Trim and List: Drafts, Weight Shift, Heel and Loll
Trim is the fore-and-aft draft difference; list is a steady sideways tilt. Covers drafts, weight shift, list formulas, list versus loll, limits and ballast.
Contents18 sections
Trim is the difference between a ship’s aft and forward drafts, and list is a steady tilt to one side. Both follow from where the weight is. A ship trims about its center of flotation and lists about its centerline. The two quantities are calculated with different hydrostatic data: TPC and MCTC for trim, GM for list.
SOLAS regulation II-1/2.13, as revised by resolution MSC.216(82) in force from 1 January 2009, defines trim. The 2008 IS Code, resolution MSC.267(85), sets the heel limits for named causes. MARPOL Annex I Regulation 18.2 sizes the segregated ballast of tankers to reach a set draft and trim. The casualty reports of the UK Marine Accident Investigation Branch record what happens when the loading data is wrong.
Every worked number uses one example ship. The example ship is 150 m between perpendiculars, 24 m wide and 12 m deep, at 8.0 m draft and 22,140 t displacement. The ship has TPC 31.37 t/cm, MCTC 265.7 t m/cm and its center of flotation 3 m aft of midships.
The midship section of the example ship is wall-sided, with KM 10.0 m, KG 9.0 m and GM 1.0 m. These are stated example values, not the data of a real ship.
Trim, list, heel and loll defined
Trim, list, heel and loll name four different inclinations, and the cause decides which one a ship has. Trim is fore and aft. List, heel and loll are transverse. A practitioner who names the wrong one applies the wrong correction.
Trim and its sign convention
SOLAS II-1/2.13 states: “Trim is the difference between the draught forward and the draught aft, where the draughts are measured at the forward and aft terminals respectively, disregarding any rake of keel.” The regulation sets no sign. This article takes trim as the aft draft less the forward draft, so trim by the stern is positive. The stability booklet and the loading computer of each ship state their own.
A ship trims by the stern when the aft draft is greater, and by the head when the forward draft is greater. Figure 1 shows a ship trimmed 0.80 m by the stern.
Trim and mean draft
where
| \(t\) | trim, positive by the stern | m |
| \(d_{\mathrm{A}}\) | draft at the after perpendicular | m |
| \(d_{\mathrm{F}}\) | draft at the forward perpendicular | m |
| \(d_{\mathrm{M}}\) | mean draft, the draft at midships for a straight keel | m |
The angle of trim is small. A trim of 0.80 m over 150 m is an angle of 0.31 degrees. For that reason trim is stated as a length, and the angle is used only inside the geometry.
List, heel and loll
Heel is the general word for any transverse inclination. The 2008 IS Code uses “angle of heel” for the steady-wind criterion in Part A 2.3 and for the turning criterion in Part A 3.1.2. A ship heels under wind, in a turn or as it rolls, and returns upright when the cause stops.
List is a heel that the ship holds because of its own loading. Its cause is a center of gravity G off the centerline, in a ship with positive metacentric height. The ship rests at one angle, to the side of the weight.
Loll is the angle at which a ship with negative GM comes to rest. G is on the centerline, the ship is unstable upright, and it rests at the same angle to either side. The angle of loll article covers the mechanism and the estimate.
Figure 2 compares the four inclinations. The table gives the same comparison in words.
| Term | Direction | Cause | Where the ship rests | Correction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trim | Fore and aft | G fore or aft of B, so that LCG is not over LCB | Stated as a length, by the stern or by the head | Move weight fore or aft, or change the ballast |
| Heel | Transverse | An outside force: wind, a turn, or waves | Returns upright when the force stops | None for the heel itself |
| List | Transverse | G off the centerline, with positive GM | At one angle, to the side of the weight | Move weight toward the high side |
| Loll | Transverse | Negative GM, with G on the centerline | At the same angle to either side, and can flop across | Lower G |
Even keel
A ship is on an even keel when its forward and aft drafts are equal and its trim is zero. Hydrostatic tables are calculated for even keel unless the booklet states otherwise. A ship with trim reads its displacement from those tables at the true mean draft, or from trim-corrected tables where the booklet carries them.
Drafts at the marks, the perpendiculars and the center of flotation
A draft read at the marks is corrected to the perpendiculars and then to the center of flotation before it gives a displacement. Each step has its own error. The draft survey trim corrections article carries the survey arithmetic, and the stability calculation uses the same geometry.
Draft marks
SOLAS II-1/5.6 states: “Every ship shall have scales of draughts marked clearly at the bow and stern.” Where the marks are hard to read, the same regulation requires “a reliable draught indicating system by which the bow and stern draughts can be determined”. Where the draft marks are not at the perpendiculars, they follow the shape of the stem and stern. Each reading is then corrected along the keel line to the perpendicular.
The correction depends on the trim and on the distance of the mark from the perpendicular. The ship’s draft mark correction table gives it. A draft survey applies the same corrections under UN/ECE ECE/ENERGY/19.
Perpendiculars and length
The 1988 Load Line Protocol, Annex B, Regulation 3(2), as amended by MSC.143(77), defines the perpendiculars. They are “at the forward and after ends of the length (L)”. The forward perpendicular is at the foreside of the stem on the waterline on which L is measured.
L is 96 per cent of the total length on a waterline at 85 per cent of the least moulded depth. Where it is greater, L is the length on that waterline from the foreside of the stem to the axis of the rudder stock.
That L is not always the length between perpendiculars in the stability booklet. SOLAS II-1 also measures trim at the “terminals”, the ends of the subdivision length Ls. A trim figure is therefore only comparable with a limit when both use the same length.
