharter earnings.
It is the usual way of expressing how far the asset price has moved from the long-run relation with earnings, and deviations from its own historical mean are used as an investment-timing signal.
Why are ship values more volatile than freight rates?
Because both halves of the discounting move at once and usually in the same direction.
A change in the expected long-run earning level moves a present value by a multiple of the annual change, since it applies across every remaining year. At the same time cheap and available finance lowers the discount rate applied to that cash, and a credit squeeze raises it.
Which is more accurate for a ship, comparable sales or discounted cash flow?
Neither is more accurate, because they answer different questions.
Comparable sales reflect what buyers are paying now and are used for covenant testing and negotiation; discounted cash flow prices the ship against her own earning capacity and is used for investment appraisal and impairment testing. They are not independent, because the comparables are themselves anchored by the earnings logic.
What does the Baltic Exchange publish for ship values?
Weekly sale and purchase assessments and a demolition assessment, both introduced in 2004.
The sale and purchase assessments cover five-year-old vessels at fixed nominal sizes: VLCC 305,000 dwt, Aframax 105,000 dwt, MR 45,000 dwt, Capesize 172,000 dwt, Panamax 74,000 dwt and Supramax 52,000 dwt, with Handysize added from 3 April 2020 at 38,200 dwt on the Imabari 38 design.
How is a Baltic assessment produced?
Each assessment other than the forward curves is the simple arithmetic average of submissions from vetted independent shipbrokers.
Because the sale and purchase market is thin, panellists weight what transactional evidence exists against tonnage availability, order lists, sentiment and news flow. Panellists do not invest in the markets they report and no part of their remuneration is linked to benchmark performance.
Is an automated valuation the same as a broker valuation?
No. A model provider such as VesselsValue, founded in 2011 and acquired by Veson Nautical in a transaction announced on 11 April 2023, produces daily vessel-specific values across eight value categories from a base of more than 100,000 historical transactions.
A broker valuation is a signed opinion from a named house on a named ship, which is normally what loan documentation requires.
Which sale form is current for a secondhand ship sale?
SALEFORM 2025, announced by BIMCO in a Documentary Committee update published on 26 February 2026.
Copyright is held by the Norwegian Shipbrokers’ Association rather than by BIMCO. SALEFORM 2012 remains in wide use and will appear on live transactions for years, because deals in progress do not migrate to a new edition.
Does SALEFORM 2012 fix the deposit at 10%?
No, and this is the most commonly repeated error about the form.
Clause 2 leaves the deposit percentage as a blank for the parties to complete and supplies 10% only as a fallback where the box is left empty. The pre-printed lodgement period is three Banking Days after the Agreement date and confirmation that the account is open, and interest accrues to the buyers unless amended.
What changed in SALEFORM 2025?
The deposit holder becomes a formal escrow agent under a separate escrow agreement executed alongside the memorandum of agreement, and the agent must confirm in writing that it can accept the funds before the deposit is payable.
An optional know-your-customer long-stop allows the compliant party to terminate with no liability. Four clauses are new at 16 to 19: anti-bribery, sanctions, EU Emissions Trading System and FuelEU Maritime.
When does a seller's claim to the deposit become a debt?
Only once the deposit holder confirms the account is open.
In King Crude Carriers SA v Ridgebury November LLC [2025] UKSC 39, judgment of 12 November 2025, the UK Supreme Court held unanimously that there is no deemed fulfilment principle in English law and that the steps around the deposit accounts are conditions precedent to the debt accruing, following and approving The Blankenstein [1985] 1 WLR 435.
Why did the sellers recover nothing in King Crude Carriers?
Because they were confined to a claim in damages rather than in debt, and on the assumed facts the market value had risen above the contract price by termination, so the damages measure produced no loss.
The commercial consequence is that a buyer facing a rising market was better off breaching before lodging the deposit than after, which is the gap the SALEFORM 2025 escrow redraft addresses.
What are the alternatives to the Norwegian Saleform?
BIMCO’s SHIPSALE 22, published in 2022 and built around electronic signature and e-document workflows; NIPPONSALE 1999, the Japan Shipping Exchange form issued in 1965 and last amended on 2 November 1999 with arbitration at TOMAC; and the Singapore Ship Sale Form 2011, launched in January 2011 with Singapore as the default arbitral seat and a choice of Singapore or English law.
