Stirling Air-Independent Propulsion for Submarines

Stirling AIP for submarines: how Kockums closed-cycle diesel and liquid oxygen extend submerged endurance, compared with fuel cells and MESMA, plus limits.

Contents16 sections

Stirling air-independent propulsion (AIP) is a non-nuclear submarine power plant in which a Stirling heat engine, heated by diesel fuel burned with stored liquid oxygen, drives a generator while the boat is fully submerged and without any intake of atmospheric air. It was developed by Kockums of Sweden, now Saab Kockums, and first went to sea in HSwMS Näcken, which received an eight-metre AIP section in 1988.

The plant does not replace the diesel-electric propulsion of a conventional submarine. It is an add-on: a compact store of oxygen and a slow, quiet energy converter that keeps the battery charged at patrol speed, so the boat need not raise a snorkel. Kockums put the gain at several hundred hours of low-speed submerged running, more than four times the energy in the ordinary battery (Pelle Stenberg, Kockums AB, The Submarine Review, October 1996). Saab describes it as extending submerged endurance “from days to weeks”.

Two navies operate Stirling-powered boats in series: Sweden, in the Gotland and Södermanland classes, and Japan, in the first ten boats of the Soryu class, whose engines Kawasaki Heavy Industries built under licence. The A26 Blekinge class for Sweden carries the next installation. Competing non-nuclear plants use fuel cells (Singapore’s Type 218SG), reformer-fed fuel cells (Spain’s S-80) or the French MESMA system. Japan’s last two Soryu-class boats carry lithium-ion batteries instead of AIP. For the contrasting case of a reactor plant, see naval nuclear propulsion.

The battery limit that AIP addresses

A conventional submarine’s submerged endurance is set by its battery, and AIP exists to extend it without enlarging the boat. Submerged, the electric motor draws on a lead-acid (or, in the newest boats, lithium-ion) battery. To recharge it the boat must run marine diesel engines, which need air, so it comes to periscope depth and raises a snorkel mast to draw air in and pass exhaust out. That mast, its exhaust plume and the diesel noise are what search radar, periscope-detection radar and passive sonar look for.

Kockums framed the problem in 1996 in plain numbers. Better batteries, and more of them, had stretched the endurance of some battery boats “towards the 100 hour mark”. In practice the interval between charges is shorter, because a commander keeps a tactical reserve of around 50 percent rather than run the battery flat. Kockums also wrote that a state-of-the-art lead-acid cell then held more than twice the energy of a cell of the same weight 50 years earlier, and that further gains would come at rising cost.

Adding battery is the obvious remedy, and it fails on size. Kockums argued that it “will quickly drive boat size to unacceptable levels”. The alternative is to carry reactants with far higher energy density than any battery and convert them aboard. That is the definition of AIP used in this article: a plant that generates power submerged from stored fuel and oxidizer, with no air taken from the atmosphere.

The idea is older than the Stirling plant. Kockums traced it to the Second World War, when airborne radar “forever” drove submarines off the surface and the snorkel was introduced to let a boat charge while submerged. The late-war German Type XXI approach of carrying much more battery shaped the first two post-war Swedish submarine generations, which Kockums states were modelled on that German design.

What an add-on module changes

The Swedish concept is a separate autonomous hull section that can be inserted into an existing submarine or designed into a new one. Kockums assessed that stretching an existing boat by 15 to 20 percent to take the module would have no notable impact on its original performance, against a gain of “a factor of 4 to 5” in submerged endurance. The module had to be weight-compensated so the converted boat stayed inside its original trim polygon, the envelope of weight and moment the ballast and trim tanks can correct.

Kockums described the intended patrol profile. The boat enters its area on AIP with a full battery, and AIP running does not discharge it. When an engagement needs power flexibility, the AIP plant is shut down and the battery takes over; afterwards the boat returns to AIP, and the cycle repeats until the oxygen is used up. In Kockums’ words, the boat has then spent “many days” in the area and “remained air-independent and stealthy during the whole period”, with roughly another hundred hours of battery in reserve on top of the AIP running.

Swedish AIP programmes before the Stirling engine

Sweden reached the Stirling engine after two abandoned attempts, and the reasons it abandoned them explain the plant’s design. Kockums set out this history in its 1996 account.

PeriodConceptOutcome (Kockums, 1996)
Early 1960sClosed-cycle diesel engine: exhaust scrubbed of carbon dioxide and recirculated to the intake, with oxygen carried aboard as high-test peroxideReached full-scale testing in a land facility; terminated over uncertainty in technology and cost. The submarine design went ahead as a pure conventional boat, five delivered by Kockums between 1968 and 1972
Following programmeFuel cells reacting oxygen and hydrogenReached an advanced land-based testing stage; terminated over uncertainty in technology and cost
Late 1970sAdd-on concept: an autonomous AIP hull module to augment the battery at low speedAdopted as the basis of the Swedish system
Early 1980sEnergy-converter studiesPointed to the Stirling engine as the best candidate
From 1982Rig testing of the power unit (engine, overpressure combustion chamber, generator, controls), with parallel LOX handling and storage trialsLed to the Näcken installation

Both early programmes aimed to replace the diesel and battery for every running mode. Lowering that ambition to an add-on for slow, quiet running is what made a modest engine of tens of kilowatts sufficient. Kockums gave three reasons the Stirling engine won: high efficiency, the energy density of storing oxygen as LOX and using fuel oil as the fuel, and the prospect of excellent balancing with continuous combustion, which promised to meet strict noise requirements.