True mean draft
The mean of the forward and aft drafts is the draft at midships, if the keel is straight. The ship does not pivot about midships. It pivots about the center of flotation, the centroid of the waterplane area. The displacement belongs to the draft at that point, the true mean draft.
True mean draft at the center of flotation
where
| \(d_{\mathrm{LCF}}\) | true mean draft, the draft at the center of flotation | m |
| \(d_{\mathrm{M}}\) | mean of the drafts at the perpendiculars | m |
| \(t\) | trim, positive by the stern | m |
| \(l\) | distance of the center of flotation from midships, positive forward | m |
| \(L_{\mathrm{BP}}\) | length between perpendiculars | m |
For the example ship, the forward draft is 7.60 m and the aft draft is 8.40 m. The trim is 0.80 m by the stern and the mean draft is 8.00 m. The center of flotation is 3 m aft of midships, so l is minus 3 m. The true mean draft is 8.00 + 0.80 × 3 / 150 = 8.016 m.
The difference is 1.6 cm. At a TPC of 31.37 t/cm, that is about 50 t of displacement. With trim by the stern and the center of flotation aft of midships, the true mean draft exceeds the simple mean. When either of the two reverses, it is less.
Hull deflection: hogging and sagging
A hull in still water bends under the distribution of its weight and buoyancy. Hogging and sagging are the two directions of that bend, and Figure 3 shows both. In a hogged hull the ends drop relative to midships, so the midships draft is less than the mean of the end drafts. In a sagged hull the midships draft is greater.
The mean of the end drafts alone then misstates the displacement. A draft survey reads the midships marks on both sides and uses the mean of means, (F + A + 6M) / 8, under ECE/ENERGY/19. The lightweight and deadweight article gives that formula as a rule card. The bending itself is covered in the section on trim and longitudinal bending.
Bodily sinkage and TPC
A weight added directly above the center of flotation makes the ship sink parallel to its waterline, by the weight divided by TPC. That parallel change is bodily sinkage. A weight removed there gives a bodily rise of the same size.
Bodily sinkage
where
| \(s\) | bodily sinkage, or rise for a weight removed | cm |
| \(w\) | weight added at the center of flotation | t |
| \(\mathit{TPC}\) | tonnes per centimeter immersion at the current draft | t/cm |
| \(A_{\mathrm{W}}\) | waterplane area | m² |
| \(\rho\) | density of the water the ship floats in | t/m³ |
Calculate the bodily sinkage from a weight added (w / TPC) on ShipCalculators.com →
Tonnes per centimeter immersion, TPC, comes from the waterplane area. TPC changes with draft, because the waterplane widens as the ship sinks into a fuller section. TPC is also in direct proportion to the water density, so it is smaller in fresh water. The example ship has a waterplane area of 3,060 m² and TPC 31.37 t/cm in sea water of 1.025 t/m³.
The relation holds for weights small enough that TPC does not change over the sinkage. For a large cargo, take TPC at the mean of the old and new drafts.
A better method reads the new draft from the displacement column of the hydrostatic tables. A change from sea water to fresh water changes the draft without any change of weight. The freeboard and reserve buoyancy article covers the fresh water allowance that the load line marks use.
Change of trim
A weight moved fore and aft, or added away from the center of flotation, changes the trim by the trimming moment divided by MCTC. The ship turns about the center of flotation. One end goes down and the other comes up.
MCTC, the moment to change trim one centimeter, is the trimming moment that changes the trim by 1 cm. MCTC equals the displacement times the longitudinal metacentric height, divided by 100 times the length. The example ship has MCTC 265.7 t m/cm at its 8.0 m draft.
Change of trim
where
| \(\delta t\) | change of trim | cm |
| \(w\,d\) | trimming moment: weight times its fore-and-aft distance moved, or its distance from the center of flotation when added | t m |
| \(\mathit{MCTC}\) | moment to change trim one centimeter | t m/cm |
| \(\Delta\) | displacement | t |
| \(\mathit{GM}_{\mathrm{L}}\) | longitudinal metacentric height | m |
Calculate the change of trim from a weight moved (w d / MCT1cm) on ShipCalculators.com →
Weight moved fore and aft
A weight w moved a distance d along the ship gives a trimming moment w d. The displacement does not change, so there is no sinkage. The change of trim is w d / MCTC, toward the end to which the weight moves.
Moving 100 t of fuel 40 m aft in the example ship gives 4,000 t m. The change of trim is 4,000 / 265.7 = 15.1 cm by the stern.
Weight added or removed away from the center of flotation
A weight added at a distance d from the center of flotation does two things at once. Treat it in two steps:
- Add the weight at the center of flotation. The ship sinks bodily by w / TPC.
- Move the weight from the center of flotation to its real position. The ship trims by w d / MCTC.
The change of trim is then shared between the ends. Each end changes in proportion to its distance from the center of flotation.
Change of draft at each perpendicular
where
| \(\delta t\) | change of trim | cm |
| \(l_{\mathrm{A}}\) | distance of the center of flotation from the after perpendicular | m |
| \(l_{\mathrm{F}}\) | distance of the center of flotation from the forward perpendicular | m |
| \(\delta d_{\mathrm{A}}, \delta d_{\mathrm{F}}\) | change of draft aft and forward; the two act in opposite directions | cm |
| \(L_{\mathrm{BP}}\) | length between perpendiculars, equal to l_A + l_F | m |
Worked example: 200 t loaded forward
Figure 4 shows 200 t loaded 50 m forward of the center of flotation of the example ship. The center of flotation is 72 m from the after perpendicular and 78 m from the forward perpendicular.
- Bodily sinkage: 200 / 31.37 = 6.38 cm at both ends.