Is there a NIPPONSALE 2022?
No. The current edition is NIPPONSALE 1999.
The 2022 form is BIMCO’s SHIPSALE 22, which is a different document published by a different body, and the two are sometimes confused because of the year.
What does a buyer inspect before taking delivery?
The ship physically, and the classification records, of which the records are usually the more valuable half.
The class file documents every survey, every condition of class and every outstanding recommendation, which is a noted defect the society requires rectified within a set period. A ship can pass a walkthrough and still carry deferred work that will cost heavily at the next drydock.
What does encumbrance-free delivery protect against?
A maritime lien attaches to the hull by operation of law and survives a private sale, so an unpaid crew wage, a salvage claim or a damage claim from the previous owner can be enforced against the new owner by arresting the ship.
Clause 9 of SALEFORM 2012 is the warranty against that, backed by the seller’s indemnity and by deletion of the old mortgage from the outgoing registry.
Can any private sale give a buyer clean title?
No. Only a judicial sale extinguishes prior maritime liens.
That is why an arrested ship sold by a court can fetch more than the same ship sold privately under a cloud, and it is the single most important limit on what a seller’s encumbrance-free warranty can actually deliver.
Does NEWBUILDCON set the instalment split?
No. Clause 15 provides that instalments fall due in accordance with Box 11, which the parties complete, so the familiar structure of payments at signing, steel cutting, keel laying, launching and delivery is market practice rather than a contractual term.
What the form does fix is that pre-delivery instalments are advances, not deposits.
What is a refund guarantee?
A bank guarantee issued by the shipyard’s bank in the buyer’s favour, repaying pre-delivery instalments with interest if the yard defaults, becomes insolvent or fails to deliver.
Under NEWBUILDCON it sits at clause 16, with the specimen at Annex A(iii) and the bank named in Box 32, provided with each pre-delivery instalment invoice for that instalment plus interest.
What is an instalment guarantee, and how does it differ?
It runs the other way. Under NEWBUILDCON clause 16 the buyer provides an irrevocable guarantee in the builder’s favour, form at Annex A(ii) with the bank named in Box 31, due within five Banking Days of the contract’s effective date under clause 44.
It secures the buyer’s obligation to pay, where the refund guarantee secures the builder’s obligation to repay.
What happens if the yard disputes a refund demand?
Under the NEWBUILDCON Annex A(iii) form the guarantee is a primary, on-demand obligation, but payment may be deferred where the builder disputes the repayment claim within 28 days of demand, until the dispute is resolved.
That deferral is why the standing of the guaranteeing bank and the precise wording are negotiated as closely as the price.
Which newbuilding contract forms are in use?
The Shipbuilders’ Association of Japan form of January 1974 across Asian yards; the AWES form, introduced in 1972 and revised and reissued in May 1999, in Europe; the Norwegian SHIP 2000; the CMAC Shanghai Form of March 2011 in China; BIMCO’s NEWBUILDCON of 2007; and the MARAD form for United States newbuildings financed under Title XI of the Merchant Marine Act 1936.
How much of a newbuilding can an export credit agency finance?
A maximum of 80% of the contract price, with a minimum cash payment of 20% by delivery and a maximum repayment term of 12 years after delivery, under the OECD Sector Understanding on Export Credits for Ships.
It applies to any new sea-going vessel of 100 gt and above, plus conversions and hovercraft.
Did the 2023 OECD reform extend ship credit terms to 15 years?
No. The wider OECD Arrangement was modernized with effect from 15 July 2023 and generally allows credit periods of up to 15 years, but the Sector Understanding for ships was not changed to match.
The 12-year term and the 20% minimum cash payment still stand for ships.
Does IAS 16 require a 25-year useful life for a ship?
No. IAS 16 requires an entity-specific estimate of useful life and residual value, reviewed at least at each financial year end under paragraph 51, with any change treated as a change in accounting estimate under IAS 8 and applied prospectively.
Straight-line depreciation over a 20 to 25 year life is the shipping convention, not a requirement of the standard.
Is residual value the expected future scrap price?
No. IAS 16 paragraph 6 measures residual value at current prices, as the amount currently obtainable on disposal net of estimated disposal costs, for an asset already of the age and condition expected at the end of its useful life.