The Stirling cycle and the helium working gas

A Stirling engine is a closed-cycle, externally heated piston engine: a fixed charge of gas is shuttled between a hot space and a cold space, and its expansion when hot does more work than its compression when cold. Robert Stirling’s name attaches to the cycle. In the submarine engine the working gas is helium, and the heat comes from a separate combustion chamber.

Kockums described the ideal cycle in four steps:

  1. Isothermal compression on the cold side.
  2. Constant-volume displacement of the gas from the cold side to the hot side.
  3. Isothermal expansion of the heated working gas.
  4. Constant-volume displacement from the hot side back to the cold side.

In a real engine the steps overlap. The gas passes through a regenerator, a matrix that takes heat from the gas on its way to the cold side and gives it back on the return, so that heat is recycled within the engine rather than rejected to the coolant each cycle. The cold side rejects heat to the boat’s cooling water. In the submarine installation the cooling chain runs through fresh-water and seawater circuits; Saab’s account of the Gotland mid-life upgrade lists sea water cooling, fresh water cooling and water chiller units in the new section.

Why the heat source is external

External combustion separates the burning of fuel from the working space. The helium never meets the combustion products, and the flame burns continuously rather than in the separate firing strokes of a diesel. Kockums wrote that the cylinder pressure curve is “sinusoidal and smooth”, which is the source of the engine’s low vibration. The same separation lets the combustion run at whatever pressure the exhaust system needs, which is the key to discharging exhaust at depth.

Helium as the working gas

Kockums states that “the working gas, i.e. the gas contained inside the engine and the heater, is helium”. Helium suits a submarine because it is inert and cannot burn or support combustion inside a closed pressure hull. It also has high thermal conductivity and low molecular weight, which let the gas carry heat in and out of the heater and cooler tubes quickly at engine speed. Kockums does not publish its reasons for the choice.

The Kockums power unit

The Kockums engine-generator set combines a four-cylinder Stirling engine, an overpressure combustion chamber mounted on top of it, and an electrical generator, all integrated in a module with its oxygen and fuel systems. Saab describes the engines as “integrated in complete modules which also contain oxygen and fuel systems, along with a generator”. The designation used across Kockums, Saab and Kawasaki documents is V4-275R.

Kockums’ published figures:

  • Four cylinders and pistons, driving a crankshaft and the generator.
  • Run at a constant speed of 2,000 rpm, developing up to 75 kW.
  • Meticulously balanced and fitted on a double elastic mounting.
  • Combustion gas temperature of 1,800 °C, with an average of 750 °C at the heater tube walls.

An earlier paper, by H. Nilsson in the Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part A, vol. 202 (1988), described the two V4-275R engines of the civil SAGA 1 installation as of “maximum 100kW power each”. The two figures come from different installations and different years, and neither source says whether it is shaft or electrical output.

Kockums also wrote that a total system of four units “could easily support even a large submarine at slow speeds and including the hotel load”. The Japanese Soryu class, at 2,950 tons, carries exactly four (Kawasaki Heavy Industries, 18 March 2019).

Controlling flame temperature in pure oxygen

Diesel burned in pure oxygen would reach a flame temperature the heater tubes could not survive. Kockums dilutes the incoming oxygen with recirculated combustion gas to hold the gas at 1,800 °C. The recirculation has no moving parts: the inrushing oxygen creates a static pressure drop at its injection points, which draws part of the combustion products back to mix with it. Fuel is injected by conventional fuel-oil pumps.

Discharging exhaust against diving pressure

The combustion chamber is a pressure vessel, and the plant runs it at an overpressure corresponding to a set diving depth. On the reactant side, an overpressure is held in the oxygen supply tank. The exhaust, which Kockums lists as carbon dioxide, water and some excess oxygen, leaves through a line ending in a non-return valve “set to the maximum diving pressure” and a disperser into the outgoing cooling-water flow. Saab’s 2022 brochure states that the exhaust gases are cooled and dissolved in water before release into the sea.

Because the chamber already sits above sea pressure, no exhaust compressor is needed to push the gas overboard. That matters on two counts: a compressor would consume a share of a plant rated in tens of kilowatts, and it would add a rotating noise source to a system built for silence. The cost is that the plant’s maximum operating depth on AIP is tied to the pressure rating chosen for the combustion system, a figure Kockums did not publish.

Liquid oxygen storage

Kockums called LOX “a daily industrial commodity in many countries”, with established storage and handling practice, while noting that carrying it in a submarine on missions of several weeks needs superb thermal insulation and integration with the boat’s safety case. The standard Swedish installation, per Kockums:

  • Two tanks of stainless steel, each with inner and outer structures separated by high-vacuum multilayer insulation.
  • Fitted inboard and resiliently connected to the hull structure for shock protection.
  • Internal pressure held constant by evaporating LOX and feeding the gas to the tank top, so the tanks can supply the combustion chamber directly.
  • Oxygen drawn from the tank bottom as liquid and gasified in an evaporator, heated from the Stirling engine’s fresh-water cooling system.