- Change of trim: 200 × 50 / 265.7 = 37.64 cm by the head.
- Forward draft: plus 37.64 × 78 / 150 = 19.57 cm, plus 6.38 cm, total plus 25.9 cm.
- Aft draft: minus 37.64 × 72 / 150 = 18.07 cm, plus 6.38 cm, total minus 11.7 cm.
The aft draft decreases although weight was added. For that reason a loading sequence is planned on the drafts at both ends, not on the mean draft. A weight added aft of the center of flotation reverses the signs.
Trim from the loading condition
The hydrostatic-table method does not add weights one at a time. It sums the weights and their moments and finds the longitudinal center of gravity, LCG. It then compares LCG with the longitudinal center of buoyancy, LCB, at even keel for that displacement. The trimming moment is the displacement times the distance between them, and the trim is that moment divided by MCTC.
The method is the same physics as the step method. It is more accurate for large changes, because it reads LCB and MCTC at the final displacement. An approved stability instrument can instead solve the floating position directly from the hull geometry. The marine stability booklet and loading computer article covers the instrument.
List from a transverse shift of weight
A weight moved across the ship moves the center of gravity off the centerline, and the ship lists until G is again below the metacenter. At small angles the list follows tan θ = w d / (Δ GM).
The center of gravity moves parallel to the shift of the weight. The distance it moves, GG1, is the weight times the distance moved, divided by the displacement. The ship heels until the new center of buoyancy is directly below G1. At small angles the metacenter M stays on the centerline, so G1 is directly below M and tan θ = GG1 / GM.
List from a transverse shift of weight
where
| \(\theta\) | angle of list | ° |
| \(d\) | transverse distance the weight moves | m |
| \(\mathit{GM}\) | metacentric height after the free surface correction | m |
| \(w\) | weight moved | t |
| \(\Delta\) | displacement | t |
| \(\mathit{GG}_{1}\) | transverse shift of the center of gravity | m |
Calculate the list from a transverse weight shift on ShipCalculators.com →
Worked example: 400 t moved 6 m to starboard
Figure 5 shows 400 t moved 6 m to starboard in the example ship.
- Heeling moment: 400 × 6 = 2,400 t m.
- Shift of G: 2,400 / 22,140 = 0.108 m.
- List: tan θ = 0.108 / 1.0, so θ = 6.19 degrees to starboard.
The GZ curve gives the same answer from the other side. The off-center G reduces the righting lever by GG1 cos θ, and the list is the angle at which the reduced lever is zero.
Weight added off the centerline
A weight loaded off the centerline changes the displacement, KG and GM as well as the transverse moment. Treat it as a weight loaded on the centerline and then moved out.
List from a weight added off the centerline
where
| \(\theta\) | angle of list | ° |
| \(y\) | transverse distance of the added weight from the centerline | m |
| \(\mathit{GM}_{1}\) | metacentric height after the addition, KM at the new draft less KG1, corrected for free surface | m |
| \(\mathit{KG}_{1}\) | height of the new center of gravity above the keel | m |
| \(h\) | height of the added weight above the keel | m |
| \(w\) | weight added | t |
| \(\Delta\) | displacement before the addition | t |
Calculate the list from a weight added off the centerline on ShipCalculators.com →
For the example ship, 150 t is loaded into a full double bottom tank, 2 m above the keel and 8 m to port. The displacement becomes 22,290 t and KG becomes 8.953 m.
With KM taken as unchanged over the 4.8 cm of sinkage, GM becomes 1.047 m. The list is tan θ = 150 × 8 / (22,290 × 1.047), so θ = 2.94 degrees to port.
The weight lowered G and so increased GM. A weight loaded high does the opposite, and the same transverse moment then gives a larger list.
Correcting a list with ballast
A list is corrected by an equal moment in the opposite direction. The list of the worked example comes from 2,400 t m to starboard. Wing tanks whose centers are 20 m apart need 120 t transferred from starboard to port to cancel it.
The tanks are slack during the transfer. The free surface effect reduces GM, so the list changes during the correction by more than the moment alone predicts. A ship with an anti-heeling system does the same thing automatically during cargo operations, with tanks and pumps arranged for it.
Free surface and list
The list formula uses GM corrected for free surface effect. The 2008 IS Code requires that correction in all loading conditions (Part A 2.1.2), with the method in Part B 3.1. Halving GM doubles tan θ at small angles.
In the example ship, a fall of GM to 0.5 m raises the small-angle list from 2,400 t m to 12.2 degrees. The wall-sided value at GM 0.5 m is 10.3 degrees. A list that grows while no weight moves can come from a tank that becomes slack, or from water entering the ship.
When the small-angle formula fails: the wall-sided formula
The small-angle formula overstates the list once the metacenter starts to rise with heel, and the error grows as GM falls. The wall-sided formula corrects that for a section with vertical sides at the waterline.
In a wall-sided section, the righting lever is GZ = sin θ (GM + ½ BM tan² θ). The second term is the rise of the metacenter. It is zero upright and grows with the square of tan θ. The equilibrium list solves the same expression with GZ replaced by the shift of G.
Wall-sided formula
where
| \(\mathit{GZ}\) | righting lever | m |
| \(\mathit{GM}\) | initial metacentric height, corrected for free surface | m |
| \(\mathit{BM}\) | transverse metacentric radius at the upright waterline | m |
| \(\theta\) | angle of heel; the equilibrium list solves the second equation | ° |
| \(w\,d / \Delta\) | transverse shift of G, GG1 | m |
Calculate the wall-sided righting lever on ShipCalculators.com →
Figure 6 plots both formulas for the example ship at GM 0.3 m.