Forecasting a future scrap price is not what the standard asks for.
Does IAS 16 require component depreciation for ships?
Yes. Paragraph 43 requires each part of an item with a cost significant in relation to the total cost of the item to be depreciated separately.
The standard sets no numeric significance threshold, which leaves the identification of components to judgement and makes it a recurring question between shipping companies and their auditors.
How is a drydocking accounted for?
Under IAS 16 paragraph 14 the cost of a major inspection is capitalized as a replacement when the recognition criteria are met, and the carrying amount of the previous inspection is derecognized at the same time.
The capitalized amount is then amortized across the interval to the next drydocking. Routine repairs and maintenance are expensed as incurred.
When must a vessel be tested for impairment?
When an indicator is present, not annually.
A vessel is property, plant and equipment, so IAS 36 testing is indicator-driven, and the paragraph 12 list of indicators is expressly not exhaustive. In shipping the usual triggers are falling charter rates, falling secondhand values, laid-up tonnage and a market capitalization below net assets.
What is the recoverable amount of a ship?
The higher of fair value less costs of disposal and value in use, and only one needs to be computed where it already exceeds the carrying amount.
Broker valuations of comparable tonnage usually make fair value less costs of disposal the practical starting point. Value in use under paragraph 33 is built from management-approved budgets, excluding financing cash flows and interest-bearing debt.
Is each ship its own cash-generating unit?
A vessel on time charter typically generates largely independent cash inflows and is her own cash-generating unit under IAS 36 paragraph 6.
Vessels trading in a pool or on interdependent liner networks may have to be grouped. The level of aggregation is the decisive judgement, because grouping can conceal an impairment that a ship-by-ship test would expose.
Can a vessel impairment be reversed?
Yes. Only goodwill impairment is irreversible under IAS 36.
Where the indicators no longer exist, a vessel impairment is reversed through profit or loss, capped at the carrying amount that would have existed had no impairment been recognized.
Why do banks lend against market value rather than book value?
Because book value is depreciated historical cost on a fixed schedule and is indifferent to the freight market, while market value is what the ship would actually realize on enforcement.
That is why a loan-to-value covenant is tested against a current broker valuation, and why falling values can breach a covenant while the accounts show nothing wrong.
What creates a ship mortgage's priority?
Recordation, not execution.
Under Liberian Maritime Law, Title 21 of the Liberian Code of Laws of 1956, section 101(1), a valid mortgage covering the whole of a vessel takes preferred status as of the date of its recordation, and section 101(2) preserves that status even where no advance has yet been made.
What happens to mortgage priority when a ship changes flag?
Under Liberian Maritime Law section 101(3), a mortgage granted in continuation of a prior recorded mortgage, including one recorded under another jurisdiction’s law while the vessel was documented there, takes preferred status as of the date of recordation of the earlier mortgage.
Separately, Article 3 of the 1993 Convention bars deregistration unless registered mortgages are deleted or all holders consent in writing.
Does a registered mortgage rank ahead of a maritime lien?
No. Article 5(1) of the International Convention on Maritime Liens and Mortgages, 1993 places the Article 4 maritime liens ahead of registered mortgages, hypotheques and charges.
National law reaches a similar result by its own route, and Liberian Maritime Law section 113 lists the specific claims that outrank a preferred mortgage lien on a sale in rem.
Which claims are maritime liens under the 1993 Convention?
Five, on a closed list at Article 4(1): crew wages and related sums including repatriation and social insurance contributions; loss of life or personal injury in direct connection with the operation of the vessel; salvage reward; port, canal, waterway and pilotage dues; and tort claims for physical loss or damage caused by the operation of the vessel, excluding cargo, containers and passengers’ effects.
Necessaries are not on the list.
Can a bunker supplier outrank a first-priority ship mortgage?
In the United States, yes, in a defined case.
Under 46 U.S.C. 31326, for a foreign vessel whose mortgage is not guaranteed under chapter 537, the preferred mortgage lien is subordinate to a maritime lien for necessaries provided in the United States. That makes the trading pattern of a foreign-flag ship a real consideration for her mortgagee, not only a commercial one.
Is the 1993 Convention on maritime liens and mortgages widely in force?