This is the same physics as the cryogenic cargo containment of an LNG carrier, at much smaller scale and with oxygen’s added fire hazard: oxygen does not burn, but an oxygen-enriched atmosphere makes ordinary materials burn fiercely. For SAGA 1, Nilsson’s paper names AGA Cryo of Gothenburg as the LOX storage supplier. A wider treatment of the hazard is at liquid oxygen storage and handling at sea.

Fuel and integration with the boat

The fuel storage and handling system is integrated with the bunkering and tankage of the diesel engines (Kockums, 1996). Saab states that the heat “is derived from low-sulphur diesel which is combusted using liquid oxygen” and that the same fuel serves the diesels and the Stirling engines. So the only consumable the plant adds is oxygen.

In the Gotland class the system sits in the compartment just aft of the pressure-tight bulkhead that divides the hull in two: the engine-generator modules on the upper level, the oxygen tanks on the lower level. Control is a small panel within the propulsion console, from which starting and stopping the AIP plant is a push-button operation, alongside control of the diesel-generator sets, the main motor and the battery (Kockums, 1996). The Stirling generators join the diesel generator sets as a source of charge for the battery, which the AIP plant exists to augment.

Development history: SAGA 1, Näcken and the Gotland class

The V4-275R went to sea first in a civil submarine and a converted naval one at about the same time, and the Gotland class was the first designed around it. Nilsson’s 1988 IMechE paper is the earliest primary record of the hardware; Saab and Kockums documents cover the naval boats.

SAGA 1

SAGA 1 was a 500-ton manned diver lock-out submarine for the French offshore firm Comex, nearing completion in Marseille when Nilsson wrote. Its plant was two V4-275R engines with two liquid oxygen tanks holding enough oxygen for 10,000 kWh, for missions of up to 14 days submerged. The same paper records that a Swedish full-scale test section had been running “since mid 1985”. SAGA 1 was a parallel customer for the engine, not the Swedish Navy’s test bed. Its diver lock-out role made it a submarine counterpart of saturation diving support.

HSwMS Näcken

Näcken was the first submarine in the world fitted with a Stirling engine. Saab’s 2015 account states that she “was placed in dry-dock and cut in two” and that “a fully outfitted eight-meter AIP section was then inserted”, with the first installation in 1988. Kockums dated “the complete installation in the submarine NACKEN” to 1989, followed by “a number of successful patrols”. Saab’s own company timeline files the event under 1987. The most specific primary statements give 1988 for the installation and 1989 for completion.

The Gotland class

The Gotland class (A19) was the first submarine class built with AIP installed during construction, per Saab’s 2022 brochure. Kockums wrote in October 1996 that the three boats were contracted in the early 1990s; that the lead boat completed acceptance sea trials and was delivered to the fleet in mid 1996; that the second began sea trials in July 1996, five months after launch; and that the third would be launched in September 1996 with sea acceptance trials in early 1997. The three boats are HSwMS Gotland, Uppland and Halland. See Gotland-class submarine for the class itself.

Stirling generations and the Gotland mid-life upgrade

The Stirling engine in service today is the third generation, which Saab calls Stirling Mk3. Saab’s February 2017 account describes it as having “increased efficiency and power density, as well as a new control system and HMI”, and states that two Gotland-class boats would be fitted with it.

The fitting came with the Gotland mid-life upgrade, ordered on 30 June 2015 at SEK 2.1 billion alongside the A26 contract (Saab press release). Saab’s 20 June 2018 release on HSwMS Gotland’s relaunch gives the post-upgrade boat as:

ItemValue (Saab, 20 June 2018)
Displacement1,580 tonnes surfaced
Length62 m
Beam6.2 m
Crew25
PropulsionSingle shaft, diesel-electric and Stirling AIP
AIPStirling AIP MkIII
EnduranceWeeks (submerged)

The hull was cut open in the mid-tank section to add a new section carrying sea water cooling, fresh water cooling and water chiller units, and the optical periscope was replaced by an optronic mast. HMS Halland, the third boat, was launched after her own mid-life upgrade on 13 February 2025; Saab states that more than twenty central systems were replaced and that Gotland and Uppland had undergone similar modifications (Saab, 14 February 2025).

Stirling AIP is in service with Sweden and Japan, and a former Swedish design with an added AIP plant serves in Singapore. Saab’s 2022 brochure states that the AIP system has been delivered to several export customers and has more than 30 years of operational service.

Sweden

Saab states that “all Swedish submarines are equipped with Stirling engines” (2017) and names the Gotland and Södermanland classes as its users (2015). On 29 June 2026 Saab announced that, under a separate agreement between Poland and Sweden, Poland will operate HMS Södermanland as a gap filler before its own A26 boats arrive.