At GM 1.0 m and 2,400 t m, the small-angle formula gives 6.19 degrees and the wall-sided formula 5.99 degrees. At GM 0.3 m and the same moment, they give 19.9 degrees and 13.2 degrees. The small-angle value then puts the deck edge under water, at 18.4 degrees in the example, where the wall-sided value does not.
The wall-sided formula is exact only while the section stays wall-sided at the waterline. It fails once the deck edge immerses or the bilge emerges. Beyond that angle the list comes from the cross curves of stability and the ship’s own GZ curve.
List or loll: telling them apart
A list has a cause that a weight explains; a loll has none, because the ship has lost positive GM. The two look the same on the inclinometer. Figure 7 shows why the two respond differently.
With positive GM and G off the centerline, the GZ curve is shifted down by GG1 cos θ. It crosses zero once, at the list angle, on the side of the weight. With negative GM and G on the centerline, the curve is negative close to upright and crosses zero at the same angle on both sides. The ship rests at either angle and can flop from one side to the other.
The diagnosis comes from the loading record, not from the angle. A list with a weight off the centerline that accounts for it is a list. A list with no transverse change of weight to explain it points to a loss of GM. Causes include:
- fuel or water used from tanks low in the ship
- a tank that has become slack
- deck cargo that has taken up water.
The corrections are opposite in effect. A list is corrected by moving weight toward the high side. A loll is corrected by lowering G, and weight moved to the high side of a lolling ship makes it flop to the other side. The angle of loll article gives the correction procedure.
Figure 8 shows this effect on the example section at GM minus 0.2 m. The ship first lolls 14.5 degrees to port. Weight moved to starboard with a heeling moment of 300 t m reduces the port angle to 12.0 degrees. Above about 440 t m the port resting angle no longer exists. The ship then flops to about 16.6 degrees to starboard.
Heel limits in the IMO instruments
The IMO instruments limit heel for named causes, not a general list for an intact ship in service. Figure 9 compares the limits.
Steady wind
The weather criterion is in the 2008 IS Code, Part A 2.3.1.2. The angle of heel under the action of steady wind “should not exceed 16° or 80% of the angle of deck edge immersion, whichever is less”. For the example ship, 80 per cent of 18.4 degrees is 14.7 degrees, so the 80 per cent limb governs.
The weather criterion section of the intact stability article covers the wind lever, the roll-back angle and the area balance. Ships with timber deck cargo can be assessed under the alternative criteria of Part A 3.3.2, where the Administration is satisfied with them. Under that alternative, Part A 3.3.2.4 keeps the 16 degree limit and lets the 80 per cent limb be ignored.
Passenger crowding and turning
Part A 3.1 of the Code applies to passenger ships. Part A 3.1.1 limits the angle of heel from passenger crowding to one side to 10 degrees. The crowding criterion assumes 75 kg for each passenger and states that a density above four persons per square meter is not necessary.
Part A 3.1.2 limits the angle of heel due to turning to 10 degrees. The card below gives its heeling moment.
Heeling moment due to turning
where
| \(M_{\mathrm{R}}\) | heeling moment due to turning | kN m |
| \(V_{0}\) | service speed | m/s |
| \(\mathit{KG}\) | height of the center of gravity above the baseline | m |
| \(L_{\mathrm{WL}}\) | length of the ship at the waterline | m |
| \(\Delta\) | displacement | t |
| \(d\) | mean draft | m |
As arithmetic only, the example ship at 8 m/s with a waterline length of 153 m gives M_R = 9,261 kN m. Divided by g Δ GM, that is a heel of 2.44 degrees at GM 1.0 m. The criterion itself applies to passenger ships.
The passenger crowding and turning heel criteria article covers both, and the heeling lever article covers how the levers are drawn on the GZ curve.
Grain shift
The International Grain Code, resolution MSC.23(59), section A 7.1, limits the angle of heel from the assumed shift of grain to 12 degrees. For ships built on or after 1 January 1994, the limit is 12 degrees or the deck-edge immersion angle, if less. The same section requires a residual area of at least 0.075 meter radians. Section A 7.1 also requires an initial GM of at least 0.30 m after the free surface correction.
Inclining test
The inclining test needs a ship close to upright. The 2008 IS Code, Part B 8.2.2.7, accepts up to one-half degree of list with the inclining weights in their initial position.
SOLAS II-1/5.1 requires every passenger ship regardless of size, and every cargo ship of 24 m in length and upwards, to be inclined on completion. The inclining experiment and lightweight survey article covers the method.
Operating limits outside the stability instruments
A crane or a cargo system has its own limits of heel and trim, set by its maker on its datasheet. These are equipment limits, not stability criteria. The officer planning a cargo operation checks both: the stability criteria in the booklet and the equipment limits on the datasheets.
Ballast draft and trim of tankers: MARPOL Annex I Regulation 18
MARPOL Annex I Regulation 18.2 sizes the segregated ballast tanks of a tanker for a minimum draft, a maximum stern trim and full propeller immersion.
Regulation 18.1 applies to crude oil tankers of 20,000 tonnes deadweight and above and product carriers of 30,000 tonnes deadweight and above. In both cases the ship is one delivered after 1 June 1982, as Regulation 1.28.4 defines.
Regulation 18.2 sets the capacity of the segregated ballast tanks. The capacity has to be enough for the drafts and trim to meet three conditions in any ballast condition, including lightweight plus segregated ballast only:
- A moulded draft amidships of at least 2.0 + 0.02L meters, without allowance for hull deformation.
- Drafts at the perpendiculars that correspond to that draft with a trim by the stern of not more than 0.015L.