It entered into force on 5 September 2004 and had 21 parties as at 4 September 2026, but neither England, the United States, Panama, Liberia nor the Marshall Islands is among them.
In the principal arrest and mortgage-registration centres, national law governs rather than the Convention.
Is the Beijing Convention on judicial sales in force?
Yes. The United Nations Convention on the International Effects of Judicial Sales of Ships was adopted on 7 December 2022 by General Assembly resolution 77/100, opened for signature in Beijing on 5 September 2023, and entered into force on 17 February 2026 under Article 21(1), 180 days after the third instrument.
It had 34 signatories and 5 parties as at 4 September 2026: Barbados, El Salvador, Spain, Panama and the European Union.
What does the Beijing Convention require a registry to do?
On production of the certificate of judicial sale, Article 7 requires the registry of a state party to delete mortgages and charges registered before completion of the sale, and either delete the ship and issue a deletion certificate for new registration or register her in the purchaser’s name.
Article 8 requires a court to dismiss an arrest application or release an arrested ship for a claim arising before the sale. Both are subject to a public-policy exception.
Does the Beijing Convention apply to sales that happened before it came into force?
No. Article 21(3) applies the Convention only to judicial sales ordered or approved after it entered into force in respect of the state of judicial sale.
Article 3 adds a further limit: the sale must be conducted in a state party and the ship must have been physically within that state’s territory at the time of sale.
What is a minimum value clause and when does it bite?
It requires the market value of the mortgaged ships to stay above a stated percentage of the loan outstanding.
Nothing about the ship or the loan need change for it to breach: a fall in secondhand values alone lifts the ratio. The borrower cures by prepaying debt or posting additional security within a stated period, commonly 30 days.
Does a recovery in values during the cure period cancel a default notice?
Not automatically under English law.
The lender is entitled to rely on the express terms of the loan-to-value clause and to accelerate on the event of default even where values recover during the cure window, which is why the covenant is a harder instrument than its arithmetic suggests.
What sits alongside the mortgage in a security package?
A deed of covenants setting out the owner’s operational, insurance, class and trading obligations; an assignment of earnings and insurances; a pledge of the shares in the owning company; and, where a charterer has taken possession, a quiet enjoyment letter.
Hull and machinery insurance protects the asset and mortgagee interest insurance protects the lender against a failure of that cover.
Why is a lessor's position stronger than a mortgagee's?
Because the lessor owns the asset.
A mortgagee holds a charge over someone else’s ship and, on enforcement, ranks behind court costs and preferred maritime liens. That is why a sale and leaseback can advance a higher proportion of a ship’s value than a conventional mortgage, and why leasing grew as bank lending to shipping tightened.
Is a time charter a lease under IFRS 16?
Usually yes, because the charterer directs how and for what purpose the named ship is used within the period.
A bareboat charter clearly is a lease. A voyage charter or a contract of affreightment generally is not, because the use is predetermined, the customer cannot change it during the period of use, does not operate the ship and did not design her.
What defeats lease classification even where a named ship is identified?
A substantive substitution right. Under IFRS 16 the supplier must have the practical ability to substitute an alternative asset throughout the period of use and must derive economic benefit from doing so.
Where that right is substantive, there is no identified asset and therefore no lease.
How large is bank lending to shipping?
Petrofin Research put top 40 bank lending at USD 300.6 billion as at 31 December 2025, up 6% on USD 283.6 billion, with total bank lending including local banks at about USD 425 billion, which it assessed as just over 60% of all ship finance.
Petrofin restates prior years between editions, so figures must be quoted by edition and not compared across them.
How many banks have signed the Poseidon Principles?
36 signatories across 14 countries, on the Sixth Annual Disclosure Report published on 15 December 2025, together covering almost three-quarters of global ship finance on the report’s own attribution to the 2024 Marine Money Shipping Portfolio League Table.
Disclosure covered 95% of eligible portfolio activity, up from 93%.
Did Poseidon Principles coverage fall from 80% to three-quarters?
No. The Fifth report of 12 December 2024 and the Sixth report state coverage on different bases and against different denominators, and the Sixth attributes its figure to the 2024 Marine Money league table.