Singapore: the Archer class

The Republic of Singapore Navy’s two Archer-class boats are former Swedish Västergötland-class submarines, bought in 2005 (Saab, November 2023). Singapore’s Ministry of Defence (MINDEF) records that RSS Swordsman, the second boat, was acquired from the Royal Swedish Navy in 2005, launched in Karlskrona on 20 October 2010, and commissioned at Changi Naval Base on 30 April 2013, and that “an Air Independent Propulsion (AIP) system was added” to give greater stealth and reach. MINDEF’s release does not name the type of plant. The Archer class is due to be replaced by the four fuel-cell Type 218SG boats described below.

Japan: the Soryu class

Japan is the only navy outside Sweden to have put Stirling AIP into series production. Saab states that in the 2000s it signed a contract with Kawasaki Heavy Industries for the delivery of Stirling engines and that, “through a licensing agreement and our transfer of knowledge”, Kawasaki implemented the technology in “the first 10 Sōryū Class submarines” of the Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force (Saab, November 2023).

Kawasaki Heavy Industries published the machinery of the tenth boat, JS Shoryu, on her delivery on 18 March 2019:

ItemJS Shoryu, 10th Soryu-class boat (Kawasaki, 18 March 2019)
Length, beam, depth84.0 m, 9.1 m, 10.3 m
Displacement2,950 tons
Diesel enginesKawasaki 12V 25/25 SB-type (2)
AIPKawasaki Kockums V4-275R Stirling engines (4)
MotorElectric propulsion motor (1)
BuildStarted 28 January 2015, launched 6 November 2017, completed 18 March 2019

The class runs to twelve boats, and the last two have no Stirling plant. Kawasaki’s release for JS Toryu, “the 12th Soryu class submarine”, delivered on 24 March 2021, describes “lithium ion battery systems for increased underwater endurance” and lists only the two diesels and one electric propulsion motor. Toryu was started on 27 January 2017 and launched on 6 November 2019. The eleventh boat, JS Oryu, likewise falls outside Saab’s “first 10”. Neither boat was converted: both were built without the Stirling plant. The class article is Soryu-class submarine.

Stirling AIP and lithium-ion batteries in the Soryu class

Japan’s last two Soryu-class boats exchange the Stirling plant and its oxygen for a larger store of electricity, which is the remedy Kockums had argued in 1996 would drive boat size to unacceptable levels on the evidence of lead-acid cells. Kawasaki’s stated purpose for the Toryu battery was “increased underwater endurance”. A wider treatment of the battery technology is at submarine lithium-ion batteries, and the merchant equivalent at battery-hybrid propulsion.

The two approaches spend their energy differently. Stirling AIP delivers a small, steady power for a long time and cannot meet a sprint, so it adds endurance at slow speed only. A lithium-ion battery delivers both slow running and high-speed bursts from one store, but it still has to be recharged by air-breathing diesels once it is empty, while a Stirling boat on patrol can stay down until its oxygen runs out. The JMSDF has not published the comparison that drove its choice, so neither endurance figure can be stated for the Japanese boats.

Sweden has kept Stirling AIP for its next class. Saab’s 30 June 2015 contract release states that the A26 is “equipped with the Kockums Stirling AIP (air-independent propulsion) system”.

AIP technologies compared

Four AIP families are compared here, and they differ in what they burn or react, how they reject their products and what they need from the base. Each row states only what its primary source publishes.

FamilyEnergy converterReactants and storageProductsExamples
Stirling (Kockums)External-combustion Stirling heat engine with generatorLow-sulphur diesel and LOXCarbon dioxide, water, excess oxygen, dissolved overboardGotland and Södermanland classes; Soryu SS-501 to SS-510
Fuel cellFuel-cell modules, for example the Siemens SINAVY rangeHydrogen and oxygenWaterSingapore Type 218SG (fuel-cell AIP, MINDEF 2019)
Reformer fuel cell (Navantia BEST)Proton-exchange membrane fuel cells fed by an onboard bioethanol reformerBioethanol and LOX; hydrogen made on demandWater and reformer productsS-80 class (Spain)
MESMA (France)French AIP systemStored oxygenNot covered by the sources cited hereKockums reported a French AIP system expected in service in 1999

Fuel-cell AIP

A fuel cell converts hydrogen and oxygen directly to electricity and water, with no combustion and no reciprocating parts. Siemens states that its SINAVY fuel-cell modules were “originally designed in close cooperation with the German Navy and HDW over 20 years ago” (22 August 2019). The same release names the earlier BZM34 and BZM120 modules and introduces the BZM evo, with “a nominal power of 40 kW” per module and future plants of 320 to 480 kW. HDW belongs to the German submarine-building lineage covered in Krupp marine engines, which also covers the Type 212A family. The cell chemistry is covered in hydrogen marine fuel cells.

Singapore chose fuel cells for its next boats. MINDEF’s 18 February 2019 fact sheet describes the four Type 218SG Invincible-class submarines as 70 metres long, of 2,000 tonnes surfaced and 2,200 tonnes submerged, with a crew of 28, and “fitted with Air Independent Propulsion systems based on Fuel Cell Technology”. They will replace the Archer and Challenger classes.

The logistics differ from Stirling. A Stirling boat needs diesel, which it already carries, and LOX, an industrial commodity. A hydrogen fuel-cell boat needs a hydrogen supply chain as well, and hydrogen’s handling at a naval base raises the issues covered in hydrogen as a marine fuel.