- In any case, an aft draft that fully immerses the propeller or propellers.
Draft and trim the segregated ballast must give
where
| \(d_{\mathrm{m}}\) | moulded draft amidships, without allowance for hull deformation | m |
| \(t\) | trim by the stern | m |
| \(L\) | length as defined in MARPOL Annex I, Reg.1 | m |
Figure 10 shows the limits for a tanker with L 150 m.
For L 150 m, the segregated ballast has to give at least 5.0 m amidships with not more than 2.25 m trim by the stern. At those two limits the forward draft is 3.88 m and the aft draft 6.13 m.
Regulation 18.3 allows ballast in cargo tanks only in the severe weather and exceptional cases it names. In severe weather the master decides whether the safety of the ship needs it. The MARPOL Annex I Regulation 18 article covers the segregated ballast tank rules in full.
For other ships, SOLAS II-1 and the 2008 IS Code set no minimum forward draft and no propeller immersion. The 2008 IS Code gives one related recommendation, in Part B 5.3.2: “In severe weather, the speed of the ship should be reduced if propeller emergence, shipping of water on deck or heavy slamming occurs”. The minimum ballast drafts for bottom slamming come from class rules and the ship’s own loading manual.
Trim in the stability booklet and the loading computer
The stability booklet and the loading computer give the trim of every loading condition and check it against the ship’s limits. SOLAS II-1/5-1 and the 2008 IS Code decide what the booklet shows.
SOLAS II-1/5-1: the trim range
SOLAS II-1/5-1.3 states: “The stability information shall show the influence of various trims in cases where the operational trim range exceeds +/- 0.5% of Ls.” For a subdivision length of 150 m, that range is 0.75 m either side of even keel. Regulation 5-1.1 requires the information to be satisfactory to the Administration.
IS Code A 2.1.7 and free trim
The 2008 IS Code, Part A 2.1.7, covers the minimum GM or maximum KG limiting curves. The curves “shall extend over the full range of operational trims, unless the Administration agrees that trim effects are not significant”. A GM limit curve drawn at even keel can be wrong for a ship that sails with a large trim.
Part B 3.5.1 recommends that the hydrostatic and stability curves take into account the change in trim due to heel, a free trim calculation. The booklet list of Part B includes cross curves of stability calculated on a free-trimming basis.
Stability booklet and loading manual
The stability booklet and the loading manual are two documents. The 2008 IS Code, Part A 2.1.6, requires a stability booklet approved by the Administration. Load Line Regulation 10(1) covers loading information for the master of every new ship. The information lets the ship be loaded and ballasted without unacceptable stresses in its structure, unless the Administration considers it unnecessary.
IACS UR S1, Rev.7 of May 2010, sets the class requirements for loading conditions, loading manuals and loading instruments.
Both documents use the same drafts and trim. The strength check of the loading instrument compares the still-water bending moments and shear forces with permissible values. The permissible values are in the approved loading manual, and IACS UR S11 covers longitudinal strength.
Where a stability instrument is used to determine compliance with the Code, Part A 2.1.6 requires it to be approved by the Administration. Part B chapter 4 gives the guidance.
Passenger ships: trim before departure
SOLAS II-1/20.1 requires the master of a passenger ship to determine the ship’s trim and stability before departure. The regulation states that the stability is always determined by calculation. The Administration can accept an electronic loading and stability computer, or equivalent means, for the purpose.
Trim with squat, under-keel clearance and longitudinal bending
Trim interacts with squat, under-keel clearance and hull girder bending, and each has its own article. The detail of each is in the linked article.
Squat is the sinkage and change of trim of a ship moving in shallow water. Squat changes the static trim that the drafts show. The under-keel clearance allowance in the passage plan starts from the deepest point of the ship. A trim by the stern puts that point at the after end.
Trim and hull girder bending are separate checks on one loading condition. A loading sequence that keeps the trim within limits can still exceed the still-water bending moment, and the loading manual checks both at each step. The hull strength and longitudinal bending article covers the bending side.
Trim optimisation uses the dependence of hull resistance on trim to find the trim of lowest fuel consumption for a speed and draft. That optimum is specific to the hull, and the article on it covers the method and its evidence.
Where trim and list come from, by ship type
Each ship type has its own sources of trim and list, set by how it loads. The mechanics are the same in every case; the loading pattern differs.
| Ship type | Main source of trim | Main source of list |
|---|---|---|
| Bulk carrier | Sequence of holds loaded and ballast discharged | Uneven trimming of cargo in a hold, cargo shift |
| Container ship | Bay-by-bay stowage and ballast | Uneven container weights across a bay |
| Oil tanker | Sequence of tanks loaded or discharged | Slack cargo tanks, uneven wing tanks |
| Ro-ro ship | Vehicle stowage on decks | Vehicle and trailer weights to one side, water on the vehicle deck |
| General cargo ship | Hatch loading sequence | Heavy lifts with ship’s own cranes |
A bulk carrier loading plan is written as a sequence of drafts, trims and bending moments for each pour. A heavy lift with the ship’s own gear gives a list that increases as the load moves outboard. The lifting operations stability article covers that case. On a ro-ro ship, water on the vehicle deck gives a list with a free surface across the whole breadth.
Trimming in the IMSBC Code
In the IMSBC Code, trimming means levelling bulk cargo inside a hold, not the longitudinal trim of the ship. The same word has two meanings, and a voyage instruction can use both.
The IMSBC Code, resolution MSC.268(85), paragraph 1.7.28, defines trimming as “any levelling of a cargo within a cargo space, either partial or total”. Section 5.1.1 requires cargoes to be trimmed reasonably level as necessary, to minimize the risk of cargo shift and of air entering the cargo. Where there is any concern about stability, 5.1.3 allows the master to require a cargo to be trimmed level.