Signatories rose from 35 to 36 over the same period, and portfolio misalignment against the minimum trajectory narrowed from just over 19% to just under 12%.
What is light displacement tonnage, and why not use deadweight?
Light displacement tonnage is the weight of the ship in light condition: hull, structure, machinery, equipment and fittings, with no cargo, fuel, water, ballast, stores, passengers or crew aboard.
Recycling yards buy recoverable steel, and LDT is the closest available proxy for it. Deadweight measures what a ship can carry and drives her earnings, not what she is made of.
Are recycling prices quoted in long tons or metric tonnes?
The contract has to state which.
Sources differ, and a long ton of 2,240 lb is about 1.6% heavier than a metric tonne, so on a 20,000 LDT hull the choice of unit is a six-figure difference at any plausible rate. Neither party should assume the other means the same thing.
Where is ship recycling actually carried out?
Bangladesh, India, Pakistan and Turkiye together accounted for over 91% of it in 2024, on UNCTAD’s Review of Maritime Transport 2025.
Total recycling that year was 6.3 million gross tons, matching 2023 and equal to 0.25% of the global fleet, with bulk carriers the largest share.
Which article brought the Hong Kong Convention into force?
Article 17, not Article 16. Article 16 governs signature, ratification, acceptance, approval and accession.
Article 17(1) sets entry into force at 24 months after three cumulative conditions are met: not less than 15 states; combined merchant fleets of not less than 40% of world merchant shipping gross tonnage; and combined maximum annual recycling volume over the preceding 10 years of not less than 3% of those states’ combined gross tonnage.
What must a ship carry under the Hong Kong Convention?
An Inventory of Hazardous Materials under regulation 5, verified by survey under regulation 10 and certified under regulation 11 by an International Certificate on Inventory of Hazardous Materials.
Before recycling she needs a ship-specific Ship Recycling Plan under regulation 9, and an International Ready for Recycling Certificate after the final survey.
When must an existing ship have its Hong Kong Convention initial survey?
Not later than five years after the Convention entered into force, that is by 26 June 2030.
Where an existing ship’s initial and final surveys are conducted at the same time, only an International Ready for Recycling Certificate is issued.
What must a recycling yard hold under the Convention?
Authorization by a Party under regulation 16.1, granted on the basis of a Ship Recycling Facility Plan under regulation 18 and evidenced by a Document of Authorization to conduct Ship Recycling in the form of appendix 5 to the annex.
Regulation 15.3 obliges each Party to run an inspection, monitoring and enforcement mechanism with powers of entry and sampling.
Can an EU-flagged ship be sent to a beaching yard?
No. Regulation (EU) No 1257/2013 confines the recycling of EU-flagged ships above 500 gross tons to facilities on the European List, and no facility on that list uses beaching.
The Hong Kong Convention permits recycling at an authorized facility including a beaching yard, so the EU regime is a stricter overlay rather than a parallel one.
Does the EU ship recycling regime reach non-EU-flagged ships?
In one respect, yes.
Article 12(1) of Regulation (EU) No 1257/2013, applicable since 31 December 2020 under Article 32(2)(b), requires a ship flying the flag of a third country calling at a Member State port or anchorage to carry an inventory of hazardous materials complying with Article 5(2), and port authorities may inspect for it.
How many facilities are on the European List?
41, as replaced by Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2026/448 of 27 February 2026: 28 in Part A, being 21 in EU Member States and 7 in Norway, and 13 in Part B, being 10 in Turkiye, 2 in the United Kingdom and 1 in the United States.
Listings run five years and each entry states the recycling method, the maximum ship size and the authorized annual output.
Has a facility ever been removed from the European List for non-compliance?
Yes. Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2026/448 removed a Turkish facility following an Article 15(4) inspection that could not confirm continued compliance with Article 13(1)(g), because it cut the primary hull on the shoreline without an impermeable floor and without a slag collector and did not take sufficient measures to collect and contain waste.
Two other facilities were removed on authorization grounds.
Which contract governs a demolition sale?
BIMCO’s RECYCLECON, latest edition 2012, for green recycling, which voluntarily incorporates the inventory and ship recycling plan requirements.
The older DEMOLISHCON, latest edition 2001, does not carry that framework. A RECYCLECON revision to align the form with the Hong Kong Convention was still in progress at BIMCO’s Documentary Committee meeting of 11 December 2025 and has not been adopted.