Reformer-fed fuel cells: Navantia BEST

Spain’s BEST AIP avoids stored hydrogen. Navantia describes it as “based on proton exchange membrane (PEM) fuel cells and bioethanol reforming”: it “produces hydrogen on board, on-demand, from bioethanol”, and the boat stays submerged “for weeks”. On its September 2026 completion of AIP testing in a dedicated section of S-83 Cosme García, Navantia reported that the tests began with the first loading of liquid oxygen and bioethanol on board and that the system had already recharged the batteries of S-81. S-82 was then in harbour and sea trials, and S-83 and S-84 were in construction. The fuel is related to the biofuels used in merchant shipping; in BEST it serves as a liquid carrier for hydrogen. The class is covered at S-80 Plus-class submarine.

MESMA and the French and German programmes

MESMA (Module d’Energie Sous-Marine Autonome) is the French AIP system. None of the sources cited in this article describes its cycle, so its engineering is left to its own article. Kockums noted in 1996 that AIP systems using alternative energy converters were expected in operational service in 1999 (France) and 2003 (Germany).

Operating profile, speed and endurance

A Stirling AIP boat patrols slowly on AIP with its battery held full and draws on the battery only when it needs speed. Kockums designed the add-on module “to augment and complement the battery in order to extend the submerged endurance at low patrol speeds”. The power a submarine needs rises steeply with speed, so a plant sized for patrol speed is small, and one sized for sprint speed would need far more oxygen.

The published endurance figures, with their sources:

  • Kockums, 1996: several hundred hours of low-speed submerged running from the AIP system alone, more than four times the energy in the ordinary battery, plus about another hundred hours from a fully charged battery.
  • SAGA 1 (Nilsson, 1988): LOX for 10,000 kWh and missions of up to 14 days submerged.
  • A26 design (Saab, 2015): up to 18 days underwater at relatively slow speeds before the AIP fuel is exhausted.
  • Saab brochure, 2022: Stirling AIP systems can be sized for fully submerged missions of up to 45 days. This is a statement about how large an installation Saab can supply, not a figure for any built class.

Endurance on AIP is a matter of oxygen stored against power drawn, so a boat’s figure depends on its tank volume, its hotel load and the speed it chooses. Navies do not publish the tank capacities of their boats, which is why the published figures are ranges and design statements rather than measured patrol results.

Noise and vibration

The Stirling plant is built to be quiet at the speeds it runs. Kockums attributed its low vibration and noise to the smooth sinusoidal cylinder pressure, meticulous balancing and the double elastic mounting. Saab quotes Sebastian Lenander, manager of Stirling assembly and testing at Saab Kockums, as saying that “the Stirling engine is quiet and vibration free” and that “no vibrations spread out to the hull making the submarine silent in the water and therefore difficult to find” (2015).

The engine is still a reciprocating machine with a crankshaft, and that is the main acoustic contrast with a fuel-cell stack, which has no reciprocating parts in its energy conversion (its pumps and fans still run). The general mechanisms, structure-borne paths and isolation methods are in ship vibration and underwater radiated noise from ships. At AIP speed the propeller and flow noise also matter; see marine propeller and propeller cavitation. No navy publishes comparative radiated-noise measurements between Stirling and fuel-cell boats.

Logistics and maintenance

The plant’s logistic case is that it adds one consumable. Diesel is already aboard, and LOX is, in Kockums’ words, a daily industrial commodity. Against that, the boat carries a cryogenic system with vacuum-insulated tanks, an oxygen evaporator and a combustion chamber running at 1,800 °C gas temperature in pure oxygen. Saab’s 2022 brochure puts accumulated operation at “varias decenas de miles de horas” (several tens of thousands of hours) over more than 30 years of service.

A26 Blekinge class and the Polish order

The A26 Blekinge class is the next Swedish submarine and the next Stirling AIP installation. Saab’s 30 June 2015 release announced the FMV contract for two A26 boats at SEK 7.6 billion, with deliveries then scheduled to start in 2022 and finish in 2024, and stated that the A26 carries the Kockums Stirling AIP system. The two boats are HSwMS Blekinge and HSwMS Skåne. The class article is A26 Blekinge-class submarine.

Saab’s 2015 design description gave the A26 as “a 62m boat with about 1,800t displacement when surfaced”, able to stay underwater for up to 18 days at relatively slow speeds on AIP. Those are design-stage figures, and Saab has not published final dimensions for the boats under construction.

The schedule slipped. On 13 October 2025 Saab announced an additional FMV order of about SEK 9.6 billion for “the last phase of the production as well as additional scope for material and services” for the two Blekinge-class boats, with “the vast majority of deliveries taking place in the period 2026-2032”. That release states neither a delivery year for each boat nor a total programme value.

Poland became the first export customer. On 29 June 2026 Saab announced an order from the Polish State Treasury Armaments Agency for three A26-type submarines, worth about SEK 47 billion, with final deliveries scheduled during 2038. That release does not describe the AIP fit of the Polish boats. Under the same arrangement Poland will operate HMS Södermanland as a gap filler, which puts a Stirling boat into a second Baltic navy before any Polish A26 is delivered.

An AIP submarine is a warship, and the international merchant-ship conventions do not govern its design or operation. Its passage rights come from UNCLOS. In Sweden the boats are contracted by the Swedish Defence Materiel Administration (FMV), per the Saab contract releases.

UNCLOS: surface transit in the territorial sea

The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), concluded at Montego Bay on 10 December 1982 and in force since 16 November 1994 (UN Treaty Collection, Chapter XXI-6), sets the rule that most limits the covert value of any submarine near a foreign coast. Article 20 states: “In the territorial sea, submarines and other underwater vehicles are required to navigate on the surface and to show their flag.”

So the submerged endurance AIP provides has no legal application in a foreign territorial sea under innocent passage: a submarine exercising that right is on the surface. Article 20 sits in the innocent-passage section of Part II; passage through straits used for international navigation and archipelagic sea lanes passage are separate regimes, governed by Parts III and IV. The related articles, from the same Part II text:

  • Article 29 defines a warship as a ship belonging to the armed forces of a State, bearing its external marks, under the command of an officer duly commissioned by the government whose name appears in the appropriate service list or its equivalent, and manned by a crew under regular armed forces discipline.
  • Article 30 lets the coastal State require a warship that disregards its laws on passage, and ignores a request to comply, to leave the territorial sea immediately.
  • Article 32 preserves the immunities of warships, subject to the stated exceptions.

Article 20 does not extend beyond the territorial sea, to the exclusive economic zone or the high seas. The rules for submarines in straits and archipelagic waters, and the warship regime as a whole, are collected at submarines under UNCLOS.

SOLAS and MARPOL exclusion

The SOLAS Convention does not apply to an AIP submarine: Regulation I/3(a)(i) excepts “ships of war and troopships” unless expressly provided otherwise (see SOLAS Chapter I exceptions). The MARPOL Convention is excluded by Article 3(3) for any warship, naval auxiliary or other State ship on government non-commercial service, but each Party must still adopt measures, not impairing operations, so that such ships act consistently with MARPOL so far as reasonable and practicable (State ships and MARPOL Article 3(3)).

The Annex VI regime does not reach the exhaust dissolved overboard, because MARPOL Article 3(3) excludes the boat. The IGC Code governs liquefied gas carried in bulk as cargo and does not address an oxidizer store such as the LOX tanks. A broader account of how naval vessels sit outside the merchant framework is in naval and defense vessels and naval defense and SAR.

Limitations

This article states only what Kockums, Saab, Kawasaki Heavy Industries, MINDEF, Navantia, Siemens and the United Nations have published. Navies treat the performance of their submarines as classified, so several quantities a practitioner would want are absent by necessity:

  • Tank capacity and AIP endurance per class. No operating navy publishes the LOX capacity of a built boat. The endurance figures given are Kockums’ 1996 general figure, the SAGA 1 design, the A26 design-stage figure and Saab’s sizing range, each attributed to its source.
  • Engine rating. Kockums gave up to 75 kW per engine (1996); Nilsson gave a maximum of 100 kW per engine for SAGA 1 (1988). Neither states whether the figure is shaft or electrical output, and Saab has not published a rating for the Mk3 engine.
  • Maximum depth on AIP. The combustion system’s pressure rating sets it, and Kockums did not publish that rating.
  • Plants whose type the operating navy has not published. Navies that operate AIP boats without publishing the type of plant are not listed as Stirling operators here. That includes the Archer class, for which MINDEF states only that an AIP system was added.
  • Comparative noise. No public measurement compares the radiated noise of Stirling and fuel-cell boats.
  • A26 programme figures. The delivery window and contract values are taken from Saab releases. The Swedish procurement authority’s own boat-by-boat delivery dates are not reproduced here.

The engineering description reflects the Kockums system as published in 1988 and 1996. The Mk3 generation changes efficiency, power density and controls (Saab, 2017), but Saab has not published revised engine parameters.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is Stirling air-independent propulsion?

Stirling air-independent propulsion (AIP) is a non-nuclear submarine power plant in which a Stirling heat engine drives a generator while the boat is fully submerged.

The heat comes from burning diesel fuel with oxygen carried aboard as liquid oxygen (LOX), so the plant needs no atmospheric air and no snorkel. Kockums of Sweden developed it, and Saab Kockums builds it today.

How much power does one Kockums V4-275R Stirling engine produce?

Kockums gave the V4-275R as a four-cylinder engine run at a constant 2,000 rpm that can develop up to 75 kW (Pelle Stenberg, Kockums AB, The Submarine Review, October 1996).

A 1988 IMechE paper on the civil SAGA 1 installation described its two V4-275R engines as of maximum 100 kW each, so the rating depends on the installation and the source.

Why does a submarine Stirling engine use helium?

Helium is the working gas sealed inside the engine and its heater, per Kockums.

It is inert and cannot burn, which matters in a closed pressure hull, and it transfers heat well through the heater and cooler tubes. Kockums names helium as the working gas without publishing the reasons for the choice.

How does a Stirling AIP submarine get rid of its exhaust underwater?

Kockums runs the combustion at an overpressure corresponding to a set diving depth.

The exhaust line ends in a non-return valve set to the maximum diving pressure and a disperser into the outgoing cooling-water flow, so the carbon dioxide, water and excess oxygen go overboard without an exhaust compressor (Kockums, 1996). Saab describes the exhaust as cooled and dissolved in water before release into the sea.

What fuel does a Stirling AIP submarine burn?

It burns ordinary low-sulphur diesel with liquid oxygen.

Saab states that the same fuel serves both the diesel generators and the Stirling engines, so the only new consumable the AIP plant adds is LOX.

Which was the first submarine with Stirling AIP?

HSwMS Näcken of the Swedish Navy.

Saab records that she was put in dry dock, cut in two, and fitted with a fully outfitted eight-metre AIP section, with the first installation in 1988; Kockums dated the complete installation to 1989. Saab’s company timeline files the event under 1987.

Which was the first submarine class designed with AIP from the outset?

The Swedish Gotland class (A19), according to Saab.

The three boats were contracted in the early 1990s, and the lead boat was delivered to the fleet in mid 1996 (Kockums, 1996).

How many Soryu-class submarines have Stirling engines?

Ten of the twelve. Saab states that the first ten Soryu-class boats used Stirling technology through a licence to Kawasaki Heavy Industries, and Kawasaki’s release for the tenth boat, Shoryu, lists four Kawasaki Kockums V4-275R Stirling engines.

The twelfth boat, Toryu, was delivered on 24 March 2021 with lithium-ion battery systems and no Stirling engines in its machinery list.

Did Japan remove Stirling engines from Oryu and Toryu?

No. The eleventh and twelfth Soryu-class boats were built without the Stirling plant.

Saab limits the Stirling installation to the first ten boats, and Kawasaki’s 24 March 2021 release for Toryu describes lithium-ion battery systems for increased underwater endurance and lists only two diesel engines and one electric propulsion motor.

How long can a Stirling AIP submarine stay submerged?

Saab describes the gain as extending submerged endurance from days to weeks.

Kockums put the AIP contribution at several hundred hours of low-speed running, more than four times the energy in the ordinary battery, plus about another hundred hours from a fully charged battery (1996). Saab gave the A26 design as able to stay underwater for up to 18 days at relatively slow speed on AIP (2015).

How fast can a submarine go on Stirling AIP alone?

Only at slow patrol speed. Kockums designed the add-on module to extend endurance at low patrol speeds, with the battery taking over for any high-power demand.

The engine count sets the ceiling: Kockums wrote that four units could support even a large submarine at slow speeds including the hotel load.

Is a Stirling AIP submarine as quiet as a fuel-cell submarine?

Both plants are designed for silent running, but they make noise in different ways.

A Stirling engine has moving pistons, so Kockums relied on a smooth sinusoidal pressure curve, careful balancing and a double elastic mounting. A fuel-cell stack has no reciprocating parts, though its pumps and auxiliaries still run. Navies do not publish comparative noise measurements.

How is liquid oxygen stored on a Stirling AIP submarine?

In two stainless-steel tanks with inner and outer shells separated by high-vacuum multilayer insulation, fitted inboard and resiliently connected to the hull for shock protection.

The tank pressure is held constant by evaporating LOX into the top of the tank, and oxygen is drawn from the bottom as liquid and gasified in an evaporator heated by the Stirling fresh-water cooling system (Kockums, 1996).

Where is the Stirling plant installed in a Gotland-class submarine?

In the compartment just aft of the pressure-tight bulkhead that divides the hull into two compartments.

The engine-generator modules sit on the upper level and the oxygen tanks on the lower level (Kockums, 1996).

Which navies operate Stirling AIP submarines?

Sweden and Japan. Saab states that all Swedish submarines carry Stirling engines, and the first ten Japanese Soryu-class boats carry four Kawasaki-built engines each.

Singapore’s two Archer-class boats are former Swedish Västergötland-class submarines to which an AIP system was added (MINDEF, 30 April 2013).

What is the current generation of the Kockums Stirling engine?

Saab calls the third generation Stirling Mk3, with increased efficiency and power density and a new control system and operator interface (Saab, February 2017).

HSwMS Gotland was relaunched after her mid-life upgrade on 20 June 2018 with Stirling AIP MkIII.

Does the A26 Blekinge class use Stirling AIP?

Yes. Saab’s 30 June 2015 contract release states that the A26 is equipped with the Kockums Stirling AIP system.

Saab’s 2015 design description gave the A26 as a 62 m boat of about 1,800 t surfaced that can stay underwater for up to 18 days at relatively slow speed on AIP.

When will the A26 submarines be delivered to Sweden?

The June 2015 contract scheduled deliveries from 2022 to 2024, and they slipped.

On 13 October 2025 Saab received an additional FMV order of about SEK 9.6 billion for the last production phase of the two Blekinge-class boats, with the vast majority of deliveries in the period 2026 to 2032.

Has Poland ordered the A26?

Yes. On 29 June 2026 Saab announced an order from the Polish State Treasury Armaments Agency for three A26-type submarines worth about SEK 47 billion, with final deliveries scheduled during 2038.

Under a separate Poland and Sweden agreement, Poland will operate HMS Södermanland as a gap filler.

What are the Siemens SINAVY fuel-cell modules?

SINAVY is the Siemens range of fuel-cell modules for underwater applications.

Siemens states the series was originally designed in close cooperation with the German Navy and HDW, names the earlier BZM34 and BZM120 modules, and gives its BZM evo module, announced on 22 August 2019, a nominal power of 40 kW, with future plants of 320 to 480 kW.

What is the Spanish BEST AIP system?

Navantia’s BEST AIP for the S-80 class runs proton-exchange membrane fuel cells on hydrogen produced on board, on demand, by reforming bioethanol, with liquid oxygen as the oxidizer.

Navantia completed testing of the system in a dedicated section of S-83 in September 2026 and states it had already recharged the batteries of S-81.

Is Stirling AIP the same as nuclear propulsion?

No. A Stirling plant burns diesel with stored oxygen and is limited by the oxygen it carries.

A nuclear reactor needs no oxidizer and can drive a submarine at high speed for as long as the crew and stores last. Kockums itself described the nuclear submarine as the ultimate underwater vehicle in sustained mobility and endurance (1996).

Can a submarine pass submerged through another state's territorial sea?

Not in innocent passage. Article 20 of UNCLOS requires submarines and other underwater vehicles in the territorial sea to navigate on the surface and show their flag.

Passage through straits used for international navigation and archipelagic sea lanes passage are separate regimes, governed by Parts III and IV. If a warship disregards the coastal State’s laws on passage and ignores a request to comply, Article 30 lets the coastal State require it to leave the territorial sea immediately.

Do SOLAS and MARPOL apply to AIP submarines?

No. SOLAS Regulation I/3(a)(i) excepts ships of war and troopships unless expressly provided otherwise, and MARPOL Article 3(3) excludes warships, naval auxiliaries and other State ships on government non-commercial service.

MARPOL still requires each Party to make such ships act consistently with the Convention so far as reasonable and practicable.

Why did Sweden choose Stirling over closed-cycle diesel and fuel cells?

Sweden had tried both. A closed-cycle diesel programme of the early 1960s, with oxygen carried as high-test peroxide, reached full-scale land testing, and a later fuel-cell programme reached an advanced land-based testing stage; both were stopped over technology and cost uncertainty.

Studies completed in the early 1980s then pointed to the Stirling engine for its efficiency, its use of fuel oil and LOX, and its prospects for low noise (Kockums, 1996).

How was Stirling AIP intended to be used on patrol?

Kockums described a submarine that enters its patrol area with a full battery and runs on AIP, so the battery is not discharged.

When a target needs power flexibility, the AIP plant is shut down and the battery takes over, and the boat returns to AIP afterwards until the oxygen is consumed (Kockums, 1996).

Sources

  1. Pelle Stenberg (Kockums AB), "AIP. The Swedish Way", The Submarine Review, Naval Submarine League, October 1996 archive.navalsubleague.org
  2. H. Nilsson, "Submarine power systems using the V4-275R Stirling engine", Proceedings of the IMechE Part A, vol. 202, 1988 (TRID record) trid.trb.org
  3. Saab. "The secret to the world's most silent submarine", March 2015 saab.com
  4. Saab. "May we request absolute silence", Stirling Mk3, February 2017 saab.com
  5. Saab press release. HSwMS Gotland relaunched after mid-life upgrade, 20 June 2018 saab.com
  6. Saab press release. HMS Halland launched after mid-life upgrade, 14 February 2025 saab.com
  7. Saab press release. contracts for A26 submarines and Gotland-class mid-life upgrade, 30 June 2015 saab.com
  8. Saab Australia. "Super stealthy Saab submarines", A26 design, 2015 saab.com
  9. Saab press release. additional order relating to the Swedish A26 submarines, 13 October 2025 saab.com
  10. Saab press release. order for three submarines for Poland, 29 June 2026 saab.com
  11. Saab. "With knowledge comes power", Kawasaki licence and Soryu class, November 2023 saab.com
  12. Saab. Submarinos brochure, Exponaval 2022 (Spanish) saab.com
  13. Saab. company history timeline saab.com
  14. Kawasaki Heavy Industries. Submarine Shoryu delivered, 18 March 2019 global.kawasaki.com
  15. Kawasaki Heavy Industries. Submarine Toryu delivered, 24 March 2021 global.kawasaki.com
  16. MINDEF Singapore. commissioning of RSS Swordsman, 30 April 2013 mindef.gov.sg
  17. MINDEF Singapore fact sheet. Invincible-class submarines, 18 February 2019 mindef.gov.sg
  18. Siemens press release. BZM evo fuel-cell series for underwater applications, 22 August 2019 press.siemens.com
  19. Navantia. BEST AIP product page navantia.es
  20. Navantia press release. testing of the AIP system for S-83 completed, September 2026 navantia.es
  21. United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, Part II. Territorial Sea and Contiguous Zone (UN DOALOS) un.org
  22. UN Treaty Collection, Chapter XXI-6. United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, status treaties.un.org