Uneven cargo in a hold moves the center of gravity off the centerline and gives a list. The IMSBC Section 5 trimming provisions article covers the requirement. A self-trimming bulk carrier is shaped so that the cargo levels itself.
Casualty lessons on list and trim
The investigation reports on Hoegh Osaka and Riverdance both found that the loading data used for stability was wrong. Both ships listed heavily after a turn. Both reports are from the UK Marine Accident Investigation Branch.
Hoegh Osaka, 3 January 2015
MAIB Report 6/2016 covers the pure car and truck carrier Hoegh Osaka. At 2109 on 3 January 2015, the ship was rounding West Bramble buoy in The Solent. It then “developed a significant starboard list causing some cargo shift and consequent flooding”. With the list above 40 degrees, the ship lost steerage and propulsion and drifted onto Bramble Bank, grounding at 2115.
The salvors calculated the list as 52 degrees on 4 January.
The chief officer had advised the master that the departure GM was 1.46 m. The MAIB could not determine the actual GM on departure. The MAIB estimated condition gave GM 1.29 m “against a minimum GM requirement of 1.34m”.
The report stated that the real situation was worse, because of the unverified ballast and cargo data. The report found the loading computer valid.
The conclusions of MAIB 6/2016, section 3.1, include these findings:
- The ship “had inadequate residual stability to survive the Bramble Bank turn at 12kt”.
- The bow trim “would have been detrimental to manoeuvring, and probably contributed to the high rate of turn”.
- The actual cargo weight and stowage “were significantly different to the final cargo tally supplied to the ship”.
- The chief officer “did not allow for cargo unit VCGs when calculating the stability condition”.
- The ballast tank quantities were estimated and “differed significantly from actual tank levels”.
Section 2.4.1 states that the heeling moment of the turn is proportional to the square of the speed. At 12 knots it is 44 per cent greater than at 10 knots.
Riverdance, 31 January 2008
MAIB Report 18/2009 covers the ro-ro ferry Riverdance, which grounded at Shell Flats, Cleveleys, on 31 January 2008. In section 2.5.3 the report calculated that the GM “could be reduced to 0.10 m or even less” during the passage of the waves.
In section 2.5.6 the report found that trailers or their cargo “broke loose or shifted bodily to port”. The likely result was a residual list of about 10 degrees to port. The master then made a rapid turn to starboard, and angles of up to 50 degrees to port were reported.
Conclusion 3.1.2 states that the only trailer weight information was the driver’s declaration. Because of the inaccurate cargo information, “accurate stability calculations could not be conducted”. A list or a GM calculated from wrong weights carries the error of those weights.
Estonia, 28 September 1994
The ro-ro passenger ship Estonia sank in the Baltic on 28 September 1994, with 852 dead and 137 survivors. The Joint Accident Investigation Commission final report of December 1997 found that the bow visor was lost and that water entered the vehicle deck. The water on the open vehicle deck increased the list, and the ship capsized. The Stockholm Agreement, in force from 1 April 1997, added regional damage stability requirements for ro-ro passenger ships with water on deck.
Limitations
The formulas in this article are first-order hydrostatics, and they apply only inside their stated ranges.
- TPC and MCTC change with draft and trim. The step method is accurate for weights small compared with the displacement. For large changes, use LCB, MCTC and KM at the final displacement, as the loading computer does.
- The list formula tan θ = w d / (Δ GM) is valid only at small angles. The wall-sided formula is valid only until the deck edge immerses or the bilge emerges. Beyond those angles, use the GZ curve from the approved cross curves.
- The example ship has stated hydrostatic values. They do not come from one hull form, and none of its numbers applies to a real ship.
- The heel limits quoted are from MSC.267(85) and the Grain Code. Amendments MSC.319(89) and MSC.443(99) do not change Part A 2.1.6, 2.1.7, 2.3.1.2 or 3.1. The approved stability booklet of the ship governs for that ship.
- The sign of trim is a convention. A loading computer that uses trim by the head as positive gives the same numbers with the opposite sign.
- The casualty summaries quote the two MAIB reports and summarize the JAIC report. They do not add findings to them.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the difference between trim and list?
Trim is the difference between the drafts at the after and forward ends of a ship, so it measures the fore-and-aft inclination.
List is a steady inclination to one side. Trim comes from the fore-and-aft position of weight relative to the center of buoyancy, and list from a center of gravity off the centerline. A ship can have both at the same time.
What is the difference between list and heel?
Heel is any transverse inclination of a ship, and list is a heel that the ship holds because of its own loading.
A ship heels under wind, in a turn or as it rolls, and returns upright when the cause stops. A ship lists because its center of gravity is off the centerline, and it stays listed until the weight is moved. The 2008 IS Code uses ‘angle of heel’ for the wind and turning criteria.
What is the difference between a list and an angle of loll?
A list comes from a center of gravity off the centerline in a ship with positive GM; a loll comes from negative GM with the center of gravity on the centerline.
A listed ship rests at one angle to one side. A lolling ship is unstable upright and rests at the same angle to either side, so it can flop over from one side to the other. The correction is different: a list is corrected by moving weight across, a loll by lowering the center of gravity.
What does trim by the stern mean?
Trim by the stern means the aft draft is greater than the forward draft.
With trim taken as aft draft less forward draft, trim by the stern is positive. SOLAS II-1/2.13 defines trim as the difference between the forward and aft drafts but sets no sign, so the sign is a convention that the stability booklet and the loading computer state.
What does trim by the head mean?
Trim by the head means the forward draft is greater than the aft draft.
A ship goes down by the head when weight is loaded forward of the center of flotation or removed aft of it. Trim by the head reduces the immersion of the propeller and rudder; MAIB Report 6/2016 found that the 0.6 m bow trim of Hoegh Osaka probably contributed to its high rate of turn.
What is an even keel?
A ship is on an even keel when its forward and aft drafts are equal, so its trim is zero.
Hydrostatic tables are calculated for even keel unless the booklet gives trim-corrected tables. Even keel is not always the best service condition, because the trim of lowest fuel consumption depends on the hull, draft and speed.
Is trim measured in meters or in degrees?
Trim is stated as a length, in meters or centimeters, as the difference between the two drafts.
The angle of trim is that difference divided by the length, and it is small: 0.80 m over 150 m is 0.31 degrees. SOLAS II-1/5-1.3 states its trim threshold as a percentage of the subdivision length Ls, 0.5 per cent.
How do you calculate trim from the forward and aft drafts?
Subtract the forward draft from the aft draft, after both are corrected from the draft marks to the perpendiculars.
A ship at 7.60 m forward and 8.40 m aft trims 0.80 m by the stern. The mean of the two drafts is the draft at midships if the keel is straight.
What is the true mean draft?
The true mean draft is the draft at the center of flotation, the point about which the ship trims.
It differs from the mean of the end drafts whenever the ship has trim and the center of flotation is not at midships. It is d_LCF = d_M - t l / L_BP, with t positive by the stern and l positive forward of midships. The displacement belongs to that draft, not to the simple mean.
Why is the true mean draft not the average of the forward and aft drafts?
The average is the draft at midships, and the ship pivots about the center of flotation, which is forward or aft of midships unless the waterplane is symmetric fore and aft.
For a ship trimmed 0.80 m by the stern with the center of flotation 3 m aft of midships on 150 m, the true mean draft is 8.016 m against a simple mean of 8.00 m. At a TPC of 31.37 t/cm the 1.6 cm difference is about 50 t of displacement.
What is the center of flotation?
The center of flotation is the centroid of the waterplane area.
A small weight added directly above it makes the ship sink bodily without a change of trim, and a ship that trims turns about a transverse axis through it. Its distance from midships, LCF, is read from the hydrostatic tables at the current draft.
How is TPC defined?
TPC, tonnes per centimeter immersion, is the weight that changes the mean draft by one centimeter: TPC = A_W ρ / 100, with the waterplane area in square meters and the water density in tonnes per cubic meter.
TPC changes with draft because the waterplane area changes, and in direct proportion to the water density. The hydrostatic tables give it for a stated sea water density, such as 1.025 t/m3.
What is the difference between bodily sinkage and a change of trim?
Bodily sinkage is the parallel increase of draft when a weight is added at the center of flotation; a change of trim is the rotation about the center of flotation when the weight is not there.
A weight added anywhere causes both. The sinkage is w / TPC and the same at both ends. The change of trim is w d / MCTC and increases the draft at one end and decreases it at the other.
How do you find the new drafts after loading a weight away from the center of flotation?
Add the bodily sinkage to both drafts, then share the change of trim between the ends in proportion to their distances from the center of flotation.
For 200 t loaded 50 m forward of the center of flotation of the example ship, the sinkage is 6.38 cm and the change of trim is 37.64 cm by the head. The forward draft increases by 25.9 cm and the aft draft decreases by 11.7 cm.
How do you calculate list from a weight moved across the ship?
Divide the transverse moment by the displacement to get the shift of the center of gravity, then divide by GM: tan θ = w d / (Δ GM).
A 400 t weight moved 6 m across a ship of 22,140 t with GM 1.0 m moves G by 0.108 m and gives a list of 6.19 degrees. The formula holds only at small angles and uses GM after the free surface correction.
How do you calculate list from a weight loaded off the centerline?
Treat the loading as two steps: load the weight on the centerline, which changes the displacement, KG and GM, then move it out to its final position.
The list is tan θ = w y / ((Δ + w) GM1), where GM1 is the metacentric height after loading. For 150 t loaded 2 m above the keel and 8 m from the centerline of the example ship, the list is 2.94 degrees.
How much ballast corrects a list?
The ballast moment equals the listing moment, in the opposite direction.
A list caused by 2,400 t m to starboard needs 2,400 t m to port, for example 120 t transferred between wing tanks whose centers are 20 m apart. The free surface of the tanks while they are slack reduces GM during the transfer, so the list changes as it is corrected.
Why does the same weight shift give a larger list in a tender ship?
The list angle is inversely proportional to GM at small angles, because tan θ = GG1 / GM.
Halving GM from 1.0 m to 0.5 m in the example ship increases the small-angle list from the same 2,400 t m shift from 6.2 degrees to 12.2 degrees. The wall-sided value at GM 0.5 m is 10.3 degrees. A tender ship is a ship with small GM.
Does free surface increase a list?
Yes: free surface reduces the effective GM, and the list from a given transverse moment depends on that reduced GM.
The list formula uses GM corrected for free surface effect, as the 2008 IS Code requires for all loading conditions (Part A 2.1.2). Slack tanks also let liquid move to the low side, so the free surface correction acts against the ship at every angle of list.
When does the small-angle list formula stop being valid?
The small-angle formula tan θ = w d / (Δ GM) assumes that the metacenter does not move as the ship heels, which holds only at small angles.
In the example ship at GM 1.0 m the formula is within 0.2 degrees at a 6 degree list. At GM 0.3 m and the same moment it gives 19.9 degrees where the wall-sided formula gives 13.2 degrees.
What does the wall-sided formula add?
The wall-sided formula adds the rise of the metacenter with heel: GZ = sin θ (GM + BM tan² θ / 2).
It is exact for a section with vertical sides at the waterline, until the deck edge immerses or the bilge emerges. Beyond that angle the list comes from the cross curves of stability.
How do I tell a list from a loll?
A list has a known cause: a weight off the centerline, and the ship rests at one angle to one side.
A loll has no off-center weight to explain it, the ship is unstable upright, and it rests at the same angle to either side. The test is the loading record: a list with no transverse change of weight to explain it points to a loss of GM. The ship then needs a stability check before any weight is moved.
What heel does the Grain Code allow after a grain shift?
The International Grain Code, resolution MSC.23(59), section A 7.1, limits the angle of heel from the assumed grain shift to 12 degrees, or the angle at which the deck edge immerses if less, for ships built on or after 1 January 1994.
The same section requires a residual area of at least 0.075 meter radians and an initial GM of at least 0.30 m after the free surface correction.
Does the 2008 IS Code set a maximum list for a ship in port?
No: the 2008 IS Code limits heel for named causes, not a general list for an intact ship in port.
Part A 3.1.1 limits heel from passenger crowding to 10 degrees, Part A 3.1.2 heel from turning to 10 degrees, and Part A 2.3.1.2 heel under steady wind to 16 degrees or 80 per cent of the deck-edge angle. Port and cargo operations set their own working limits, for example the limits on a crane or a cargo system datasheet.
What ballast draft and trim does MARPOL Annex I Regulation 18 set for oil tankers?
MARPOL Annex I Regulation 18.2 sets the capacity of the segregated ballast tanks, not a draft the tanker must always float at.
The capacity must be enough for the ship in any ballast condition to reach a moulded draft amidships of at least 2.0 + 0.02L meters, a trim by the stern of not more than 0.015L and full propeller immersion. Regulation 18 applies to crude oil tankers of 20,000 tonnes deadweight and above and product carriers of 30,000 tonnes deadweight and above, delivered after 1 June 1982. For L 150 m the values are 5.0 m and 2.25 m.
When must the stability information show the effect of trim?
SOLAS regulation II-1/5-1.3 requires the stability information to show the influence of various trims where the operational trim range exceeds plus or minus 0.5 per cent of the subdivision length Ls.
The 2008 IS Code, Part A 2.1.7, requires minimum GM or maximum KG limiting curves to extend over the full range of operational trims, unless the Administration agrees that trim effects are not significant.
What is the difference between the stability booklet and the loading manual?
The stability booklet covers stability and the loading manual covers hull girder strength.
The 2008 IS Code, Part A 2.1.6, requires a stability booklet approved by the Administration. Load Line Regulation 10 and IACS UR S1 cover the loading information that keeps still-water bending moments and shear forces within limits. Both documents use the same drafts and trim.
What does trimming mean in the IMSBC Code?
In the IMSBC Code, trimming means levelling a bulk cargo inside a cargo space, partly or totally (1.7.28).
It is not the longitudinal trim of the ship. Section 5.1.1 requires cargoes to be trimmed reasonably level as necessary, to minimize the risk of cargo shift and of air entering the cargo. Section 5.1.2 adds trimming to spread the load on the tank top.
What did trim have to do with the Hoegh Osaka accident?
MAIB Report 6/2016 concluded that the ship’s bow trim of about 0.6 m ‘would have been detrimental to manoeuvring, and probably contributed to the high rate of turn’.
Conclusion 1 was that the ship had inadequate residual stability for the Bramble Bank turn at 12 knots on 3 January 2015. The estimated condition gave GM 1.29 m against a required minimum of 1.34 m.
How much list is acceptable during the inclining test?
The 2008 IS Code, Part B 8.2.2.7, accepts up to one-half degree of list with the inclining weights in their initial position.
The ship should be as upright as possible, and the actual trim and keel deflection should be taken into account in the hydrostatic data where practical.
What triggers a new inclining test?
SOLAS regulation II-1/5.5 requires a lightweight survey of every passenger ship at intervals not exceeding five years.
The ship is re-inclined where a deviation from the lightship displacement exceeding 2 per cent, or of the longitudinal center of gravity exceeding 1 per cent of Ls, is found or anticipated. Under II-1/5.4, a ship altered in a way that changes its stability is re-inclined when the anticipated deviations exceed those values. A change in the lightship LCG changes the trim in every loading condition in the booklet.
No question matches. Try a shorter or different word.
Sources
- IMO Resolution MSC.267(85). International Code on Intact Stability, 2008 imo.org
- IMO Resolution MSC.216(82). Amendments to SOLAS 1974, revised chapter II-1 imo.org
- IMO Resolution MEPC.117(52). Revised MARPOL Annex I imo.org
- IMO Resolution MSC.143(77). Amendments to the Protocol of 1988 relating to the International Convention on Load Lines imo.org
- IMO Resolution MSC.23(59). International Code for the Safe Carriage of Grain in Bulk imo.org
- IMO Resolution MSC.268(85). International Maritime Solid Bulk Cargoes Code imo.org
- IACS UR S1 Rev.7 (May 2010). Requirements for Loading Conditions, Loading Manuals and Loading Instruments iacs.org.uk
- MAIB Report 6/2016. Listing, flooding and grounding of Hoegh Osaka, Bramble Bank, 3 January 2015 assets.publishing.service.gov.uk
- MAIB Report 18/2009. Riverdance, Shell Flats, Cleveleys, 31 January 2008 assets.publishing.service.gov.uk
- JAIC Final report on MV ESTONIA (December 1997), Part 3. Chapters 15 to 21, failure analysis, findings and conclusions shk.se