What is a cash buyer in a demolition sale?
An intermediary that buys the ship for its own account and resells her to a recycling yard, sometimes after a change of flag and name.
The structure moves the yard relationship, the payment risk and some of the reputational exposure off the owner, and it is the normal commercial route rather than an aberration.
Can a seller be prosecuted over a beaching sale?
It has happened. In a judgment of the Rechtbank Rotterdam of 15 March 2018, ECLI:NL:RBROT:2018:2108, a director of a large shipping company was convicted of breaching Regulation (EC) No 1013/2006 on shipments of waste by sending four ships from Rotterdam and Hamburg to beaches in India, Bangladesh and Turkiye for demolition.
The court held the ships were waste and imposed a fine of EUR 50,000 and a one-year professional ban.
Is a shipbroker liable for a death at a recycling yard?
That question is open in England.
In Begum v Maran (UK) Ltd [2021] EWCA Civ 326, judgment of 10 March 2021, the Court of Appeal refused to strike out a negligence claim against an English shipbroker arising from a death at the Zuma Enterprise Yard in Chattogram, holding the pleaded duty was not fanciful on the assumed facts. It did not decide that a duty exists, and it allowed the appeal on Article 7 of Rome II so that the Bangladeshi limitation period applied.
What is the asset play, and what ends it?
Buying a secondhand ship near the bottom of the price cycle to sell her near the top, capturing the capital gain rather than the operating margin.
Three things end it: timing, because a trough can outlast the owner’s patience; leverage, because a further fall in values breaches the loan-to-value covenant; and carrying cost, because a hull held through a trough consumes money every day it waits.
When does an ageing ship become worth more as scrap than as a trading asset?
When the expected cost of the next special survey and drydocking, including steel renewal, exceeds the earnings the remaining life would generate net of operating cost.
That comparison, rather than the ship’s age, is what tips a demolition decision, which is why survey position is priced into every secondhand bid.
What is the difference between hot and cold lay-up?
Hot lay-up keeps machinery operational under a reduced crew and allows a return to service in days.
Cold lay-up shuts systems down under a preservation regime and takes weeks and a substantial bill to reverse. Neither reduces the carrying cost to zero, and the choice turns entirely on how long the owner expects the trough to last.
Does a poor carbon intensity rating reduce a ship's market value?
It affects the inputs that produce the value rather than the value directly.
A ship’s carbon intensity indicator rating and her energy efficiency position affect which charterers will take her, which lenders will finance her and on what terms, and therefore what a buyer will pay for the remaining years of her life. That is a residual-value question presented as a compliance question.
No question matches. Try a shorter or different word.
Sources
- International Convention on Maritime Liens and Mortgages, 1993 (UN/IMO Conference of Plenipotentiaries, Geneva, 6 May 1993). Articles 4, 5 and 12 unctad.org
- United Nations Convention on the International Effects of Judicial Sales of Ships (Beijing Convention), adopted 7 December 2022 by General Assembly resolution 77/100, in force 17 February 2026. status and Articles 5 to 9, 21 treaties.un.org
- Regulation (EU) No 1257/2013 of 20 November 2013 on ship recycling. Articles 5, 12, 13, 16 and 32 eur-lex.europa.eu
- Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2026/448 of 27 February 2026 amending Implementing Decision (EU) 2016/2323 as regards updates to the European List of ship recycling facilities data.europa.eu
- IAS 16 Property, Plant and Equipment (IASB). paragraphs 6, 14, 43, 50 and 51 ifrs.org
- IAS 36 Impairment of Assets (IASB). paragraphs 6, 12 and 33 ifrs.org
- OECD Sector Understanding on Export Credits for Ships, Annex I to the Arrangement on Officially Supported Export Credits legalinstruments.oecd.org
- 46 U.S.C. 31326. Court sales to enforce preferred mortgage liens and maritime liens, and priority of claims uscode.house.gov
- Liberian Maritime Law, Title 21 of the Liberian Code of Laws of 1956 (RLM-107). sections 101 and 113 liscr.com
- Begum v Maran (UK) Ltd [2021] EWCA Civ 326 (Court of Appeal of England and Wales, 10 March 2021) caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk